From: "Marc Branchaud" <>
Sent: Friday, May 02, 2014 4:37 PM
(Apologies for not CCing all the folks who've participated in the "Pull is Evil" thread -- I couldn't find a good branch of that thread for this message.)

OK, so maybe "git pull" is just Mostly Evil. People seem to have found many
different ways to make it work for them.

But in reality "git pull" has become a chimera that confuses a large number of new users, and that experienced users either avoid entirely or customize
to give them a convenient shorthand for working in their particular
environment.  As a tool for new git users, it just doesn't seem to be
achieving its goals.

I think the git project as a whole would benefit if it started to treat "git pull" as an advanced command, in the sense that it needs to be configured by
an experienced user in order to make it correctly follow a project's
workflow. Once it's configured properly, "git pull" is a powerful tool that gives users an easy way to do complex things. In that sense, it may be appropriate for a project to tailor "git pull" as it likes, then teach its
own users to use the command.

However, when it comes to teaching people how to use git qua git, "git pull"
should be the last thing they learn about, because it's only after you
understand various basic git concepts that you can configure "git pull" to do
the right thing.

To that end, I suggest that pull's default behaviour should be to do
*nothing*. It should just print out a message to the effect that it hasn't been configured, and that the user should run "git help pull" for guidance.

I tend to agree.
The hard part is making sure folk have enough prior learning to make a choice that their will fit their real needs.

It'll take quite a bit of time, but I think that if we change our attitude towards "git pull" and take this unconfigured-by-default approach, then in a
few years the entire git ecosystem will be in a better place.


To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe git" in
the body of a message to
More majordomo info at

Reply via email to