I kind ok liked both the same ... can you write one of them up on the proposal page :-) Oh here I will do it ... in general if you see a gap like this modify the page and lets move on :-) If it is something worth discussion (like this is, we can talk about it in email).
The v1_0 makes me sad - does not look like anything else in java - can we do better? (If we cannot I am good with it) Can I try an idea for you? Only track major version numbers with package names ... GML2 and GML3 are different enough that they do get there own package - org.geotools.xml.gml2 or org.geotools.geometry.gml2 - org.geotools.xml.gml3 or org.geotools.geometry.gml3 Filter 1.0 and Filter 1.1 have a different relationship one extends the other. We produce the same objects out of the bindings ... is there any way we can have them both in the same package? CQL is a different encoding for Filter ... - org.geotools.xml.filter1 or org.geotools.filter.filter1 - org.geotools.text.cql or org.geotools.filter.cql If we cannot pull this off we are stuck in compromise - nothing looks great, your second option looks better. - org.geotools.xml.filter1 - org.geotools.xml.filter1_1 - org.geotools.xml.gml2 - org.geotools.xml.gml3 I really wish the quality of the OGC specifications was more consistent - we have no problem taking the "latest" gml2 and gml3 specification (because the other two did not work). But both filter 1.0 and filter 1.1 are valid and useful. >> So what is your package naming conventions? > Are you asking now? I dont really have one. the one in the proposal is > good, but does not take versions into account. The comment i made > lists two possibilities. So yeah; I am asking now :-) Or basically "you got me - I did not do versions" - and asking you to select a possible fix before we continue. Jody >> >> Cheers, >> Jody >> >>>> We are not; can you read and comment on the proposal please. >>>> >>> >>> Sure, proposal updated with comments about packing naming structure >>> with regard to version numbers. >>>> >>>> >>>> >>> >>> >> >> >> !DSPAM:4007,45fecdc6241011194215290! >> > > ------------------------------------------------------------------------- Take Surveys. Earn Cash. Influence the Future of IT Join SourceForge.net's Techsay panel and you'll get the chance to share your opinions on IT & business topics through brief surveys-and earn cash http://www.techsay.com/default.php?page=join.php&p=sourceforge&CID=DEVDEV _______________________________________________ Geotools-devel mailing list [email protected] https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/geotools-devel
