On Mon, 30 Oct 2000, David Goodman wrote: > Instead of saying, as you do, that > >sh> Implementing peer review is not the province of archivists, nor of >sh> universities, research institutions nor libraries. And when Learned >sh> Societies do it, they do it in their capacity as Publishers. > > one could instead say that: > >dg> Implementing peer review is not the province of archivists, libraries, >dg> or publishers, but that of the scholars themselves, possibly as >dg> organized into universities, research institutions, learned societies, >dg> or otherwise into less formal groups such as open forums. > > What do publishers have to do with peer review, except for the > historical accident of having in the print era a limited number of > pages they can afford to print, and thus wanting the best of the > available material to put in those pages? > > If we freed peer review from the publishers, then this would almost > immediately free the distribution of the material from them as well.
Your points are well-taken, but I think they contain one incorrect (or perhaps merely unexamined) assumption: What, in essence, IS a (refereed) journal publisher? What is the essential service a journal publisher performs, medium-independently, and independently of the cost-recovery model? A journal publisher is not a printer or a type-setter (if we are speaking medium-independently); nor is a publisher a marketer or a fulfiller (independently of the cost-recovery model). I think you will find that the only ESSENTIAL function that a refereed journal publisher performs (medium-independently) is quality-control and certification [QC/C]. That is, the journal IMPLEMENTS peer review (the peers themselves review for free), i.e. administers the soliciting of the expert feedback and the application of the feedback to the revision) and then CERTIFIES the accepted, revised final draft as appearing in the Journal (volume, issue, page, date). That is the essential function of journal publication, and it must be preserved, independently of both medium (on-paper or on-line) and cost-recovery model (Subscription/License-Pay-Per-View [S/L/P] tolls to the reader-institution for a PRODUCT or Quality-Control/Certification [QC/C] fees to the author-institution for a SERVICE). QC/C is what distinguishes refereed-journal publication from vanity-press self-publication. Let us call the former "publication" for short, to distinguish it from the latter. So what do publishers have to do with peer review? Whether or not by historical accident, they are the ones, and the only ones, who have the track record in implementing it. Now, we are talking about freeing that refereed literature online. That is freeing it from the access/impact barriers of S/L/P. We agree that this does not mean freeing the literature from QC/C, because that is essential (otherwise it is just vanity-press). Does it then mean freeing the literature from QC/C-provision by the only ones who have experience and expertise in implementing it? Why? I could understand contemplating something like that if there were no alternative: Referees, after all, and editorial boards, are free to migrate to other publishers (and have done so), and from old publishers to new publishers. But until and unless there is reason for them to do so, why should they do so? And, even more important, why on earth should freeing this literature, which is already within reach (through self-archiving), wait for them to do so? It is already ironic that the self-archiving solution has not yet taken us all to the optimal and inevitable, given that it is completely feasible and even easy. Let us hope that with the release of the eprints.org software this will at last happen, and quickly. But if we are to wait instead for the defection or co-option of the editorial boards and referees of the established journals, the wait will be a long (and needless) one. > This is in some ways the opposite of the direction you have been > proposing, but I wonder whether it might be a more practical route to > accomplish the same goal. I am sure the progress to open archives in > most fields has been disappointingly slow to you as it has been to all > of us who are engaged in it, and it might now be appropriate to try > some additional pathways. It has been disappointingly slow, but with no good reason (and the free and immediate availability of the eprints.org software for creating institutional, interoperable Eprint Archives for self-archiving may at last get it up to speed). In contrast, waiting now for the defection of editorial boards and referees would provide a "good" reason for a much longer delay. > Certainly I agree we should immediately proceed to > >sh> freeing the peer-reviewed literature, such as it is, now. The online >sh> medium makes that immediately attainable WITH NO NEED TO FIRST WAIT TO >sh> TEST OUT NEW FORMS OF PEER REVIEW, OR TO RUSH IN AND IMPLEMENT THEM >sh> WITHOUT FIRST TESTING THEM! > > But if we don't succeed in freeing the peer-reviewed literature right > away, and surely we haven't succeeded so far, I for one am ready to > entertain other approaches. Perhaps after all we should first reform > peer review, and then reform publishing. Even though you and I think > it makes more sense the other way round, maybe we are wrong. We're > scientists, not prophets, and should be prepared to test other theories > than just our own. As I said, I hope eprints.org will now provide the missing momentum for the self-archiving solution. Parallel approaches are of course welcome -- as long as they really are likely to hasten rather than retard the process. The current and future literature could be completely freed by self-archiving almost overnight. Peer-review reform awaits testing, demonstrated success and feasibility, and then implementation. That's a long empirical research programme. Journal migration is another long path, and it's not clear there are significant numbers ready, willing or able to embark on either of these paths now; more important, it's unnecessary! Moreover, any armchair endorsement of the hypothetical, long-term reform/migration route amounts to yet another rationale for not taking the immediate self-archiving route (i.e., yet another basis for what I have called "Zeno's Paralysis" -- or should it be called Buridan's Delay -- in getting the research cavalry to drink from the waters of self-archiving). Let 1000 flowers bloom -- as long as they don't block one another's way. -------------------------------------------------------------------- Stevan Harnad [email protected] Professor of Cognitive Science [email protected] Department of Electronics and phone: +44 23-80 592-582 Computer Science fax: +44 23-80 592-865 University of Southampton http://www.ecs.soton.ac.uk/~harnad/ Highfield, Southampton http://www.princeton.edu/~harnad/ SO17 1BJ UNITED KINGDOM NOTE: A complete archive of the ongoing discussion of providing free access to the refereed journal literature online is available at the American Scientist September Forum (98 & 99 & 00): http://amsci-forum.amsci.org/archives/American-Scientist-Open-Access-Forum.html You may join the list at the site above. Discussion can be posted to: [email protected]
