Y!'s developed extensive security features based on the 0.20 branch. The 0.20 versions of the individual patches appear in Jira, but these have not been committed to any branch in Apache's SVN. Y! has periodically pushed out versions of these as Yahoo!'s Distribution of Hadoop at github, and Cloudera is likely to make a 0.20-based distribution including these as well.

Shouldn't we commit these all to some 0.20-based branch at Apache? I'd earlier (on common-dev) suggested we might start a 1.0 branch based on 0.20, then add a 1.1 branch with the security patches. If that were done, the 0.21 release could perhaps instead be called 1.2. But, regardless of the naming, it would be good to have the 0.20 versions of all of the security patches committed to a branch at Apache so that we can make a release that includes them, patches can be targeted against this branch, etc.

What do others think?

Doug

Reply via email to