I didn't see it until I set "RunDef.Comparisons = {'truth', 'regression'};".
That's the same setting in autorundef_T6.m. I don't know too much about the
inner working of the test system, but perhaps comparing previous test
pass/fails is enabled separately than the regression comparator, which I
believe compares the values of the test script results.
On 9/21/2018 11:43, Darrel Conway wrote:
I'm definitely doing compares to a regression build when doing a full system
run; I see the "fixed truth failures":
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Fixed Issues
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Fixed truth failures:
BatchEstimator_InversionAlgorithm_Cholesky_NormalMatrixReduction_Bias
BatchEstimator_InversionAlgorithm_Cholesky_NormalMatrixReduction_Bias
BatchEstimator_InversionAlgorithm_Cholesky_NormalMatrixReduction_Bias2
BatchEstimator_InversionAlgorithm_Cholesky_NormalMatrixReduction_Bias2
BatchEstimator_InversionAlgorithm_Internal_NormalMatrixReduction_Bias
...
and can't see any way other than a regression comparison for that to work. On
Linux, this is set in the rundef like this:
version = GetLinuxVersion;
...
RunDef.Comparisons = {'truth'};
RunDef.RegressionBuild = strcat(version, 'Baseline');
I there something else I should be doing there? (Linux nightly rundef files
attached for your viewing pleasure.)
- DJC
On 09/21/2018 08:28 AM, John McGreevy wrote:
There's also a the following if statement in
test\bin\+comparisonmoderator\@RegressionModerator\RunComparators.m:
if exist(outputFile, 'file') && exist(truthFile, 'file')
If it can't find either the outputFile or the truthFile, the MATLAB script
silently skips running the comparator. Maybe that's what happening to you? That
happened to me before I explicitly set the folder in RunDef.RegressionBuild,
and I discovered that while running through the MATLAB debugger to see how the
regression comparators worked.
John
On 9/21/2018 11:22, Darrel Conway wrote:
Why would it pass on Linux, then?
Here's the .tc file contents that I see:
Bugs: []
Categories: [System]
Requirements: []
OutputFiles: [
{
File: GMT-6055-GMATFunctionLargeArrayCrash.report,
Truth: GMT-6055-GMATFunctionLargeArrayCrash.truth,
Comparator: PercentDiffComparator,
RegressionComparator: FileDiffComparator,
Tolerances: [1e-10],
}
]
I also do not have a FileDiffComparator.
- DJC
On 09/21/2018 08:00 AM, Hughes, Steven P. (GSFC-5950) wrote:
I suspect that is a typo in .tc the file. I created that test, and I do not
have a comparator named FileDiffComparator on my machine that I forgot to
commit. You can change the comparator name and commit.
From: gmat-nav
<[email protected]><mailto:[email protected]> On
Behalf Of John McGreevy
Sent: Friday, September 21, 2018 10:46 AM
To: Stark, Michael E. (GSFC-5830)
<[email protected]><mailto:[email protected]>; Cooley, D S.
(GSFC-5950) <[email protected]><mailto:[email protected]>;
[email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>;
[email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>
Cc: [email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>
Subject: Re: [gmat-nav] [Gmat-buildtest] GMT-6055-GMATFunctionLargeArrayCrash
The GMT-6055-GMATFunctionLargeArrayCrash has a separate regression comparator
which I've been able to reproduce the crash in. There's two things going on
here, one is why it's hard to reproduce, and the other is why it's crashing:
1. This test uses a regression comparator, instead of just a truth
comparator, which wouldn't run until I added 'regression' to my
RunDef.Comparisons, along with setting a folder name to RunDef.RegressionBuild.
2. The regression comparator is the FileDiffComparator, which does not exist
in the repo. If I change this comparator to the DiffComparator, the test
passes. Was the comparator just renamed and the .tc file not updated? If so, I
can push the updated name to the test repo.
