Hi, I'm currently struggeling with a strage behaviour of git-svn: After git-svn-cloning a given repository (see attachment) in some cases the git blame differs from the svn blame. The history looks like after a merge all affected files have been added from scratch at this revision.
The behaviour can be observed using at least the following versions of git: 184.108.40.206 220.127.116.11 1.8.2.GIT Given: * svn-repository, svn-server 1.6.11, apache2 module via WEB DAV * repository like the one attached: * standard svn layout * branch ^/branches/feature1 copied from ^/trunk * changes made and files added on project1/branches/feature1 by 'testuser1' * branch ^/branches/rc-1.0 copied from ^/trunk on revX by 'mergeuser' * ^/branches/feature1 merged to ^/trunk on revY by 'mergeuser' * ^/branches/rc-1.0 merged back to trunk revZ by 'mergeuser' Action: git svn clone -s <repo-url> git blame <some_file_modified_on-feature1> Observed behaviour: Changes being made on project1/branches/feature1 being associated to 'mergeuser' who integrated feature1 but not implemented on that branch. > $ git blame src/file2.txt > 9846ece6 (mergeuser 2013-04-11 14:31:21 +0000 1) content2-1 > 9846ece6 (mergeuser 2013-04-11 14:31:21 +0000 2) content2-2 > 9846ece6 (mergeuser 2013-04-11 14:31:21 +0000 3) content2-3 Action: svn blame <repo-url>/trunk/<some_file_modified_on-feature1> Observed behaviour: Changes are correctly associated to user1 > $ svn blame src/file2.txt > 4 testuser1 content2-1 > 4 testuser1 content2-2 > 4 testuser1 content2-3 I don't know yet which steps are really needed to re-create a repository with this behaviour. My guess is that adding files together with a merge (see r6 in the attached repository) has something to do with it. Can you tell me whether this is a known issue or if there's a work around for this? Unfortunately I'm not very into perl so I can't solve this on my own. Please let me know if you need additional information. Thanks Frans