Ok, so the issue is that open source software might contain some sort of
back door. I guess you could tell your bosses the following:
* Every bank on earth uses open source software, whether it's openssh,
bind, sendmail, Linux, ant, junit, apache, etc.
* Every fortune 500 company in the world (many of which have *very*
stringent security requirements) also use the above-mentioned open
* Every large government institution on earth uses this open source
So yes, while it is possible that some back-door has been written into
an open-source program, it's highly unlikely, especially for large,
well-respected projects like Gimp.
> That is exactly the type of resistance that I am expecting. Certain
> bodies will trust Micorsoft / Adobe etc because they never cause
> problems (ahem!) I think the fear is that the because the source code
> is open it could be tinkered with to allow a backdoor to do...
> Would have thought that I'm not the first person to have met this kind
> of objection and was just wondering if / how others had dealt with it.
> Would be a shame to capitulate and have to use Adobe stuff.
> The work that I am planning to do involves running creative
> educational projects using the GIMP.
> Simon Davis - IT in the Community
> 01904 634748 - http://www.futureprospects.org.uk/
> 24 Swingate
> YO1 8AZ
> ----- Message from [EMAIL PROTECTED] ---------
> Date: Thu, 26 Oct 2006 16:06:45 -0700
> From: jim feldman <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
> Reply-To: jim feldman <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
> Subject: Re: [Gimp-user] GIMP used in prisons / secure institutions
> To: Simon Davis <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
> Cc: gimp-user@lists.XCF.Berkeley.EDU
>> Draw a picture of a "shiv"?
>> I can't imagine GIMP being a problem. That being said, it's linked to
>> libraries that have occasionally had security issues. Both closed and
>> open source rendering libraries have at various times suffered from
>> buffer overflows.
>> I tend to see resistance to FOSS solutions with these inane arguments
>> that force you to prove a negative. "GIMP (or whatever) could start a
>> nuclear war, can you prove it won't?". I say, then lets make that a
>> testing prerequisite for any app, including the one you want to use.
>> Simon Davis wrote:
>>> Does anyone have any experience / anecdotal evidence of using the
>>> GIMP in prisons or situations where security was of paramount
>>> importance. Coming accross resistance and would like to be able to
>>> point to precedent.
>>> Thanks a lot,
> ----- End message from [EMAIL PROTECTED] -----
> This email is confidential and solely intended for the recipient(s) to
> it is addressed. If you have received this mail in error, please reply to
> the sender of this email advising this error. The contents of any email
> from any employee of Future Prospects does not necessarily reflect the
> opinion of the company.
> Gimp-user mailing list
Gimp-user mailing list