John
On 9/17/2018 13:55, Stark, Michael E. (GSFC-5830) via Gmat-buildtest wrote:
The answer is "a while", I notice the repetitiveness of it about a month ago,
but I didn't trace back to see how far before that. I suspect it matches how
far back it goes on Windows; I can't prove it though.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Michael Stark
[email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>
(301) 286-8571
"I don't give them hell, I tell the truth and they think it's hell!" -- Harry
S. Truman
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
On 9/17/18, 13:17, "Cooley, D S. (GSFC-5950) via Gmat-buildtest"
<[email protected]><mailto:[email protected]>
wrote:
Hi Mike,
Do you have an idea on how long its been failing on the Mac?
steve
-----Original Message-----
From: Cooley, D S. (GSFC-5950)
Sent: Monday, September 17, 2018 12:58 PM
To: '[email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>'
<[email protected]><mailto:[email protected]>;
[email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>
Cc: [email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>
Subject: RE: [Gmat-buildtest] GMT-6055-GMATFunctionLargeArrayCrash
I focus on the Nav tests but from a look back, it appears to fail every run
for the last 3 months or so.
-----Original Message-----
From: Darrel Conway <[email protected]><mailto:[email protected]>
Sent: Monday, September 17, 2018 11:56 AM
To: Cooley, D S. (GSFC-5950)
<[email protected]><mailto:[email protected]>;
[email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>
Cc: [email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>
Subject: Re: [Gmat-buildtest] GMT-6055-GMATFunctionLargeArrayCrash
Question: when you say "It seems to fail a lot on the nightly runs.", is
that a recent occurrence, something that has happened ever since you took over
the test machine chores, or something else? I seem to remember looking at this
test a while ago and thinking it was a stack size issue on Windows (the
comparator running out of memory for the compare, given other data buffered in
memory during a full test run). But if that were the case, I'd expect it to
work fine on Mac, unless MATLAB is somehow cutting the default stack size down.
- Darrel
On 09/15/2018 11:24 AM, Cooley, D S. (GSFC-5950) via Gmat-buildtest wrote:
> Good News. We only had one Windows regression test fail:
>
> GMT-6055-GMATFunctionLargeArrayCrash
>
> The test passes locally. It seems to fail a lot on the nightly runs.
Anyone have any ideas on how to make this test more stable?
>
>
>
> -----Original Message-----
> From: [email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>
<[email protected]><mailto:[email protected]>
> Sent: Saturday, September 15, 2018 2:52 AM
> To: Cooley, D S. (GSFC-5950)
<[email protected]><mailto:[email protected]>;
>
[email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>
> Subject: Test results: 2018-09-14
> (GS580W-GMAT-T6/Win7-64/GMAT-64/M2016a/VS2013)
>
> -----------------------------------------------------------------
> Summary
> -----------------------------------------------------------------
> System configuration: Windows 10/MATLAB R2017a/VS 2013 Tested build:
> 2018-09-14 Regression build: 2018-09-13
>
> Total number of scripts: 13853 (+83 deferred) Percent Passed: 99.99% New
