DarkWanderer commented on PR #23851:
URL: https://github.com/apache/datafusion/pull/23851#issuecomment-6988521796

   @adriangb this change is specifically in row group filter machinery, so I 
don't see a way to put it into `arrow-rs`. I have dug more and managed to 
squeeze more performance - by cross-checking the `IN` and `NOT IN` against the 
`min`/`max` statistics and avoiding the extra fetch where it would not be 
useful - but regressions are still visible in many places. 
   
   While testing, I found that my change in `arrow-rs` is not backward 
compatible with ClickBench data. 
[Fix](https://github.com/apache/arrow-rs/pull/12321/changes).
   
   Below is Claude-generated benchmark report with the locally applied patch. 
`needle` is an illustrative test case over ClickBench data - which demonstrates 
the win the most. Simulated S3 results are primarily driven by noise in the 
random latency.
   
   ____________________________________
   
   Each query runs with 
`datafusion.execution.parquet.dictionary_filter_on_read` off, then on, in fresh 
`dfbench` processes on the same VM. Times are medians of the timed iterations; 
the first iteration of each process is dropped. Change is on / off − 1, so 
negative is faster. Every query returns the same number of rows in both modes.
   
   | | |
   |---|---|
   | Code | this PR at `28dceb388`, with arrow-rs 60.1.0 plus a fix that 
accepts `PLAIN_DICTIONARY` dictionary pages (the ClickBench files use them) |
   | Machine | GCP `c2d-standard-8` Spot VM (AMD EPYC 7B13, 8 vCPUs, 32 GB); 
`target_partitions` = 8 |
   | Local | data on the VM's disk; 5 iterations per process |
   | Simulated S3 | `dfbench --simulate-latency`: GET first-byte latency 19–230 
ms, 90 MB/s per connection, 128 connections; 4 iterations per process |
   | Rounds | 3 off/on pairs per query for TPC-H, TPC-DS and needle on 
simulated S3, and for needle locally; 1 otherwise |
   | Datasets | TPC-H SF1, TPC-DS SF1, IMDB, ClickBench `hits_partitioned` (100 
files) |
   
   ## Totals
   
   | Suite | Local | Simulated S3 |
   |---|---:|---:|
   | TPC-H | +0.2% | +6.8% |
   | TPC-DS | +0.6% | +2.8% |
   | IMDB (Join Order Benchmark) | +1.3% | +4.9% |
   | ClickBench | −0.9% | −0.8% |
   | ClickBench with filter pushdown | −0.7% | −0.9% |
   | ClickBench needle queries | −56.5% | −51.1% |
   | ClickBench needle queries with filter pushdown | −4.7% | −8.8% |
   
   ## Per query
   
   <details>
   <summary><b>TPC-H</b>: local +0.2% overall, no query moves by 10% or more; 
simulated S3 +6.8%: Q19 +60%, Q11 +36%, five more +11% to +18%</summary>
   
   **Local** (4 timed samples per query and mode)
   
   | Query | Off (ms) | On (ms) | Change |
   |---|---:|---:|---:|
   | Q1 | 116.9 | 117.0 | +0.1% |
   | Q2 | 31.6 | 31.3 | −1.2% |
   | Q3 | 70.2 | 70.9 | +1.0% |
   | Q4 | 40.4 | 39.6 | −2.0% |
   | Q5 | 81.9 | 80.5 | −1.7% |
   | Q6 | 36.1 | 36.2 | +0.4% |
   | Q7 | 110.6 | 109.9 | −0.6% |
   | Q8 | 93.2 | 93.6 | +0.5% |
   | Q9 | 124.6 | 124.3 | −0.2% |
   | Q10 | 88.0 | 89.8 | +2.0% |
   | Q11 | 24.9 | 24.5 | −1.5% |
   | Q12 | 45.3 | 48.5 | +7.2% |
   | Q13 | 82.8 | 82.3 | −0.6% |
   | Q14 | 55.8 | 54.4 | −2.5% |
   | Q15 | 82.6 | 84.8 | +2.7% |
   | Q16 | 23.2 | 23.6 | +1.8% |
   | Q17 | 165.3 | 161.7 | −2.1% |
   | Q18 | 111.7 | 106.5 | −4.7% |
   | Q19 | 78.0 | 80.3 | +2.9% |
   | Q20 | 72.3 | 73.6 | +1.8% |
   | Q21 | 132.5 | 136.3 | +2.9% |
   | Q22 | 23.5 | 24.8 | +5.4% |
   | **Total** | **1691.3** | **1694.4** | **+0.2%** |
   
   **Simulated S3** (9 timed samples per query and mode)
   
   | Query | Off (ms) | On (ms) | Change |
   |---|---:|---:|---:|
   | Q1 | 776.9 | 802.6 | +3.3% |
   | Q2 | 974.0 | 874.4 | −10.2% |
   | Q3 | 1316.4 | 1382.5 | +5.0% |
   | Q4 | 1228.9 | 1182.2 | −3.8% |
   | Q5 | 1289.9 | 1310.4 | +1.6% |
   | Q6 | 754.9 | 692.2 | −8.3% |
   | Q7 | 1266.7 | 1492.1 | +17.8% |
   | Q8 | 1424.1 | 1606.9 | +12.8% |
   | Q9 | 1545.4 | 1676.5 | +8.5% |
   | Q10 | 1312.9 | 1543.2 | +17.5% |
   | Q11 | 802.5 | 1093.7 | +36.3% |
   | Q12 | 1263.0 | 1462.4 | +15.8% |
   | Q13 | 555.1 | 562.4 | +1.3% |
   | Q14 | 1046.2 | 1006.1 | −3.8% |
   | Q15 | 1635.2 | 1560.8 | −4.6% |
   | Q16 | 484.1 | 514.6 | +6.3% |
   | Q17 | 1628.1 | 1809.8 | +11.2% |
   | Q18 | 1743.5 | 1738.6 | −0.3% |
   | Q19 | 962.5 | 1542.5 | +60.3% |
   | Q20 | 1225.6 | 1188.0 | −3.1% |
   | Q21 | 2802.2 | 2866.9 | +2.3% |
   | Q22 | 615.5 | 569.0 | −7.6% |
   | **Total** | **26653.6** | **28478.0** | **+6.8%** |
   
   </details>
   
   <details>
   <summary><b>TPC-DS</b>: local +0.6% overall, short queries vary up to ±25% 
either way; simulated S3 +2.8%: Q41 +148%, Q26 +74%, Q37 +70%, 27 more +10% to 
+51%, 17 queries −10% to −27%</summary>
   
