On Mon, 2004-07-26 at 22:43, Scherler, Thorsten wrote: > Rolf Kulemann wrote: > > Hello Incubators, > > > > since the Lenya community is confronted with being graduated to a TLP > > and thus with setting up a resolution for the ASF Board (did I used the > > right terms?), I wonder if it is better to do a silent vote for the > > future Apache Lenya PMC Chair. > > > > I followed some discussions on cocoon-pmc@ and I think this is a good > > idea. > > > > The main reason I see is, that such votes should not end up in a > > popularity contest. > > > > I saw some ASF Board minutes from year 2002 where it was discussed to > > use STV as a voting system. I could not find any detailed information > > about such a system and its usage within the ASF. > > > > Does a silent voting system exists somewhere, which we could use for > > sensitive votes or do u think silent voting is not needed? > > > > I think that was used from the guys of forrest. There just added the > draft to the cvs and let the committer edit it. That would be > semi-silent but I reckon will do the job. > > I will add the draft into CVS-HEAD as proposal.txt so all committer can > vote. > > WDYT?
-1, because that would not solve the problem I mentioned, if it there is a problem at all. I think we do a normal vote on ppmc. Lets make our experience. I can understand both opinions, Noel's and Stefano's. The last cocoon pmc vote was a bit ridiculous in the beginning. However we should wait for the SUMMARY on [EMAIL PROTECTED] befdore we vote a PMC Chair or whatever. Fact is we have to do it sometime if we want to become TLP. IMHO, we do not need a chair for our community and the development process, but we need one for the ASF, so lets do it. -- Rolf Kulemann --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
