Hi,

-1 (binding), but see below

I checked:
   • incubating in name
   • signature and hash are good
   • DISCLAIMER-WIP exists
   • LICENSE and NOTICE are fine
   • no unexpected binary files
   • all source files have ASF headers one

However, the issue I raised on RC1 is still there. Issue #3268 shows that 36% 
of the surviving lines were written before the repository had any license, and 
two of the larger contributors from that period (27,449 lines) have no ICLA on 
file that I can find. UncertaintyDeterminesYou4ndMe (27,449 lines) have no ICLA 
on file that I can find, but mapping GitHub names is difficult. I notice that 
it is claimed in that issue, "The SGA is an incubation setup item, not a 
release item” and similar AI-generated statements; this is not correct. The 
release policy is clear: we can’t release stuff we don't have permission to.[2].

If that ICLA is in place, or we have an SGA covering them, or the mentor's 
record on some other basis, that's fine, and I withdraw my -1 vote. I notice 
they are still active in the project; has anyone asked them for an ICLA?

The nightly builds are also still public. There are 30 "Maka Desktop Nightly" 
GitHub prereleases, the latest from yesterday, and npm maka-agent has a nightly 
tag pointing at 0.2.0-dev.62. None of them has the incubation disclaimer. This 
doesn't affect the source release, but it contradicts release policy [1] and 
needs to be sorted out.

Kind regards,
Justin

1. https://www.apache.org/legal/release-policy.html#publication
2. https://www.apache.org/legal/release-policy.html#licensing



---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected]
For additional commands, e-mail: [email protected]

Reply via email to