   **Local** (4 timed samples per query and mode)
   
   | Query | Off (ms) | On (ms) | Change |
   |---|---:|---:|---:|
   | Q1 | 6.3 | 6.7 | +6.0% |
   | Q2 | 106.1 | 101.0 | −4.7% |
   | Q3 | 43.1 | 43.6 | +1.3% |
   | Q4 | 591.4 | 594.9 | +0.6% |
   | Q5 | 71.7 | 72.4 | +1.0% |
   | Q6 | 46.3 | 45.7 | −1.4% |
   | Q7 | 96.6 | 99.5 | +3.0% |
   | Q8 | 46.8 | 55.1 | +17.8% |
   | Q9 | 137.1 | 136.2 | −0.6% |
   | Q10 | 72.9 | 74.6 | +2.2% |
   | Q11 | 336.1 | 347.0 | +3.2% |
   | Q12 | 35.6 | 36.6 | +2.9% |
   | Q13 | 152.2 | 154.4 | +1.5% |
   | Q14 | 657.7 | 679.4 | +3.3% |
   | Q15 | 70.5 | 58.5 | −17.1% |
   | Q16 | 6.5 | 6.6 | +1.8% |
   | Q17 | 110.6 | 103.8 | −6.1% |
   | Q18 | 133.5 | 131.1 | −1.9% |
   | Q19 | 59.7 | 63.3 | +6.0% |
   | Q20 | 44.3 | 44.1 | −0.5% |
   | Q21 | 35.0 | 33.6 | −3.8% |
   | Q22 | 185.0 | 181.8 | −1.7% |
   | Q23 | 510.0 | 500.0 | −2.0% |
   | Q24 | 271.9 | 280.9 | +3.3% |
   | Q25 | 139.0 | 141.2 | +1.6% |
   | Q26 | 55.8 | 56.2 | +0.8% |
   | Q27 | 8.4 | 6.4 | −23.9% |
   | Q28 | 147.8 | 146.8 | −0.7% |
   | Q29 | 131.8 | 131.0 | −0.6% |
   | Q30 | 38.0 | 38.3 | +0.7% |
   | Q31 | 140.3 | 147.1 | +4.9% |
   | Q32 | 24.6 | 25.4 | +3.2% |
   | Q33 | 55.5 | 56.1 | +1.1% |
   | Q34 | 6.6 | 6.8 | +3.0% |
   | Q35 | 89.3 | 90.0 | +0.8% |
   | Q36 | 7.2 | 6.6 | −8.1% |
   | Q37 | 9.6 | 9.1 | −5.2% |
   | Q38 | 83.3 | 82.6 | −0.9% |
   | Q39 | 128.0 | 132.6 | +3.6% |
   | Q40 | 30.2 | 29.0 | −3.8% |
   | Q41 | 17.5 | 17.5 | +0.2% |
   | Q42 | 34.2 | 30.5 | −10.6% |
   | Q43 | 5.8 | 5.5 | −5.4% |
   | Q44 | 7.1 | 7.3 | +4.0% |
   | Q45 | 40.7 | 42.1 | +3.3% |
   | Q46 | 15.2 | 15.2 | +0.1% |
   | Q47 | 292.1 | 305.8 | +4.7% |
   | Q48 | 117.2 | 117.4 | +0.2% |
   | Q49 | 102.5 | 101.5 | −1.0% |
   | Q50 | 75.9 | 80.0 | +5.4% |
   | Q51 | 140.1 | 147.8 | +5.5% |
   | Q52 | 35.0 | 30.5 | −12.8% |
   | Q53 | 44.8 | 39.9 | −11.0% |
   | Q54 | 64.5 | 68.8 | +6.7% |
   | Q55 | 39.0 | 38.7 | −0.8% |
   | Q56 | 58.2 | 56.4 | −3.1% |
   | Q57 | 204.9 | 210.0 | +2.5% |
   | Q58 | 123.5 | 130.7 | +5.8% |
   | Q59 | 157.6 | 151.5 | −3.9% |
   | Q60 | 60.0 | 61.7 | +2.9% |
   | Q61 | 9.9 | 10.0 | +0.9% |
   | Q62 | 50.5 | 51.6 | +2.1% |
   | Q63 | 49.9 | 40.6 | −18.7% |
   | Q64 | 458.1 | 481.3 | +5.1% |
   | Q65 | 93.6 | 100.9 | +7.8% |
   | Q66 | 90.4 | 89.6 | −1.0% |
   | Q67 | 334.7 | 322.9 | −3.5% |
   | Q68 | 6.7 | 6.9 | +2.4% |
   | Q69 | 71.5 | 70.8 | −0.9% |
   | Q70 | 123.6 | 128.2 | +3.7% |
   | Q71 | 54.2 | 56.2 | +3.7% |
   | Q72 | 4161.8 | 4209.4 | +1.1% |
   | Q73 | 6.5 | 6.0 | −7.7% |
   | Q74 | 212.4 | 222.0 | +4.5% |
   | Q75 | 190.4 | 188.4 | −1.0% |
   | Q76 | 54.3 | 47.0 | −13.6% |
   | Q77 | 81.0 | 87.9 | +8.5% |
   | Q78 | 378.9 | 354.3 | −6.5% |
   | Q79 | 88.1 | 88.8 | +0.8% |
   | Q80 | 142.2 | 144.1 | +1.4% |
   | Q81 | 30.5 | 32.1 | +5.2% |
   | Q82 | 30.0 | 29.8 | −0.5% |
   | Q83 | 38.2 | 37.8 | −1.0% |
   | Q84 | 32.9 | 33.5 | +1.8% |
   | Q85 | 125.9 | 122.5 | −2.7% |
   | Q86 | 31.0 | 31.5 | +1.5% |
   | Q87 | 75.9 | 74.7 | −1.5% |
   | Q88 | 132.7 | 133.3 | +0.4% |
   | Q89 | 54.0 | 54.8 | +1.4% |
   | Q90 | 21.0 | 20.4 | −2.8% |
   | Q91 | 60.9 | 48.0 | −21.2% |
   | Q92 | 38.3 | 37.5 | −2.0% |
   | Q93 | 74.2 | 75.6 | +2.0% |
   | Q94 | 47.1 | 46.2 | −1.9% |
   | Q95 | 113.5 | 112.8 | −0.6% |
   | Q96 | 38.9 | 32.6 | −16.4% |
   | Q97 | 77.9 | 73.0 | −6.4% |
   | Q98 | 56.8 | 57.7 | +1.6% |
   | Q99 | 76.3 | 77.2 | +1.2% |
   | **Total** | **14373.1** | **14452.5** | **+0.6%** |
   
