On 20-Oct-04, at 10:28 AM, Stevan Harnad wrote:
I think the interpretation of this is fairly clear: Once there is 100% OA, research is used far more, and although the overall number of references per article may not increase, their *selectivity* does, because authors can cite what is most important and relevant, rather than just what their institutions happen to be able to afford to access (as is the case before there is 100% OA, which is the prevailing condition in all fields other than astro currently).
As Stevan points out, the citation advantage for OA as opposed to non-OA materials is only demonstrable in traditional numeric terms for fields that are only partially OA. Once 100% OA is achieved, then all articles and authors have an equal research impact advantage. Here is my perspective, as someone who is no expert on bibliometrics: There are other obvious impact advantages of OA in a 100% OA field, which may need different types of measurements. One example is the increased quality of research that can proceed once researchers have ready access to all the scholarly knowledge in their fields. Another advantage that might not be picked up by traditional measurements is increased citations in journals that are not covered by western-based citation indexes. That is, researchers in developing countries will have access, and are likely citing articles, but citations in publications based in their home countries are not covered by current indexes. Another clue to increasing impact in terms of usage is the increase in downloads or readership that Stevan refers to. This may be the beginnings of evidence of impact beyond academe, that is, usage by professionals, teachers, students, etc. Thoughts? Heather G. Morrison Project Coordinator BC Electronic Library Network ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Phone: 604-268-7001 Fax: 604-291-3023 Email: [email protected] Web: http://www.eln.bc.ca