issues: 12
> Output changes: 12
> New truth failures: 0
> New crashes: 0
> New script errors: 0
> New comparator errors: 0
> Fixed issues: 26
> Total issues: 1
>
> Test system warnings: 39
> New deferred issues: 11
> Fixed deferred issues: 0
> Total deferred issues: 55
>
> Run Time: 13 hours, 45 minutes, 49 seconds
>
> -----------------------------------------------------------------
> New Issues
> -----------------------------------------------------------------
> New truth failures:
> None
>
> Output changes (but still pass):
> BatchEstimator_ReportFile_MeasurementModeling
> Ephem_GMAT_Code500_ACE_OpsPrototype_v13
> Ephem_GMAT_Code500_CoordinateSystem
> Ephem_GMAT_Code500_ManeuverAtEnd
> Ephem_GMAT_Code500_OutputFormat
> Ephem_GMAT_Code500_TimeInteractions
> Ephem_GMAT_Code500_TimeInteractions
> Ephem_GMAT_Code500_TimeInteractions
> Ephem_GMAT_Code500_Toggle
> Ex_FirstVersionNumericSettings
> SNOPT_OverrideSpecsFile
> SNOPT_SpecsFile
>
> Output changes (but still fail):
> None
>
> New crashes/hangs/etc.:
> None
>
> New script errors:
> None
>
> New comparator errors:
> None
>
> -----------------------------------------------------------------
> Fixed Issues
> -----------------------------------------------------------------
> Fixed truth failures:
> fmincon_Report
> fmincon_ShowProgress
> Optimize_fmincon_cvg_status
> Optimize_fmincon_cvg_status
> Vary_optimizer_fmincon__AdditiveScaleFactor_Variable
>
Vary_optimizer_fmincon_Additive_and_Multiplicative_ScaleFactor_RealNumber
> Vary_optimizer_fmincon_AdditiveScaleFactor_ArrayElement
> Vary_optimizer_fmincon_AdditiveScaleFactor_RealNumber
> Vary_optimizer_fmincon_MultiplicativeScaleFactor_ArrayElement
> Vary_optimizer_fmincon_MultiplicativeScaleFactor_RealNumber
> Vary_optimizer_fmincon_MultiplicativeScaleFactor_Variable
>
> Fixed crashes/hangs/etc.:
> None
>
> Fixed script errors:
> Vary_optimizer_fmincon_InitialGuess_ForLoopVariable_2
> Vary_optimizer_fmincon_InitialGuess_ForLoopVariable
> Vary_optimizer_fmincon_Perturbation_ArrayElement
> Vary_optimizer_fmincon_Perturbation_RealNumber
> Vary_optimizer_fmincon_Perturbation_Variable
> Vary_optimizer_fmincon_UpperBound_ArrayElement
> Vary_optimizer_fmincon_UpperBound_Variable
> Vary_optimizer_fmincon__InitialValue_Array
> Vary_optimizer_fmincon__InitialValue_RealNumber
> Vary_optimizer_fmincon__InitialValue_Variable
> Vary_optimizer_fmincon__LowerBound_Array
> Vary_optimizer_fmincon__LowerBound_RealNumber
> Vary_optimizer_fmincon__LowerBound_Variable
> completed_steps_1_thru_10_of_FRC_1_using_fmincon_Optimizer
> fmincon_ConstraintTolerance
>
> Fixed comparator errors:
> None
>
> -----------------------------------------------------------------
> All Known Issues
> -----------------------------------------------------------------
> Crashes/hangs/etc.:
> None
>
> Script errors:
> None
>
> Comparator errors:
> GMT-6055-GMATFunctionLargeArrayCrash: (reg)
> ERROR MESSAGE: Undefined function
> 'comparator.FileDiffComparator.Compare' for input arguments of type
> 'char'.
>
> Truth failures:
> None
>
> -----------------------------------------------------------------
> New Issues (Deferred)
> -----------------------------------------------------------------
> New truth failures (deferred):
> None
