On 4/20/06, Noel J. Bergman <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > -1 > > Bill Stoddard is correct in his understanding of > http://incubator.apache.org/incubation/Incubation_Policy.html#Releases. The > fact that other people have voted +1 without verifying that the release > adheres to Incubator policy is a bit disturbing, but that's why we have > multiple sets of eyes on these things. > > I really don't understand why it has been so hard for ActiveMQ and > ServiceMix to follow Incubator policy, particularly after James acknowledged > precisely what needs to be done, and said that the issues would be corrected > for the next ActiveMQ candidate.
FWIW now that the ActiveMQ build is fixed it should never again fail these incubator release requirements - though it did take quite a few attempts to get there. This is the first attempt at a milestone release of ServiceMix so its hardly surprising that one little thing was missed. Right now there's a disclaimer in the README and the maven POM and artifacts clearly use 'incubator-servicemix'. The missing piece (which is my bad, I should have fixed it when I fixed ActiveMQ) is that the maven project which creates the assembly does not include 'incubator-' in the filenames of the generated zips/tarballs - though its clearly visible in the directory name in which those tarballs are placed together with the maven POMs. FWIW I use maven for pretty much all projects I work on and use; so mentally when I see a maven build I read the project name from the groupID/artifactID of where the distro is in the maven repo - e.g. looking at the URL Guillaume posted I read 'incubator-servicemix' version '3.0-M1'. I suspect many other folks do the same - which could be why noone noticed the need for another explicit 'incubator-' in there for good measure. I've patched the build so this issue should be resolved now (it was servicemix-assembly/project.xml). Guillaume do you want to cut another build of 3.0-M1? Then AFAIK we should have the ServiceMix build process complying totally with the current incubator release guidelines. -- James ------- http://radio.weblogs.com/0112098/ --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
