On Sat, Dec 4, 2010 at 8:55 AM, Ralph Goers <ralph.go...@dslextreme.com>wrote:
> > On Dec 4, 2010, at 8:50 AM, Ralph Goers wrote: > > > > > On Dec 4, 2010, at 4:39 AM, Ian Boston wrote: > > > >> > >> On 4 Dec 2010, at 01:50, Tad Glines wrote: > >> > >>> 2010/12/3 Dan Peterson <dpeter...@google.com> > >>> The 18 binding votes: > >>> Andrus Adamchik, Ant Elder, Bernd Fondermann, Bertrand Delacretaz, > Chris A. Mattmann, Christian Grobmeier, Davanum Srinivas, Dave Johnson, Doug > Cutting, Emmanuel Lecharny, Jim Jagielski, Kevan Miller, Luciano Resende, > Mark Struberg, Michael McCandless, Ralph Goers, Tim Williams, and Upayavira > >>> > >>> The 8 non-IMPC members who are ASF members: > >>> Ate Douma, Brett Porter, Leif Hedstrom, Marcel Offermans, Niklas > Gustavsson, Richard Hall, Santiago Gala, and Vincent Siveton > >>> > >>> Wow! Did we set some sort of record? I didn't realize that so many ASF > people had voted. > >> > >> Congrats.... lots of support from all corners. > >> > >> Just incase it is a record, long may it stand.... but it may be even > more than that, I see Paul Lindner name in the list of non members, I > thought as Shindig PMC Chair he was a member, with me that makes 10, there > may be others. ? (well done, I thought it was painful counting just ten on a > release votes) > > > > PMC chairs are not automatically ASF members. The easy way to tell is to > look at http://people.apache.org/committer-index.html. If the person's > name is in bold then they are an ASF member. It appears Paul is not. > > However, I do see Isabel Drost, who is a member, in the list. So your > assertion that there are probably more is correct. > > Ian, Isabel (and anyone else I missed), sorry about that -- I manually compared the list of voters against http://apache.org/foundation/members.html (and http://incubator.apache.org/whoweare.html ) Ralph, your list looks more up to date it seems. To avoid confusion in the future, I imagine the ASF members page I found could be filled in from the same list as the committer-index page? One question related to incubator policy: are ASF member votes meant to be officially binding for incubator acceptance or is it explicitly restricted to the IPMC? Paul and I couldn't find a clear answer to that. There is a mention that the IPMC is responsible for incubator projects, so I could see it both ways. It wasn't an issue in this case, just wondering what the policy is for any future potential incubator projects. -Dan
