OK, so the journal I edit is not a scientific research journal, and this is purely anecdotal. But in editing Learned Publishing for the past couple of years (which includes copy-editing), I have found and corrected numerous errors in citations (and have corrected incomplete ones, and added DOI or other links for all of those available online). I have also identified numerous instances where text was inconsistent or at variance with the Figures. And, now and again, downright errors in the text which I happen to spot because I know the field.
I like to think it is the Editor's (and copy-editor's) job to make the author look better than he/she is! Seriously though, the aim of copy-editing is primarily to make the content as understandable as possible - picking up errors at that late stage is a bonus (peer-reviewers should have spotted them, but don't always) Sally Sally Morris Partner, Morris Associates - Publishing Consultancy South House, The Street Clapham, Worthing, West Sussex BN13 3UU, UK Tel: +44(0)1903 871286 Fax: +44(0)8701 202806 Email: [email protected] ____________________________________________________________________________ From: American Scientist Open Access Forum [mailto:[email protected]] On Behalf Of Stevan Harnad Sent: 19 January 2009 23:36 To: [email protected] Subject: Re: STM Publisher Briefing on Institution Repository Deposit Mandates On Mon, Jan 19, 2009 at 3:14 PM, Sandy Thatcher <[email protected]> wrote: The only statement in Stevan's commentary that I find surprising and questionable--because it is stated with such certainty of its truth, with no reference to any empirical backing, which is unusual for Stevan--is the claim that it is "exceedingly rare" (Stevan's emphasis) for copyediting "to detect any substantive errors" in articles. I have no evidence to disprove this claim that is based on systematic investigation of my own, but in all the years I spent as a copyeditor myself, it does not ring true, and was not consistent with my own experience in editing scholarly work in the humanities and social sciences. But Sandy, you were copy-editing books, and I was talking about journal articles (OA's target content)! And during those years you were copy-editing at Princeton, I was editing (a journal) at Princeton. My only evidence is from those 25 years: Lots of substantive errors were caught by the editor (me!), but that was part of the peer review, the editor being a super-peer. Negligibly few were ever caught by the copy-editors... Are the sciences any different? Not according to one editor who has worked on thousands of scientific articles, who commented on a draft of my article on "The Value Added by Copyediting" (Against the Grain, September 2008). Among other things, he testified that "even in highly technical articles 'the equations are usually accompanied by thickets of impenetrable prose,' and a lot of his work 'involves making sure that the text and the equations say the same thing.' He also adds that he checks 'the basic math in tables, since it's amazing how often scientists get the sums and averages wrong.'" There's a lot of awfully bad writing in science, alas, and the copy-editing is usually so light that it doesn't make the writing much better. But I said *substantive* errors, and the responsibility for catching those is the referees' (and editor's), not the copy-editor's. A study by Malcolm Wright and J. Scott Armstrong titled "Fawlty Towers of Knowledge" in the March/April 2008 issue of Interfaces also found high rates of errors in citations and quotations, partly because researchers relied on preprints and never bothered to check the accuracy of citations and quotations from those preprints. I would consider these "substantive errors," since they are not simply matters of style or grammar. So, I would ask Stevan whence his high degree of confidence in this claim derives. Nothing in my experience, or that of other editors I have asked, bears it out. Sandy and I clearly mean something different by "substantive errors": I wouldn't consider citation errors substantive (though it's certainly useful to correct them). I think citations and even quotations will be increasingly checked by software, online, as everything is made OA. But I agree that only the future will decide how much copy-editing service author/institutions will be prepared to pay for, if and when journal publishing downsizes to just peer-review (plus copy-editing) alone. Stevan Harnad