   **Simulated S3** (9 timed samples per query and mode)
   
   | Query | Off (ms) | On (ms) | Change |
   |---|---:|---:|---:|
   | Q1 | 29.9 | 26.3 | −11.9% |
   | Q2 | 587.6 | 612.1 | +4.2% |
   | Q3 | 308.7 | 281.3 | −8.9% |
   | Q4 | 1615.0 | 1578.4 | −2.3% |
   | Q5 | 441.6 | 441.3 | −0.1% |
   | Q6 | 446.6 | 587.2 | +31.5% |
   | Q7 | 439.0 | 645.8 | +47.1% |
   | Q8 | 514.0 | 547.0 | +6.4% |
   | Q9 | 654.7 | 599.4 | −8.5% |
   | Q10 | 622.2 | 710.1 | +14.1% |
   | Q11 | 1024.6 | 920.0 | −10.2% |
   | Q12 | 309.4 | 274.2 | −11.4% |
   | Q13 | 630.0 | 951.4 | +51.0% |
   | Q14 | 3630.5 | 3506.3 | −3.4% |
   | Q15 | 375.7 | 385.9 | +2.7% |
   | Q16 | 25.1 | 26.2 | +4.7% |
   | Q17 | 773.3 | 739.6 | −4.4% |
   | Q18 | 580.8 | 748.1 | +28.8% |
   | Q19 | 544.7 | 464.8 | −14.7% |
   | Q20 | 240.5 | 356.3 | +48.2% |
   | Q21 | 491.2 | 559.3 | +13.9% |
   | Q22 | 518.8 | 484.3 | −6.6% |
   | Q23 | 2282.7 | 2210.7 | −3.2% |
   | Q24 | 1781.6 | 1879.1 | +5.5% |
   | Q25 | 879.4 | 788.5 | −10.3% |
   | Q26 | 363.2 | 632.0 | +74.0% |
   | Q27 | 25.2 | 24.7 | −1.8% |
   | Q28 | 347.6 | 324.4 | −6.7% |
   | Q29 | 820.1 | 743.0 | −9.4% |
   | Q30 | 484.4 | 456.9 | −5.7% |
   | Q31 | 1349.0 | 1451.7 | +7.6% |
   | Q32 | 405.0 | 405.8 | +0.2% |
   | Q33 | 439.7 | 585.4 | +33.1% |
   | Q34 | 30.1 | 27.3 | −9.5% |
   | Q35 | 701.3 | 770.3 | +9.8% |
   | Q36 | 27.9 | 30.5 | +9.4% |
   | Q37 | 87.1 | 147.7 | +69.7% |
   | Q38 | 518.6 | 550.6 | +6.2% |
   | Q39 | 1691.4 | 1925.1 | +13.8% |
   | Q40 | 363.8 | 375.6 | +3.2% |
   | Q41 | 155.6 | 386.4 | +148.3% |
   | Q42 | 356.5 | 291.2 | −18.3% |
   | Q43 | 21.0 | 24.5 | +16.5% |
   | Q44 | 43.9 | 42.7 | −2.6% |
   | Q45 | 526.4 | 383.4 | −27.2% |
   | Q46 | 217.5 | 243.2 | +11.8% |
   | Q47 | 1268.8 | 1223.7 | −3.6% |
   | Q48 | 548.3 | 782.6 | +42.7% |
   | Q49 | 436.3 | 481.8 | +10.4% |
   | Q50 | 555.1 | 542.6 | −2.3% |
   | Q51 | 437.6 | 497.3 | +13.6% |
   | Q52 | 337.9 | 348.8 | +3.2% |
   | Q53 | 357.9 | 444.0 | +24.0% |
   | Q54 | 743.6 | 832.8 | +12.0% |
   | Q55 | 289.6 | 318.0 | +9.8% |
   | Q56 | 445.1 | 439.8 | −1.2% |
   | Q57 | 1186.9 | 1108.0 | −6.6% |
   | Q58 | 1229.7 | 990.1 | −19.5% |
   | Q59 | 930.6 | 829.9 | −10.8% |
   | Q60 | 494.3 | 454.6 | −8.0% |
   | Q61 | 47.7 | 47.4 | −0.7% |
   | Q62 | 469.6 | 342.6 | −27.1% |
   | Q63 | 290.4 | 420.0 | +44.6% |
   | Q64 | 2836.4 | 2754.5 | −2.9% |
   | Q65 | 623.2 | 700.3 | +12.4% |
   | Q66 | 488.3 | 582.9 | +19.4% |
   | Q67 | 669.7 | 576.6 | −13.9% |
   | Q68 | 31.4 | 29.6 | −5.5% |
   | Q69 | 555.1 | 672.8 | +21.2% |
   | Q70 | 700.4 | 633.4 | −9.6% |
   | Q71 | 418.2 | 452.8 | +8.3% |
   | Q72 | 4652.1 | 4559.5 | −2.0% |
   | Q73 | 30.0 | 26.5 | −11.7% |
   | Q74 | 915.1 | 1024.0 | +11.9% |
   | Q75 | 960.5 | 948.3 | −1.3% |
   | Q76 | 407.3 | 431.0 | +5.8% |
   | Q77 | 619.1 | 578.7 | −6.5% |
   | Q78 | 1002.3 | 1009.9 | +0.8% |
   | Q79 | 446.7 | 367.6 | −17.7% |
   | Q80 | 696.8 | 728.5 | +4.5% |
   | Q81 | 421.6 | 433.4 | +2.8% |
   | Q82 | 633.0 | 506.5 | −20.0% |
   | Q83 | 641.6 | 664.3 | +3.5% |
   | Q84 | 340.4 | 337.4 | −0.9% |
   | Q85 | 797.7 | 961.7 | +20.6% |
   | Q86 | 245.4 | 259.9 | +5.9% |
   | Q87 | 478.3 | 542.2 | +13.3% |
   | Q88 | 541.1 | 585.2 | +8.2% |
   | Q89 | 368.7 | 323.5 | −12.3% |
   | Q90 | 296.0 | 341.6 | +15.4% |
   | Q91 | 594.0 | 741.4 | +24.8% |
   | Q92 | 352.6 | 381.2 | +8.1% |
   | Q93 | 537.3 | 536.6 | −0.1% |
   | Q94 | 460.5 | 464.3 | +0.8% |
   | Q95 | 715.4 | 737.6 | +3.1% |
   | Q96 | 310.5 | 343.3 | +10.6% |
   | Q97 | 504.7 | 371.1 | −26.5% |
   | Q98 | 299.2 | 367.9 | +23.0% |
   | Q99 | 570.7 | 508.3 | −10.9% |
   | **Total** | **63953.6** | **65734.3** | **+2.8%** |
   
