On Wed, 7 Jul 1999, Mats Bengtsson wrote:
> > > \score { \notes{
> > > \context Staff <
> > > \context Voice = one { \stemdown c1 c4 }
> > > \context Voice = two { \stemup d1 d4 }
> > > >
> > > }}
> > >
> > > If you don't get any moved heads, that would be a bug; please send a
> > > bugreport
Han-Wen, please ignore my previous utterings concerning your
example. It's working alright. I remembered wrongly.
But now I've succeeded in reproducing a related bug (which I thought
would be the one mentioned) which I discovered in one of my own
scores.
Check out:
\score {
\notes \relative c' {
\context Staff <
\context Voice = one { \stemdown c1 c4 }
\context Voice = two { \stemup d1 d4 }
>
}
}
Notes are shifted as expected. Now check out:
\score {
\notes \relative c' {
\context Staff <
\context Voice = one { \stemdown c1 <a4 c4> }
\context Voice = two { \stemup d1 d4 }
>
}
}
i.e. do
- \context Voice = one { \stemdown c1 c4 }
+ \context Voice = one { \stemdown c1 <a4 c4> }
Now the chord collides with the note of the other voice!
> Since the stems explicitly are set to point in different directions,
> you also get a moved head. The problem, as I've already pointed out in
> a previous email, is that Michael in his original example had two
> different voices but no explicitly set stem directions, a case that's
> not covered in Han-Wen's nice cathegorization of different cases.
...a case which I mentioned "by accident"; it's not that I'm actually
needing it, but see my next mail.
--
michael krause [aka raw style / lego] - www.tu-harburg.de/~semk2104/
