Alexander Terekhov <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > Now read > > http://www.usfca.edu/law/determann/softwarecombinations060403.pdf
I just skimmed it. I didn't find what the author is trying to prove, but I know that most of your mails about the GPL are claims that it isn't enforceable or doesn't work how FSF say it works. One simple piece of data that weakens your position is the paper's date: April 2006. If this paper gave any support to your anti-GPL arguments, don't you think that after more than 2 years, someone with finances or connections and an anti-GPL agenda like Microsoft, SCO, or an attention-seeking journalist/controversialist/lawyer would have jumped on it? But no one did. It's been ignored. So it's really, really unlikely this paper provides credible support to your usual agenda. >From my skim, I saw various points suggesting that the method of linking (dynamic vs. static), or the mixing of outputs, or hyperlinking have no effect on whether or not something is a derived work. The author is probably right, and this just supports what FSF has been saying for years. FSF's position, IIRC, IANAL, is that being a derived work is something that is decided based on the author's actions and intentions at the time of writing the software - not at the later times of someone running or linking the software. If I've missed something meaningful in the paper, could you quote it here? Thanks. -- Ciarán O'Riordan, +32 477 36 44 19, http://ciaran.compsoc.com/ Support free software, join FSFE's Fellowship: http://fsfe.org Recent blog entries: http://fsfe.org/en/fellows/ciaran/ciaran_s_free_software_notes/using_latex_to_make_pdf_documents_with_japanese_characters http://fsfe.org/en/fellows/ciaran/ciaran_s_free_software_notes/links_sean_daly_kde_swpat_chessboxing http://fsfe.org/en/fellows/ciaran/ciaran_s_free_software_notes/links_india_pats_clipperz_freegis_rms_emacs http://fsfe.org/en/fellows/ciaran/ciaran_s_free_software_notes/using_and_writing_emacs_22_input_methods _______________________________________________ gnu-misc-discuss mailing list [email protected] http://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/gnu-misc-discuss