   </details>
   
   <details>
   <summary><b>IMDB (Join Order Benchmark)</b>: local +1.3% overall, six 
queries +10% to +14%; simulated S3 +4.9%: Q5 +44%, Q15 +36%, 38 more +10% to 
+30%, six queries −11% to −21%</summary>
   
   **Local** (4 timed samples per query and mode)
   
   | Query | Off (ms) | On (ms) | Change |
   |---|---:|---:|---:|
   | Q1 | 134.5 | 125.0 | −7.0% |
   | Q2 | 118.4 | 115.3 | −2.6% |
   | Q3 | 108.3 | 104.3 | −3.7% |
   | Q4 | 120.4 | 122.9 | +2.1% |
   | Q5 | 116.0 | 113.3 | −2.3% |
   | Q6 | 109.5 | 110.9 | +1.3% |
   | Q7 | 41.1 | 42.7 | +4.0% |
   | Q8 | 133.2 | 133.3 | +0.1% |
   | Q9 | 369.5 | 374.2 | +1.3% |
   | Q10 | 336.2 | 310.2 | −7.7% |
   | Q11 | 398.5 | 397.1 | −0.4% |
   | Q12 | 151.5 | 147.7 | −2.5% |
   | Q13 | 124.2 | 124.9 | +0.6% |
   | Q14 | 160.6 | 161.3 | +0.4% |
   | Q15 | 87.7 | 92.8 | +5.9% |
   | Q16 | 80.2 | 85.5 | +6.6% |
   | Q17 | 419.1 | 420.7 | +0.4% |
   | Q18 | 608.7 | 591.1 | −2.9% |
   | Q19 | 663.8 | 641.0 | −3.4% |
   | Q20 | 593.7 | 613.4 | +3.3% |
   | Q21 | 712.8 | 695.7 | −2.4% |
   | Q22 | 627.7 | 635.4 | +1.2% |
   | Q23 | 1206.9 | 1131.3 | −6.3% |
   | Q24 | 376.5 | 376.5 | −0.0% |
   | Q25 | 364.7 | 358.6 | −1.7% |
   | Q26 | 621.5 | 611.5 | −1.6% |
   | Q27 | 387.6 | 427.9 | +10.4% |
   | Q28 | 399.3 | 450.7 | +12.9% |
   | Q29 | 2053.1 | 2084.4 | +1.5% |
   | Q30 | 1544.3 | 1545.1 | +0.1% |
   | Q31 | 607.9 | 656.2 | +8.0% |
   | Q32 | 583.3 | 627.2 | +7.5% |
   | Q33 | 640.3 | 678.7 | +6.0% |
   | Q34 | 676.0 | 717.5 | +6.1% |
   | Q35 | 422.2 | 419.8 | −0.6% |
   | Q36 | 294.5 | 283.7 | −3.7% |
   | Q37 | 405.9 | 409.8 | +1.0% |
   | Q38 | 137.0 | 144.7 | +5.6% |
   | Q39 | 144.1 | 131.5 | −8.7% |
   | Q40 | 126.2 | 124.2 | −1.5% |
   | Q41 | 285.0 | 280.7 | −1.5% |
   | Q42 | 315.0 | 329.0 | +4.5% |
   | Q43 | 242.4 | 245.3 | +1.2% |
   | Q44 | 336.2 | 338.8 | +0.8% |
   | Q45 | 438.2 | 437.6 | −0.1% |
   | Q46 | 338.3 | 352.9 | +4.3% |
   | Q47 | 312.0 | 312.2 | +0.0% |
   | Q48 | 345.5 | 345.8 | +0.1% |
   | Q49 | 418.2 | 394.7 | −5.6% |
   | Q50 | 443.5 | 435.7 | −1.7% |
   | Q51 | 440.5 | 436.9 | −0.8% |
   | Q52 | 536.9 | 536.4 | −0.1% |
   | Q53 | 520.5 | 507.2 | −2.5% |
   | Q54 | 558.6 | 563.1 | +0.8% |
   | Q55 | 232.9 | 242.6 | +4.2% |
   | Q56 | 6570.7 | 6549.8 | −0.3% |
   | Q57 | 6610.9 | 6633.2 | +0.3% |
   | Q58 | 6595.4 | 6541.2 | −0.8% |
   | Q59 | 6511.1 | 6573.0 | +1.0% |
   | Q60 | 3828.5 | 3774.9 | −1.4% |
   | Q61 | 9515.4 | 9643.3 | +1.3% |
   | Q62 | 9527.2 | 9670.0 | +1.5% |
   | Q63 | 9854.3 | 10142.9 | +2.9% |
   | Q64 | 3976.9 | 4022.4 | +1.1% |
   | Q65 | 9908.1 | 9938.6 | +0.3% |
   | Q66 | 552.8 | 569.2 | +3.0% |
   | Q67 | 506.7 | 534.9 | +5.6% |
   | Q68 | 519.2 | 577.1 | +11.2% |
   | Q69 | 868.8 | 914.9 | +5.3% |
   | Q70 | 826.5 | 886.6 | +7.3% |
   | Q71 | 891.9 | 949.4 | +6.5% |
   | Q72 | 1016.5 | 1049.4 | +3.2% |
   | Q73 | 426.5 | 419.9 | −1.6% |
   | Q74 | 507.8 | 508.9 | +0.2% |
   | Q75 | 455.0 | 461.2 | +1.4% |
   | Q76 | 417.6 | 419.0 | +0.3% |
   | Q77 | 412.8 | 437.6 | +6.0% |
   | Q78 | 453.0 | 450.0 | −0.7% |
   | Q79 | 581.2 | 556.6 | −4.2% |
   | Q80 | 582.7 | 549.4 | −5.7% |
   | Q81 | 580.9 | 602.7 | +3.7% |
   | Q82 | 597.0 | 609.8 | +2.1% |
   | Q83 | 505.8 | 501.0 | −0.9% |
   | Q84 | 411.5 | 423.8 | +3.0% |
   | Q85 | 525.9 | 517.1 | −1.7% |
   | Q86 | 1028.8 | 1073.9 | +4.4% |
   | Q87 | 919.2 | 967.5 | +5.3% |
   | Q88 | 572.6 | 624.1 | +9.0% |
   | Q89 | 559.0 | 596.8 | +6.8% |
   | Q90 | 615.6 | 650.7 | +5.7% |
   | Q91 | 516.6 | 510.9 | −1.1% |
   | Q92 | 455.5 | 453.9 | −0.3% |
   | Q93 | 511.5 | 503.9 | −1.5% |
   | Q94 | 442.4 | 429.5 | −2.9% |
   | Q95 | 451.7 | 433.2 | −4.1% |
   | Q96 | 470.4 | 428.6 | −8.9% |
   | Q97 | 530.2 | 514.1 | −3.0% |
   | Q98 | 499.1 | 515.5 | +3.3% |
   | Q99 | 587.1 | 578.7 | −1.4% |
   | Q100 | 831.4 | 853.0 | +2.6% |
   | Q101 | 786.7 | 854.7 | +8.6% |
   | Q102 | 1214.2 | 1227.8 | +1.1% |
   | Q103 | 543.9 | 571.6 | +5.1% |
   | Q104 | 578.0 | 613.4 | +6.1% |
   | Q105 | 558.4 | 600.5 | +7.5% |
   | Q106 | 601.9 | 665.6 | +10.6% |
   | Q107 | 576.8 | 636.8 | +10.4% |
   | Q108 | 612.8 | 696.8 | +13.7% |
   | Q109 | 19.0 | 18.3 | −3.5% |
   | Q110 | 114.4 | 120.9 | +5.7% |
   | Q111 | 289.3 | 295.4 | +2.1% |
   | Q112 | 265.1 | 259.6 | −2.1% |
   | Q113 | 325.6 | 324.1 | −0.4% |
   | **Total** | **122985.9** | **124544.9** | **+1.3%** |
   
