Quiliro Ordóñez wrote:
2009/1/13 Eus <[email protected]
<mailto:[email protected]>>
Hi Ho!
--- On Tue, 1/13/09, Quiliro Ordóñez <[email protected]
<mailto:[email protected]>> wrote:
> No it is not. Once software is free under a free license,
> whoever got it
> alwasys will have that part as free software. Whoever got
> it as nonfree
> without copyright would be able to at least execute and
> reverse engineer.
> Much better than before.....don't you think.
No, I don't think so. Reverse-engineering is much more difficult
than just compiling the source code.
I agree on that. You still don't have the code when you have
copyright. There is no advantage for us to have copyright. It's a
disadvantage. If we elimintate copyright, at least we will advance one
step forward.
Which is exactly why we need copyright, but /only/ until we have other
means of keeping software free. Near as I can tell, the GPL and
enforcement of it is the most significant reasons we are able to
maintain software freedom once it is attained. If there is no copyright
anyone will be able to take a free program, make some changes, (perhaps
only breaking changes, if it is a big company,) and release it binary
only. Since free software utilities have a habit of being the best
quality tools, I think this issue could become a significant problem
unless the ramifications of copyright changes are thought through.
How to fix this issue I am less sure of, however. Although I don't care
for government oversight, perhaps laws requiring /companies/ to maintain
the source code of old releases, and release the /complete/ source
(comments included) 3-5 years after release would be an intermediary
step. Of course ideal would be if non-free software could simply be
banned:)
Either way, as an Artist, Musician, and Computer User, I absolutely
agree that copyright is currently extremely excessive, and should at the
very least be greatly decreased.
Tor
_______________________________________________
gNewSense-users mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.nongnu.org/mailman/listinfo/gnewsense-users
