Just curious, is there a reason that PNG is a bad choice for this?
 
Lossless compression seems like it'd be a great advantage and it isn't a fly by night file format.

 
On 10/25/06, Tom Purl <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
Thanks Markus and Chris for the advice!

I checked out the Wikipedia page on the JPEG format, and found this
excellent link on image degradation when you edit a jpeg:

* http://www.jmg-galleries.com/articles/jpeg_compression.html

It appears that at the very least, I should first convert my image into
a TIFF before I edit the image.

>> * Fidelity - The higher the better.  I would like the images to be of
>> a high enough quality where they could be easily used to create a
>> clear 8 x 10.  I realize that other factors affect the clearness of a
>> large image (such as film speed and such).  File size isn't a factor.

It looks like both TIFF's and JPEG's will work equally well here, as
long as I convert the image to a different format (like TIFF or XCF)
*before* I edit it.

>> * Compatibility - I would like the freedom of being able to send my
>> images to multiple developing companies and have them all be able to
>> use the image.  What's a good standard format that most "real"
>> developing companies accept?

I'm pretty sure that my local Work Camera will print photos from a TIFF,
and I'm pretty sure that Flickr will do it too.  I just tried uploading
a TIFF to Snapfish, however, and it was rejected.  Thank goodness it's a
trivial task to convert it to a JPEG using ImageMagick.

>> * Bitrot - I would like to use a format that will probably be around
>> for a while.  I know that no format is completely future-proof, but I
>> don't want to convert these images more than once every couple of
>> decades if possible.

Both formats seem equally well-suited in this regard.

> Markus Kamp said:
>
> Using none of the features supported by non-ancient versions of
> Photoshop like i.e. multi layers and omitting any kind of compression
> you should be fine for the forseeable future.

Thanks for the tips!  If I start working with layers or anything like
that, I'll be sure to save the file as a Gimp XCF.

_______________________________________________
Gimp-user mailing list
Gimp-user@lists.XCF.Berkeley.EDU
https://lists.XCF.Berkeley.EDU/mailman/listinfo/gimp-user

_______________________________________________
Gimp-user mailing list
Gimp-user@lists.XCF.Berkeley.EDU
https://lists.XCF.Berkeley.EDU/mailman/listinfo/gimp-user

Reply via email to