Derrick Stolee <sto...@gmail.com> writes:

> +struct packed_oid_list {
> +     struct object_id **list;
> +     int nr;
> +     int alloc;
> +};

What is the typical access pattern for this data structure?  If it
is pretty much "allocate and grow as we find more", then a dynamic
array of struct (rather than a dynamic array of pointers to struct)
would be a lot more appropriate.  IOW

        struct packed_oid_list {
                struct object_id *list;
                int nr, alloc;
        };

The version in the posted patch has to pay malloc overhead plus an
extra pointer for each object id in the list; unless you often
replace elements in the list randomly and/or you borrow object ID
field in other existing data structure whose lifetime is longer than
this list by pointing at it, I do not see how the extra indirection
is worth it.


Reply via email to