On 01/11/15 23:07, Michael Orlitzky wrote: > On 11/01/2015 12:44 PM, Michael Palimaka wrote: >> There's been a lot of discussion about relying on GitHub for pull >> requests and code review and such, so I have set up a Phabricator >> instance against gentoo.git to see how a free alternative might work. >> >> ... >> >> What do you think? >> > > Thanks for working on this. I personally didn't like Phabricator very > much when I used it, but I'm glad someone is trying out code review > platforms. I could live with it.
Most of the code-review platforms are cumbersome and inefficient depending on the purpose. Phab has some nice ideas (gamification is one of them), but overall I feel interacting with it less pleasant than interacting with github and gitlab (both have different defects). Personally I wouldn't mind having a gitlab setup if there is consensus in going in that direction. If we want to try to do something more simple, patchwork or plaid (from truly yours =p) might be options as well. lu