[ 
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/GIRAPH-157?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:comment-tabpanel&focusedCommentId=13232835#comment-13232835
 ] 

Eli Reisman commented on GIRAPH-157:
------------------------------------

Hi Sebastian,

Yes I make no claims its in polynomial time or a perfect algorithm. It does 
seem to pass all the test graphs i put it too, but they are small. I would like 
to test it on a larger graph but I need to generate or find one that I have a 
worked out coloring for. Even in the small tests, I had to work out colorings 
to make sure the one it chose was a "real" choice and I had to "confirm" on 
wikipedia that the one it found was also a minimal coloring for that graph.

The algorithm just says, everyone starts with no color. Hardcoded (for now) 
SOURCE_VERTEX_ID vertex is lucky guy, chooses FIRST_COLOR and messages others.

>From here on we do supersteps until everyone votes to halt. On each superstep, 
>messages are passed to a vertex if one of its neighbors changes color. Each 
>vertex is keeping track of a reference count of how many neighbors occupy 
>which colors. Any round where messages come in, we end up checking to see if 
>we need to change color. Any round where a message contains a color conflict 
>with us, we oblige by choosing a new color. Choosing a new color always 
>consists of looking for the lowest unoccupied color the neighbors aren't 
>currently occupying. If we end up choosing a new color and it doesn't end up 
>beign the color we already are, then we always message all neighbors regarding 
>our old color (to remove a ref count) and our new one (to add a ref count and 
>recalc their color if need be).

The trick is when you get conflicting color messages directly with your own 
color. As far as I could figure, this should only happen when you and one or 
more of your neighbors chose the same color at the same time (the last 
superstep) and in this case, I let the one with the lowest vertexId break the 
tie and keep the color. This is arbitrary, but seems to work as these ties must 
be broken and since everyone tries to choose a new color targeting the lowest 
color available according to their own reference counts, these conflicts tend 
to settle out correctly in the end (so far!). One possible optimization (or 
not?) involves letting the conflict count (a count of how many of the current 
neighbors I am in simultaneous color conflict with who have a higher (weaker) 
vertexID than the current vertex) help me guess at my next color choice. this 
should reduce the number of supersteps required to resolve a worst-case N-way 
conflict (which i believe is currently about N supersteps).

I am speaking of course of an isolated conflict. I do have the sneaking 
suspicion that given a graph that is still simple, undirected, and connected 
(thats all i made promises for!) of sufficient size and complexity, it might be 
possible to tangle this thing up in some feedback loop somehow? Further, I 
would suspect that this ends up being some sort of heuristic close-guess at a 
minimal color in some complex situations too. 

So, I'm sure its not super fast and I'm not at all sure it works at scale, but 
it does seem fairly simple and it seems to work so far. Does someone know some 
slicker algorithms that we can convert to a "think like a vertex" paradigm? To 
be clear, this algorithm only colors vertices too -- I don't know how to think 
like an edge yet at all!

Thanks, I welcome the feedback

Eli

                
> Vertex to perform graph coloring on simple, connected, undirected graphs and 
> related test.
> ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
>
>                 Key: GIRAPH-157
>                 URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/GIRAPH-157
>             Project: Giraph
>          Issue Type: Test
>          Components: examples, test
>    Affects Versions: 0.2.0
>            Reporter: Eli Reisman
>            Assignee: Eli Reisman
>            Priority: Trivial
>              Labels: newbie
>         Attachments: GIRAPH-157.patch
>
>
> Hi. I am attempting to learn the Hadoop and Giraph codebases and wanted to 
> write a simple client application for Giraph to help me learn the ins and 
> outs of it. This is a simple unit test and vertex modeled after the 
> ConnectedComponentsVertex and related test. The vertex test runs whenever you 
> run the "mvn test" or "mvn verify" suite of tests. When finished processing, 
> each vertex will have an integer value that is its color.
> This is a pretty simple implementation, and although I have tested it on a 
> number of small graphs of varied trickiness and it seems to rapidly arrive at 
> a minimal coloring, its hard (for me at least) to guess which possible 
> coloring it will arrive at and I have no idea how it will do on really big 
> graphs yet without finding some more pre-colored larger test graphs to try it 
> on. Ideas anyone?
> Anyway, it was fun to put this together, and I'd be happy to improve it or 
> receive some help or advice to further the cause. Thanks again, I am hoping 
> this will be the first of many (hopefully more useful) contributions!
> Eli

--
This message is automatically generated by JIRA.
If you think it was sent incorrectly, please contact your JIRA administrators: 
https://issues.apache.org/jira/secure/ContactAdministrators!default.jspa
For more information on JIRA, see: http://www.atlassian.com/software/jira

        

Reply via email to