It depends what you want. As Richard has said, flashhd and hlshd are pretty 
much equal to eachother BUT we now know that HLS is on a legacy system and 
Flash is due to be phased out at some point.

All the HLS options run at 25fps but are only supplied by Akamai who (at least 
for the time being) aren't packaging them in any useable way.

The only options on the "current system" are the HVF modes. Most of these 
though will give you a 50fps video. In the case of hvfhd, you will end up with 
a download thats 1280x720 50fps. But that 50fps frame rate will make an HD 
download about double the size of the current flashhd streams which are only 
25fps. If you want something that is roughly the same file size as the flashhd 
streams and are happy to settle for something that isn't HD resolution, you can 
use hvfsd which will give you a 960x540 50fps download. This is what iPlayer 
currently uses when you stream in HD.

> >is there a list showing which of these give what actual resolutions and -
> >where relevant - what limit there is on 'supplier'?
> 
> >What are the optimum choices here if I want 1280x720? Or is this a matter
> >of experiment?
> 
> HLSHD and FlashHD are both 1280x720 25fps
> HVFHD is 1280x720 50fps, but it probably only applies to Red Button and 
> Olympic channels.
> 
> In v2.95 best will give you HLSHD if it is available.  As far as I know if 
> HLSHD is not available it will fall back to FlashHD, as you have found.
> 
> I'll leave it to someone else to say what is provided by which CDN.

_______________________________________________
get_iplayer mailing list
get_iplayer@lists.infradead.org
http://lists.infradead.org/mailman/listinfo/get_iplayer

Reply via email to