   **Simulated S3** (3 timed samples per query and mode)
   
   | Query | Off (ms) | On (ms) | Change |
   |---|---:|---:|---:|
   | Q1 | 590.7 | 770.2 | +30.4% |
   | Q2 | 571.0 | 632.4 | +10.8% |
   | Q3 | 478.7 | 591.4 | +23.5% |
   | Q4 | 630.1 | 556.4 | −11.7% |
   | Q5 | 619.8 | 895.5 | +44.5% |
   | Q6 | 853.4 | 1070.0 | +25.4% |
   | Q7 | 456.1 | 457.0 | +0.2% |
   | Q8 | 831.7 | 680.2 | −18.2% |
   | Q9 | 1188.6 | 1267.2 | +6.6% |
   | Q10 | 1142.8 | 1147.5 | +0.4% |
   | Q11 | 1129.5 | 1260.0 | +11.6% |
   | Q12 | 743.2 | 963.7 | +29.7% |
   | Q13 | 785.5 | 856.0 | +9.0% |
   | Q14 | 824.0 | 845.0 | +2.6% |
   | Q15 | 378.4 | 515.8 | +36.3% |
   | Q16 | 441.4 | 401.9 | −8.9% |
   | Q17 | 1593.7 | 1589.2 | −0.3% |
   | Q18 | 1742.9 | 1624.5 | −6.8% |
   | Q19 | 1616.6 | 1686.8 | +4.3% |
   | Q20 | 1631.0 | 1750.2 | +7.3% |
   | Q21 | 1680.4 | 1827.5 | +8.8% |
   | Q22 | 1740.7 | 1678.5 | −3.6% |
   | Q23 | 2014.8 | 2168.4 | +7.6% |
   | Q24 | 2002.7 | 2080.4 | +3.9% |
   | Q25 | 1803.6 | 1935.2 | +7.3% |
   | Q26 | 2524.5 | 2552.5 | +1.1% |
   | Q27 | 1962.8 | 2114.1 | +7.7% |
   | Q28 | 1844.1 | 2224.0 | +20.6% |
   | Q29 | 3050.5 | 2954.4 | −3.1% |
   | Q30 | 2615.9 | 2680.6 | +2.5% |
   | Q31 | 2496.9 | 2762.3 | +10.6% |
   | Q32 | 2456.1 | 2672.2 | +8.8% |
   | Q33 | 2349.4 | 2989.8 | +27.3% |
   | Q34 | 2647.8 | 3003.4 | +13.4% |
   | Q35 | 1999.9 | 1786.2 | −10.7% |
   | Q36 | 1744.0 | 1374.4 | −21.2% |
   | Q37 | 1901.8 | 1884.7 | −0.9% |
   | Q38 | 782.2 | 905.1 | +15.7% |
   | Q39 | 731.6 | 926.7 | +26.7% |
   | Q40 | 744.1 | 818.2 | +10.0% |
   | Q41 | 1014.4 | 972.6 | −4.1% |
   | Q42 | 1553.1 | 1621.8 | +4.4% |
   | Q43 | 1203.0 | 1181.9 | −1.8% |
   | Q44 | 1304.4 | 1529.9 | +17.3% |
   | Q45 | 1554.9 | 1557.6 | +0.2% |
   | Q46 | 1203.9 | 1429.6 | +18.8% |
   | Q47 | 1197.9 | 1500.5 | +25.3% |
   | Q48 | 1207.0 | 1518.7 | +25.8% |
   | Q49 | 1319.7 | 1624.9 | +23.1% |
   | Q50 | 1271.5 | 1435.6 | +12.9% |
   | Q51 | 1346.1 | 1588.0 | +18.0% |
   | Q52 | 1886.4 | 1865.4 | −1.1% |
   | Q53 | 1782.4 | 1960.3 | +10.0% |
   | Q54 | 2014.1 | 1899.2 | −5.7% |
   | Q55 | 1562.4 | 1384.1 | −11.4% |
   | Q56 | 7617.3 | 7506.7 | −1.5% |
   | Q57 | 7674.1 | 7707.9 | +0.4% |
   | Q58 | 7584.1 | 7794.3 | +2.8% |
   | Q59 | 7636.2 | 7854.6 | +2.9% |
   | Q60 | 4787.1 | 4760.6 | −0.6% |
   | Q61 | 10652.6 | 10548.9 | −1.0% |
   | Q62 | 10676.6 | 10524.0 | −1.4% |
   | Q63 | 10837.6 | 10898.5 | +0.6% |
   | Q64 | 5099.7 | 5131.9 | +0.6% |
   | Q65 | 10853.1 | 10774.8 | −0.7% |
   | Q66 | 2161.2 | 2447.0 | +13.2% |
   | Q67 | 2235.2 | 2866.4 | +28.2% |
   | Q68 | 2177.0 | 2677.9 | +23.0% |
   | Q69 | 2859.4 | 3260.8 | +14.0% |
   | Q70 | 2901.2 | 3151.4 | +8.6% |
   | Q71 | 3058.8 | 3237.9 | +5.9% |
   | Q72 | 2938.5 | 3400.1 | +15.7% |
   | Q73 | 1967.5 | 1809.4 | −8.0% |
   | Q74 | 2283.3 | 2117.2 | −7.3% |
   | Q75 | 2003.8 | 2042.5 | +1.9% |
   | Q76 | 1940.3 | 1789.5 | −7.8% |
   | Q77 | 1652.3 | 1737.7 | +5.2% |
   | Q78 | 1603.4 | 1571.1 | −2.0% |
   | Q79 | 1811.4 | 1998.7 | +10.3% |
   | Q80 | 1899.4 | 1716.7 | −9.6% |
   | Q81 | 1921.7 | 2076.5 | +8.1% |
   | Q82 | 1884.4 | 1951.2 | +3.5% |
   | Q83 | 1999.2 | 1764.1 | −11.8% |
   | Q84 | 1667.1 | 1648.9 | −1.1% |
   | Q85 | 1944.3 | 1943.9 | −0.0% |
   | Q86 | 3434.0 | 3495.5 | +1.8% |
   | Q87 | 3510.4 | 3760.5 | +7.1% |
   | Q88 | 2589.4 | 2977.1 | +15.0% |
   | Q89 | 2682.1 | 3026.1 | +12.8% |
   | Q90 | 2621.9 | 3091.0 | +17.9% |
   | Q91 | 2539.4 | 2548.1 | +0.3% |
   | Q92 | 2130.4 | 2386.2 | +12.0% |
   | Q93 | 2394.3 | 2586.0 | +8.0% |
   | Q94 | 2034.9 | 1958.9 | −3.7% |
   | Q95 | 1783.5 | 1799.2 | +0.9% |
   | Q96 | 1800.2 | 2204.0 | +22.4% |
   | Q97 | 1990.5 | 1843.9 | −7.4% |
   | Q98 | 1934.6 | 1916.2 | −1.0% |
   | Q99 | 2077.1 | 2002.0 | −3.6% |
   | Q100 | 3684.1 | 3740.5 | +1.5% |
   | Q101 | 3547.5 | 4016.0 | +13.2% |
   | Q102 | 3858.9 | 4362.3 | +13.0% |
   | Q103 | 2724.6 | 3264.3 | +19.8% |
   | Q104 | 2743.0 | 2839.6 | +3.5% |
   | Q105 | 2673.8 | 3005.9 | +12.4% |
   | Q106 | 2818.1 | 3243.7 | +15.1% |
   | Q107 | 2980.2 | 3234.3 | +8.5% |
   | Q108 | 2781.5 | 3193.9 | +14.8% |
   | Q109 | 262.3 | 269.7 | +2.8% |
   | Q110 | 846.6 | 925.2 | +9.3% |
   | Q111 | 1587.8 | 1494.9 | −5.9% |
   | Q112 | 1515.1 | 1698.6 | +12.1% |
   | Q113 | 1516.6 | 1794.4 | +18.3% |
   | **Total** | **272155.3** | **285359.0** | **+4.9%** |
   
