There are a couple of distinct issues here and it would be good to keep them separate. Would it be desirable for the Logging Services project to start development on a JavaScript logging framework? If so, would it be better to start from an existing code base? If so, which code base would be the best to start from?

Doing a quick search on JavaScript and Logging, I found the following links which seem to be on topic and many of them provide some some implementation code:

http://kb.mozillazine.org/JavaScript_Console
http://www.alistapart.com/articles/jslogging
http://jroller.com/page/stritti?entry=logging_in_javascript_log4js
http://log4js.sourceforge.net/
http://gleepglop.com/javascripts/logger/
http://www.decafbad.com/blog/2005/07/18/ajax_testing_and_logging
http://ajaxpatterns.org/Logging

There does seem to be a lot of interest and likely a good community could develop around LS hosted project. I'd be hesitant to pick a particular implementation to start with at this time before trying to put together a community and developing some shared vision. It may be that none of the existing frameworks aligns with the collective vision and it ends up being simpler to start from scratch than to deal with adopting an existing code base. Based on a very superficial review, it appears that all of the logging frameworks in the previous links were solo developer efforts.

I'd suggest:

Creating a [EMAIL PROTECTED] for Sandbox related discussion and SVN commits. Rearranging the sandbox as previous discussed in http:// marc.theaimsgroup.com/?l=apache-logging-general&m=112649550919155&w=2 Create a directory sandbox to collect artifacts related to a logging framework for Javascript Invite the authors of javascript frameworks listed above and others to join the discussion

Once a community is established:
Decide how to collect requirements (JIRA, Wiki, SVN, etc)
Pick a name
Pick a development strategy

Reply via email to