>
> Output changes (but still pass) (deferred):
> Ephem_GMAT_Code500_InterpolationOrder [GMT-4075, GMT-4112]
> Ephem_GMAT_Code500_InterpolationOrder [GMT-4075, GMT-4112]
> Ephem_GMAT_Code500_StepSize [GMT-4112]
>
> Output changes (but still fail) (deferred):
> Ephem_GMAT_Code500_InterpolationOrder [pos err 0.0173914, tol 0.002]
[GMT-4075, GMT-4112]
> Ephem_GMAT_Code500_InterpolationOrder [pos err 0.0463976, tol 0.002]
[GMT-4075, GMT-4112]
> Ephem_GMAT_Code500_StepSize [pos err 305.165, tol 0.002] [GMT-4112]
>
EphemStressTests_Default_and_ABM_Integrator_Code500_60Sec_MultipleSCs_ForwardDirection
[pos err 15.2466, tol 1e-12] [GMT-4077]
>
EphemStressTests_Default_Prop_Code500_60Sec_MixedStopTypes_LogicTypes_DiscontinuityTypes_ForwardDirection
[pos err 9.57664, tol 1e-12] [GMT-4077]
>
EphemStressTests_Default_Prop_Code500_60Sec_MixedStopTypes_LogicTypes_DiscontinuityTypes_SolverTypes_ForwardDirect
[pos err 14.3693, tol 1e-12] [GMT-4077]
>
EphemStressTests_Default_Prop_Code500_60Sec_MixedStopTypes_LogicTypes_ForwardDirection
[pos err 0.000216981, tol 1e-12] [GMT-4112]
> EphemStressTests_PD78_ABM_Prop_Code500_60Sec_Step_ForwardDirection
> [pos err 21.5632, tol 1e-12] [GMT-4112]
>
> New crashes/hangs/etc. (deferred):
> None
>
> New script errors (deferred):
> None
>
> New comparator errors (deferred):
> None
>
> -----------------------------------------------------------------
> Fixed Issues (Deferred)
> -----------------------------------------------------------------
> Fixed truth failures (deferred):
> None
>
> Fixed crashes/hangs/etc. (deferred):
> None
>
> Fixed script errors (deferred):
> None
>
> Fixed comparator errors (deferred):
> None
>
> -----------------------------------------------------------------
> All Known Issues (Deferred)
> -----------------------------------------------------------------
> Crashes/hangs/etc. (deferred):
> GMAT_LunarTransfer_AllPlanets_DE421_BS
> GMAT_MarsTransfer_4_BS
>
> Script errors (deferred):
> BatchEstimator_EstimationEpoch [GMT-5708]
> Math_Shadowed_Builtins [GMT-3043]
> Python_IO_String [5317]
> ScriptLanguage_WhiteSpace_AfterArrayName [GMT-3522]
> THF_Sim_Accel_ConfigD_None_NA_2 [GMT-6451]
> THF_Sim_Accel_ConfigD_None_NA_3 [GMT-6451]
> THF_Sim_Accel_ConfigD_None_NA_4 [GMT-6451]
> THF_Sim_Accel_ConfigD_None_NA [GMT-6451]
> THF_Sim_Thrust_CSF2_None_NA_ZeroTSF [GMT-6451]
> TrkFile_SimEst_DSN_DS_Range_Solve_Bias_apriori [GMT-5709]
>
> Comparator errors (deferred):
> GroundStation_Iono_Range_Kband (truth) [GMT-5644]
> GroundStation_Iono_RangeRate_Kband (truth) [GMT-5644]
> GroundStation_TropoIono_Range_Kband (truth) [GMT-5644]
>
> Truth failures (deferred):
> AcceptFilter_Validation_RecordNumbers [#5 failed] [GMT-6034]
> Achieve_Validation_LHS_Field [ptrn 1 failed] [GMT-3687]
> Achieve_Validation_RHS_Field [no error or exception] [GMT-3687]
> BatchEstimator_ReportFile_InitialState [#5 failed] [GMT-6412]
>
Ephem_GMAT_Code500_InterpolationOrder/Ephem_GMAT_Code500_InterpolationOrder_1.eph
[pos err 0.0173914, tol 0.002] [GMT-4075, GMT-4112]
>
Ephem_GMAT_Code500_InterpolationOrder/Ephem_GMAT_Code500_InterpolationOrder_3.eph
[pos err 0.0463976, tol 0.002] [GMT-4075, GMT-4112]
> Ephem_GMAT_Code500_StepSize/Ephem_GMAT_Code500_StepSize_1.eph [pos err
305.165, tol 0.002] [GMT-4112]
>