   </details>
   
   <details>
   <summary><b>ClickBench</b>: local −0.9% overall, no query moves by 10% or 
more; simulated S3 −0.8%: three queries +12% to +18%, three −11% to 
−19%</summary>
   
   **Local** (4 timed samples per query and mode)
   
   | Query | Off (ms) | On (ms) | Change |
   |---|---:|---:|---:|
   | Q0 | 1.4 | 1.4 | −0.4% |
   | Q1 | 30.2 | 30.3 | +0.2% |
   | Q2 | 90.1 | 90.4 | +0.4% |
   | Q3 | 93.5 | 91.6 | −2.1% |
   | Q4 | 795.9 | 856.4 | +7.6% |
   | Q5 | 760.9 | 764.8 | +0.5% |
   | Q6 | 1.4 | 1.4 | −0.7% |
   | Q7 | 32.1 | 31.6 | −1.3% |
   | Q8 | 1096.8 | 1060.6 | −3.3% |
   | Q9 | 1135.2 | 1073.3 | −5.4% |
   | Q10 | 196.5 | 204.7 | +4.2% |
   | Q11 | 233.5 | 234.0 | +0.2% |
   | Q12 | 711.4 | 716.2 | +0.7% |
   | Q13 | 1038.8 | 1040.1 | +0.1% |
   | Q14 | 691.7 | 712.6 | +3.0% |
   | Q15 | 906.2 | 880.3 | −2.9% |
   | Q16 | 1816.4 | 1863.9 | +2.6% |
   | Q17 | 1837.1 | 1788.7 | −2.6% |
   | Q18 | 3616.1 | 3413.7 | −5.6% |
   | Q19 | 86.0 | 84.5 | −1.8% |
   | Q20 | 1142.3 | 1159.2 | +1.5% |
   | Q21 | 1154.0 | 1168.5 | +1.3% |
   | Q22 | 2226.4 | 2195.7 | −1.4% |
   | Q23 | 8805.6 | 8488.7 | −3.6% |
   | Q24 | 79.0 | 77.2 | −2.2% |
   | Q25 | 235.1 | 238.9 | +1.6% |
   | Q26 | 78.6 | 78.2 | −0.5% |
   | Q27 | 1153.4 | 1141.5 | −1.0% |
   | Q28 | 6298.7 | 6279.2 | −0.3% |
   | Q29 | 82.5 | 83.8 | +1.5% |
   | Q30 | 789.5 | 795.7 | +0.8% |
   | Q31 | 788.0 | 795.9 | +1.0% |
   | Q32 | 2914.1 | 2871.8 | −1.5% |
   | Q33 | 3557.7 | 3626.9 | +1.9% |
   | Q34 | 3609.7 | 3726.7 | +3.2% |
   | Q35 | 822.9 | 793.2 | −3.6% |
   | Q36 | 74.6 | 74.0 | −0.7% |
   | Q37 | 38.0 | 40.3 | +6.0% |
   | Q38 | 46.5 | 44.3 | −4.7% |
   | Q39 | 140.1 | 142.9 | +2.0% |
   | Q40 | 18.6 | 20.3 | +9.0% |
   | Q41 | 18.8 | 17.9 | −4.9% |
   | Q42 | 14.9 | 14.4 | −3.3% |
   | **Total** | **49260.1** | **48815.8** | **−0.9%** |
   
