Kalpana-chavhan opened a new pull request, #37210:
URL: https://github.com/apache/beam/pull/37210
### Description
This PR improves the Developer Experience (DX) when a user-defined function
(UDF) or transform fails to serialize during pipeline construction. Currently,
users are presented with a generic `PicklingError` or `AttributeError` from the
internal pickler, which can be opaque to developers new to distributed
processing.
The change wraps these failures in a descriptive `RuntimeError` that
identifies the specific failing function and provides a clear, actionable
troubleshooting guide directly in the console.
### Proposed Changes
- Modified `sdks/python/apache_beam/transforms/ptransform.py` to intercept
serialization errors during the initialization of transforms (e.g., `beam.Map`,
`beam.FlatMap`).
- Added a specialized test case in`
sdks/python/apache_beam/transforms/ptransform_test.py` to ensure the improved
message format is raised and contains the correct troubleshooting steps.
### Comparison of Error Messages
#### Before (Generic Traceback)
The previous error provided a low-level traceback that left developers
guessing why their code failed to initialize.
```
RuntimeError: Unable to pickle fn <function <lambda> at 0x7f...>:
can't pickle _io.TextIOWrapper objects
```
#### After (With Troubleshooting Guide)
The new error message identifies the SDK context and provides actionable
steps to resolve the issue without requiring the user to search the
documentation.
```
[Apache Beam SDK] Serialization Failure: The function '<function <lambda> at
0x7f...>'
could not be serialized.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Apache Beam ships your code to remote workers. This requires your
functions and their captured variables to be 'picklable'.
Common Solutions:
1. Use a named function defined at the module level instead of a lambda.
2. Ensure all variables captured in the closure are serializable.
3. If you're using a complex object (like a DB client or ML model),
initialize it inside a DoFn.setup() method rather than the constructor.
Reference:
https://beam.apache.org/documentation/programming-guide/#serialization
----------------------------------------------------------------------
```
### Testing Accomplished
- Unit Test Added: Added test_ptransform_serialization_error_message to
`ptransform_test.py`.
- Verification: Confirmed that the test correctly identifies the custom
error string when a non-serializable object (like a file handle) is captured in
a lambda.
- Regression Check: Ran the full suite for `ptransform_test.py` to ensure no
impact on valid transform initializations.
### Impact
- Developer Experience: Significantly reduces debugging time for common
"gotchas" in the Python SDK.
- Onboarding: Helps new Beam users understand the requirement for picklable
functions early in their development cycle.
- Performance: No impact on pipeline execution speed; this check only occurs
during the pipeline construction/graph-building phase.
--
This is an automated message from the Apache Git Service.
To respond to the message, please log on to GitHub and use the
URL above to go to the specific comment.
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected]
For queries about this service, please contact Infrastructure at:
[email protected]