EphemStressTests_Default_and_ABM_Integrator_Code500_60Sec_MultipleSCs_ForwardDirection
[pos err 15.2466, tol 1e-12] [GMT-4077]
>
EphemStressTests_Default_Prop_Code500_60Sec_MixedStopTypes_LogicTypes_DiscontinuityTypes_ForwardDirection
[pos err 9.57664, tol 1e-12] [GMT-4077]
>
EphemStressTests_Default_Prop_Code500_60Sec_MixedStopTypes_LogicTypes_DiscontinuityTypes_SolverTypes_ForwardDirect
[pos err 14.3693, tol 1e-12] [GMT-4077]
>
EphemStressTests_Default_Prop_Code500_60Sec_MixedStopTypes_LogicTypes_ForwardDirection
[pos err 0.000216981, tol 1e-12] [GMT-4112]
> EphemStressTests_PD78_ABM_Prop_Code500_60Sec_Step_ForwardDirection
[pos err 21.5632, tol 1e-12] [GMT-4112]
> EphemStressTests_SPK_Integrator_Code500_60Sec_ForwardDirection [pos
err 0.000427977, tol 1e-12] [GMT-4112]
> Epoch_LeapSecond_G2MJD [max mjd diff 1.000259s > tol 0.001000s] [2561]
> Epoch_LeapSecond_In [max greg. diff 1.000005s > tol 0.001000s] [2561]
> Epoch_LeapSecond_Out [max mjd diff 1.000146s > tol 0.001000s] [2561]
> Formation_Validation_MissingComma [no error or exception] [GMT-3672]
> GMAT_ISS_Earth_JGM2_0_0_NutationUpdateInterval [pos err 0.00081496,
tol 1e-06] [GMT-2567]
> GMAT_LEO_PropSynchronization_BS []
> GMAT_Molniya_EarthSunLuna_JGM2_JR_SRP_BS [pos err 0.0756285, tol 0.002]
> Math_Inf [GMAT: 53 lines, Truth: 69 lines] [GMT-3195]
> Minimize_Validation_Field [no warn or err] [GMT-3687]
> Nonlinear_Validation_LHS_Field [no warn or err] [GMT-3687]
> Nonlinear_Validation_RHS_Field [no warn or err] [GMT-3687]
> Optimize_Yukon_Minimize_Height_on_circle_2 [diff 497, tol 0.001]
> Optimize_Yukon_Minimize_Height_on_circle_4 [diff 497, tol 0.001]
> RejectFilter_Validation_RecordNumbers [#5 failed] [GMT-6034]
> ScriptLanguage_Comments_AfterControlFlow [] [GMT-3332]
> ScriptLanguage_LineContinuation_BeginningOfLine [] [GMT-3756]
> ScriptLanguage_LiteralArrays_String [] [GMT-3680]
> ScriptLanguage_ReferenceArrays_ForceModel_7 [] [GMT-3541]
> ScriptLanguage_Validation_Semicolons_1 [no error or exception]
[GMT-3545]
> Simulator_MoonOccultation [GMAT: 11299 lines, Truth: 11306 lines]
[GMT-6134]
> SpacecraftNavigation_Validation_Mode [#1 failed] [GMT-5841]
> String_AssignNumericParam [] [GMT-2888]
> THF_Sim_Accel_ConfigD_None_NA_FixedStep [ Observable Error: 100.8 m.]
[FixedStep 1 second, Sim, constant thrust over entire interval, should it pass]
> TrkFile_SimEst_TDRS_range_Solve_Cr [] [GMT-5416]
> Vary_Validation_RHS_Field [no error or exception] [GMT-3687]
> Write_Multiple_ReportFile_Concise_2 [#69 failed] [GMT-5801]
> Write_Multiple_ReportFile_Verbose_2 [#69 failed] [GMT-5801]
>
> -----------------------------------------------------------------
> Test System Warnings
> -----------------------------------------------------------------
> Passing tests tagged with bugs:
> (To fix, remove bug ID from Bugs key in .tc file)
> Comet_Validation_OrientationEpoch_3 [GMT-3252]
> CoordSysTest_Luna_MJ2000Eq_To_ICRF [GMT-3227]
> CoordinateSystem_Validation_Axes_4 [GMT-3155]
> EphemPropagator_Code500_CentralBody_Jupiter [GMT-5795]
> EphemPropagator_Code500_CentralBody_Saturn [GMT-5795]
> EphemPropagator_Code500_ForwardProp_Interp [GMT-5760]
> EphemPropagator_SatAssigmentToNewSatThenProp [GMT-3434]
>
EphemStressTests_Default_Prop_STK_60Sec_MixedStopTypes_LogicTypes_DiscontinuityTypes_ForwardDirection