   **Simulated S3** (3 timed samples per query and mode)
   
   | Query | Off (ms) | On (ms) | Change |
   |---|---:|---:|---:|
   | Q0 | 1.3 | 1.4 | +3.4% |
   | Q1 | 2503.7 | 2647.7 | +5.8% |
   | Q2 | 3537.9 | 3523.1 | −0.4% |
   | Q3 | 3306.9 | 3159.8 | −4.5% |
   | Q4 | 3801.0 | 3511.8 | −7.6% |
   | Q5 | 3913.2 | 3821.2 | −2.4% |
   | Q6 | 1.4 | 1.4 | −0.8% |
   | Q7 | 2470.4 | 2485.1 | +0.6% |
   | Q8 | 3963.2 | 3858.4 | −2.6% |
   | Q9 | 5661.6 | 5445.9 | −3.8% |
   | Q10 | 4234.9 | 4238.5 | +0.1% |
   | Q11 | 4152.1 | 4266.6 | +2.8% |
   | Q12 | 3827.6 | 3634.0 | −5.1% |
   | Q13 | 5061.9 | 5025.3 | −0.7% |
   | Q14 | 3798.6 | 3757.7 | −1.1% |
   | Q15 | 3823.4 | 3777.6 | −1.2% |
   | Q16 | 5730.8 | 5679.4 | −0.9% |
   | Q17 | 5628.4 | 5832.2 | +3.6% |
   | Q18 | 7468.4 | 7432.2 | −0.5% |
   | Q19 | 2672.5 | 2442.9 | −8.6% |
   | Q20 | 7414.7 | 7169.7 | −3.3% |
   | Q21 | 7843.6 | 7486.1 | −4.6% |
   | Q22 | 10250.5 | 10221.3 | −0.3% |
   | Q23 | 28380.9 | 28501.2 | +0.4% |
   | Q24 | 1002.4 | 810.4 | −19.2% |
   | Q25 | 3432.3 | 3468.9 | +1.1% |
   | Q26 | 810.3 | 957.2 | +18.1% |
   | Q27 | 7538.9 | 7558.5 | +0.3% |
   | Q28 | 11150.9 | 10961.0 | −1.7% |
   | Q29 | 2858.5 | 2952.9 | +3.3% |
   | Q30 | 4892.8 | 5470.3 | +11.8% |
   | Q31 | 6069.5 | 6310.0 | +4.0% |
   | Q32 | 6825.6 | 6656.2 | −2.5% |
   | Q33 | 9209.7 | 9062.4 | −1.6% |
   | Q34 | 9333.6 | 8958.1 | −4.0% |
   | Q35 | 3585.2 | 3602.2 | +0.5% |
   | Q36 | 390.0 | 416.2 | +6.7% |
   | Q37 | 309.7 | 275.7 | −11.0% |
   | Q38 | 384.5 | 430.9 | +12.1% |
   | Q39 | 630.7 | 587.8 | −6.8% |
   | Q40 | 238.3 | 218.9 | −8.2% |
   | Q41 | 249.4 | 211.4 | −15.2% |
   | Q42 | 250.4 | 247.2 | −1.3% |
   | **Total** | **198611.8** | **197076.5** | **−0.8%** |
   
   </details>
   
   <details>
   <summary><b>ClickBench with filter pushdown</b>: local −0.7% overall, no 
query moves by 10% or more; simulated S3 −0.9%: Q41 +44%, four queries −12% to 
−34%</summary>
   
   **Local** (4 timed samples per query and mode)
   
   | Query | Off (ms) | On (ms) | Change |
   |---|---:|---:|---:|
   | Q0 | 1.4 | 1.4 | −0.2% |
   | Q1 | 31.6 | 31.4 | −0.6% |
   | Q2 | 90.8 | 90.6 | −0.2% |
   | Q3 | 94.3 | 92.8 | −1.5% |
   | Q4 | 854.0 | 840.4 | −1.6% |
   | Q5 | 746.9 | 773.2 | +3.5% |
   | Q6 | 1.4 | 1.5 | +1.3% |
   | Q7 | 38.2 | 38.2 | −0.1% |
   | Q8 | 1125.4 | 1131.1 | +0.5% |
   | Q9 | 1156.8 | 1154.5 | −0.2% |
   | Q10 | 252.1 | 249.9 | −0.9% |
   | Q11 | 294.1 | 310.0 | +5.4% |
   | Q12 | 796.4 | 808.4 | +1.5% |
   | Q13 | 1149.4 | 1137.5 | −1.0% |
   | Q14 | 830.8 | 793.1 | −4.5% |
   | Q15 | 937.7 | 929.1 | −0.9% |
   | Q16 | 1838.8 | 1825.9 | −0.7% |
   | Q17 | 1882.2 | 1819.9 | −3.3% |
   | Q18 | 3632.9 | 3570.6 | −1.7% |
   | Q19 | 92.6 | 94.5 | +2.1% |
   | Q20 | 1143.8 | 1142.1 | −0.2% |
   | Q21 | 1331.8 | 1337.3 | +0.4% |
   | Q22 | 2178.2 | 2165.6 | −0.6% |
   | Q23 | 210.9 | 200.3 | −5.0% |
   | Q24 | 66.8 | 66.8 | −0.0% |
   | Q25 | 244.7 | 248.1 | +1.4% |
   | Q26 | 94.7 | 95.5 | +0.9% |
   | Q27 | 1202.2 | 1182.7 | −1.6% |
   | Q28 | 6442.1 | 6382.6 | −0.9% |
   | Q29 | 85.2 | 84.5 | −0.8% |
   | Q30 | 806.3 | 804.3 | −0.2% |
   | Q31 | 778.8 | 791.9 | +1.7% |
   | Q32 | 3050.1 | 2934.7 | −3.8% |
   | Q33 | 3748.9 | 3782.1 | +0.9% |
   | Q34 | 3664.9 | 3678.3 | +0.4% |
   | Q35 | 763.2 | 780.3 | +2.2% |
   | Q36 | 70.7 | 69.5 | −1.7% |
   | Q37 | 38.5 | 38.5 | +0.1% |
   | Q38 | 37.3 | 38.2 | +2.3% |
   | Q39 | 132.0 | 134.6 | +2.0% |
   | Q40 | 22.4 | 20.9 | −6.9% |
   | Q41 | 19.6 | 19.5 | −0.7% |
   | Q42 | 17.9 | 16.4 | −8.5% |
   | **Total** | **41998.7** | **41708.7** | **−0.7%** |
   
