we've got a lot of patches attached to various bug in Bugzilla, many of then 
unreviewed (currently: 77) and, for the most part, untried.
There's also a large number of patches in the needs-work state (currently: 61), 
meaning that someone has reviewed them and determined that there are changes to 
be done.

There are some efforts to get them applied, but this doesn't seem to be an 
ongoing. It isn't obvious who might be working on applying a patch, and patch 
contributors do not get much visible feedback.

I think we're not using the power of Git to its full potential here. 

We can easily have someone apply a patch to a local bug-specific branch, check 
if it looks basically correct, maybe try if it compiles (this can be difficult 
if it is intended for a different platform), and then push this branch to 
origin to make it available for testing by others, changes, fixes, ...

The goal for those branches would be to be merged/cherry-picked into the 
branches master, gimp-2-8, ... as applicable and desired, and the temporary bug 
branch could be deleted after all of its changes have become part of these 

I've done this locally for several of the attachments we currently got in 
Bugzilla, and pushed one of these branches, bug-357818, to enable someone to 
build and test it. Bug 357818 is about a change to the TWAIN plug-in, and I 
don't build on, for or run the platform it is intended for. The build test 
enabled us to spot and remove some erroneous characters that have been added 
when I had to adjust the patches to the current state of the plug-in.

Possible advantages can include nightly builds of those branches, if we think 
that some bug fix should get much user exposure before it is added to a release.

I vote for encouraging to have public branches that correspond to bugs/patches, 
and name them in an obvious way. I'm not booked to the bug-<number> naming 
scheme, but found it useful for this purpose.

Comments, opinions, suggestions? (but please try to keep the bikeshedding down)

GPG: 96A8 B38A 728A 577D 724D 60E5 F855 53EC B36D 4CDD
gimp-developer-list mailing list
List address:    gimp-developer-list@gnome.org
List membership: https://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/gimp-developer-list
List archives:   https://mail.gnome.org/archives/gimp-developer-list

Reply via email to