[GMT-6090]
>
EphemStressTests_Default_Prop_STK_60Sec_MixedStopTypes_LogicTypes_DiscontinuityTypes_SolverTypes_ForwardDirect
[GMT-6090]
> Ephem_GMAT_SPK_60sec_backward [GMT-5286]
> Ephem_GMAT_SPK_DefaultIntegrationStep_User_Defined_LagrangeOrder
> [GMT-5286]
> Ephem_GMAT_STK_60sec_IterativeProcess_Optimizer [GMT-6090]
> Ephem_GMAT_STK_60sec_IterativeProcess_Optimizer_NoBoundaries [GMT-6090]
> Events_ContactLocator_Ephemeris_DE405AllPlanets [GMT-5377]
> Events_ContactLocator_Ephemeris_DE424AllPlanets [GMT-5377]
> Events_ContactLocator_Heo2 [GMT-5302]
> Events_ContactLocator_UseEntireInterval_False_MissionSequence
[GMT-5292]
> Ex_GmatFunction [GMT-3604]
> Formation_Validation_PropFormSatInTwoProps [GMT-3581]
> GMAT_GEO_EarthSunMoon_0_0_0_Relativity [3405]
> GMAT_GEO_EarthSun_0_0_0_Relativity [3405]
> GMAT_ISS_EarthSunMoon_0_0_0_Relativity [3405]
> GMAT_ISS_EarthSunMoon_0_0_0_Relativity_Cmd [3405]
> GMAT_ISS_EarthSun_0_0_0_Relativity [3405]
> Math_Validation_Cross_WrongDim2 [GMT-5676]
> ScriptLanguage_Validation_DataTypes_ReferenceArray_Formation_5
[GMT-6064]
> Simulator_Propagator_EarthPointMass_Drag [GMT-5417]
> Simulator_Propagator_EarthPointMass_SRP_Drag [GMT-5417]
> Simulator_Propagator_Sun_EM [GMT-6040]
> Simulator_Propagator_Sun_EM_AllPlanets [GMT-6040]
> Simulator_Propagator_Sun_EM_AllPlanets_SRP_GR [GMT-6040]
> Simulator_Propagator_Sun_EM_GR [GMT-6040]
> SpacePointParams_CelestialBody_EpochOutput [3939]
> THF_AccelMass_CSC_None_None [GMT-5981]
> THF_Accel_CSC_None_None [GMT-5981]
> THF_ThrustMass_CSC_None_None [GMT-5981]
> THF_Thrust_CSC_None_None [GMT-5981]
> THF_Thrust_CSC_None_None_2 [GMT-5981]
> Thruster_Finite_Burn_Permutations_Separate_Propagators_2 [GMT-3455]
>
>
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> Gmat-buildtest mailing list
>
[email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>
> https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/gmat-buildtest
>
>
--
Darrel J. Conway, Ph.D. Thinking Systems, Inc.
Senior Scientist and CEO 437 W Thurber Road, Suite 6
Phone: (623) 298-4530 Tucson, AZ 85705
FAX: (520) 232-2533 www.thinksysinc.com<http://www.thinksysinc.com>
Cell: (520) 425-3626
[email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>
_______________________________________________
Gmat-buildtest mailing list
[email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/gmat-buildtest
_______________________________________________
Gmat-buildtest mailing list
[email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/gmat-buildtest
--
Darrel J. Conway, Ph.D. Thinking Systems, Inc.
Senior Scientist and CEO 437 W Thurber Road, Suite 6
Phone: (623) 298-4530 Tucson, AZ 85705
FAX: (520) 232-2533 www.thinksysinc.com<http://www.thinksysinc.com>
Cell: (520) 425-3626 [email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>
--
Darrel J. Conway, Ph.D. Thinking Systems, Inc.
Senior Scientist and CEO 437 W Thurber Road, Suite 6
Phone: (623) 298-4530 Tucson, AZ 85705
FAX: (520) 232-2533 www.thinksysinc.com<http://www.thinksysinc.com>
Cell: (520) 425-3626 [email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>
_______________________________________________
Gmat-buildtest mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/gmat-buildtest