   **Simulated S3** (3 timed samples per query and mode)
   
   | Query | Off (ms) | On (ms) | Change |
   |---|---:|---:|---:|
   | Q0 | 1.4 | 1.4 | +2.0% |
   | Q1 | 2525.5 | 2482.0 | −1.7% |
   | Q2 | 3692.8 | 3527.0 | −4.5% |
   | Q3 | 3246.2 | 3037.6 | −6.4% |
   | Q4 | 3694.9 | 3936.7 | +6.5% |
   | Q5 | 4008.9 | 3706.1 | −7.6% |
   | Q6 | 1.4 | 1.5 | +2.6% |
   | Q7 | 2344.0 | 2535.0 | +8.1% |
   | Q8 | 3915.0 | 3859.8 | −1.4% |
   | Q9 | 5570.9 | 5527.7 | −0.8% |
   | Q10 | 5973.4 | 5936.2 | −0.6% |
   | Q11 | 6590.2 | 7065.0 | +7.2% |
   | Q12 | 3859.8 | 3690.8 | −4.4% |
   | Q13 | 7226.0 | 6982.4 | −3.4% |
   | Q14 | 6332.6 | 6540.3 | +3.3% |
   | Q15 | 3590.3 | 3774.4 | +5.1% |
   | Q16 | 5613.4 | 5556.3 | −1.0% |
   | Q17 | 5510.6 | 5462.6 | −0.9% |
   | Q18 | 7670.0 | 7965.4 | +3.9% |
   | Q19 | 2600.8 | 2435.0 | −6.4% |
   | Q20 | 7252.8 | 7210.0 | −0.6% |
   | Q21 | 10591.6 | 10643.2 | +0.5% |
   | Q22 | 19008.0 | 18682.9 | −1.7% |
   | Q23 | 2432.0 | 2398.2 | −1.4% |
   | Q24 | 1176.2 | 1146.9 | −2.5% |
   | Q25 | 3495.5 | 3521.9 | +0.8% |
   | Q26 | 1187.1 | 1249.3 | +5.2% |
   | Q27 | 9319.9 | 9155.5 | −1.8% |
   | Q28 | 11085.6 | 11228.0 | +1.3% |
   | Q29 | 3123.8 | 2758.1 | −11.7% |
   | Q30 | 8389.6 | 8000.4 | −4.6% |
   | Q31 | 9010.0 | 8968.8 | −0.5% |
   | Q32 | 6754.8 | 6562.3 | −2.9% |
   | Q33 | 9164.5 | 9138.8 | −0.3% |
   | Q34 | 9277.9 | 9171.3 | −1.1% |
   | Q35 | 3599.5 | 3580.6 | −0.5% |
   | Q36 | 861.3 | 800.9 | −7.0% |
   | Q37 | 951.0 | 627.0 | −34.1% |
   | Q38 | 1084.9 | 929.4 | −14.3% |
   | Q39 | 1094.1 | 916.9 | −16.2% |
   | Q40 | 807.8 | 783.5 | −3.0% |
   | Q41 | 671.7 | 966.8 | +43.9% |
   | Q42 | 602.1 | 579.9 | −3.7% |
   | **Total** | **204910.0** | **203043.3** | **−0.9%** |
   
   </details>
   
   <details>
   <summary><b>ClickBench needle queries</b>: local −56.5% overall: Q0 37x and 
Q1 28x faster, Q2 −38%; simulated S3 −51.1%: Q0 7.1x and Q1 6.5x faster, Q2 
−40%</summary>
   
   Q0 to Q2 look up values that few row groups hold. Q3 looks up a phrase that 
every row group holds, which dictionaries cannot prune.
   
   **Local** (12 timed samples per query and mode)
   
   | Query | Off (ms) | On (ms) | Change |
   |---|---:|---:|---:|
   | Q0 | 2146.6 | 58.4 | −97.3% |
   | Q1 | 2177.4 | 77.8 | −96.4% |
   | Q2 | 2272.5 | 1403.2 | −38.3% |
   | Q3 | 2279.1 | 2322.2 | +1.9% |
   | **Total** | **8875.6** | **3861.7** | **−56.5%** |
   
   **Simulated S3** (9 timed samples per query and mode)
   
   | Query | Off (ms) | On (ms) | Change |
   |---|---:|---:|---:|
   | Q0 | 11432.5 | 1603.8 | −86.0% |
   | Q1 | 11583.3 | 1776.1 | −84.7% |
   | Q2 | 11773.5 | 7035.7 | −40.2% |
   | Q3 | 11578.4 | 12251.5 | +5.8% |
   | **Total** | **46367.6** | **22667.1** | **−51.1%** |
   
   </details>
   
   <details>
   <summary><b>ClickBench needle queries with filter pushdown</b>: local −4.7% 
overall: Q0 3.6x and Q1 4.7x faster; simulated S3 −8.8%: Q0 −41%, Q1 −36%, Q2 
−17%</summary>
   
   Same queries as above, with `--pushdown`.
   
   **Local** (12 timed samples per query and mode)
   
   | Query | Off (ms) | On (ms) | Change |
   |---|---:|---:|---:|
   | Q0 | 80.1 | 22.3 | −72.2% |
   | Q1 | 140.5 | 29.6 | −78.9% |
   | Q2 | 225.3 | 223.9 | −0.6% |
   | Q3 | 1706.6 | 1776.1 | +4.1% |
   | **Total** | **2152.5** | **2051.9** | **−4.7%** |
   
   **Simulated S3** (9 timed samples per query and mode)
   
   | Query | Off (ms) | On (ms) | Change |
   |---|---:|---:|---:|
   | Q0 | 2774.7 | 1645.7 | −40.7% |
   | Q1 | 3014.0 | 1913.9 | −36.5% |
   | Q2 | 3503.5 | 2916.5 | −16.8% |
   | Q3 | 14005.2 | 14760.1 | +5.4% |
   | **Total** | **23297.5** | **21236.2** | **−8.8%** |
   
   </details>
   


-- 
This is an automated message from the Apache Git Service.
To respond to the message, please log on to GitHub and use the
URL above to go to the specific comment.

To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected]

For queries about this service, please contact Infrastructure at:
[email protected]


---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected]
For additional commands, e-mail: [email protected]

Reply via email to