Following the recent postings to this list concerning RAE 2001, I thought that I would consult the RAE 2001 website (http://www.rae.ac.uk/).
1) Regarding the importance or not of the impact factors of journals, the following is stated: http://www.rae.ac.uk/ASP/GuideFAQ/ShowQ.asp?QID=10 Is there a hierarchical list which attributes weight to published research according to the place of publication? No. While panels may take into consideration the degree of peer-review an item of research output may have before publication, no panel may take the absence of peer-review as meaning a lack of quality within any given item of research output. Hierarchical lists of weightings are not used in the assessment process. Panel members form judgements on all the evidence presented in the round, with a full awareness of the wider context in which they are assessing output. 2) The types of 'output' which may be submitted in the RAE 2001 are listed as (clearly including online publications, which often do not have page numbers) Authored book, Software, Composition, Edited book, Report for external body, Design, Chapter in book, Confidential report for external body, Exhibition, Journal article, Internet publication, Artefact, Conference contribution, Internet publication (via subscription only), Scholarly edition, Patent/ published patent application, Performance and 'Other form of assessable output'. http://www.rae.ac.uk/Pubs/briefing/note4.htm Dr Jamie Humphrey CChem MRSC Managing Editor, Electronic Journals Royal Society of Chemistry, Thomas Graham House, Milton Road, Science Park, Cambridge, CB4 0WF, UK Tel +44 (0)1223 432139, Fax +44 (0)1223 420247 E-mail [email protected] www.rsc.org and www.chemsoc.org
