The unexpectedly high figure is due to Ulrich's counting the print version and 
the electronic version of a journal title as separate journals.

Example (using a smaller dataset): a search for active journals which are 
academic/scholarly and peer reviewed/refereed filtered by Country of 
Publication=Ireland shows the total number of journals as 175.

These are listed in Ulrich's as comprising the following:

Print (77)
Online (65)
Microform (33)
LooseLeaf (1) 

However when the duplicate titles are (manually) removed from the downloaded 
spreadsheet the number of unique journal titles is 154.

Heather Morrison has commented on this issue here:

http://poeticeconomics.blogspot.ie/2012/05/about-30-of-peer-reviewed-scholarly.html

where she says:

'we don't have a count of how many peer-reviewed journals there are in the 
world. We tend to use Ulrich's as a surrogate, however this list reflects a 
strong English-language / western bias, e.g. Ulrich's would only include a very 
tiny fraction of the academic journals from China.

Something else to keep in mind is that is has become more difficult to assess 
the number of peer-reviewed journals in Ulrich's, because the default search 
does not deduplicate for multiple formats (i.e. a quick search for academic / 
peer-reviewed / scholarly journals will yield two titles when a journal is 
produced in both print and electronic form).

My latest count of active, peer-reviewed scholarly journals from Ulrich's using 
deduplication from Dec. 1, 2011 is 26,746. My method and calculations are shown 
here, in this appendix of my draft thesis:

http://pages.cmns.sfu.ca/heather-morrison/appendix-c-how-many-active-scholarly-peer-reviewed-journals/
 "

Heather's methodology looks like the best we can do with Ulrich's. However when 
her method is applied to my example above with the small dataset of Irish 
journals (77 print + 6 electronic only = 83) the result falls considerably 
short of the actual number of unique journal titles for that dataset (154 - 
deduplicated manually). Perhaps it works better with a larger dataset.

It would be very helpful if Ulrich's would provide a simple 'De-duplicate' 
option on its search results. 

Meanwhile it would be an easy matter for Ulrich's to provide us with the data. 
Let's ask them!

Best wishes,

Niamh









-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Niamh Brennan
Programme Manager, Research Information Systems & Services
Ussher Library, Second Floor,
Trinity College Library Dublin,
College Street,
Dublin 2
Ireland

phone: +353 1 896 1646
email: [email protected]
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________________________________
From: [email protected] [[email protected]] On Behalf Of Sally 
Morris [[email protected]]
Sent: 03 August 2012 21:53
To: 'Global Open Access List (Successor of AmSci)'
Subject: [GOAL] Re: Update on Ulrichs estimate of total number of active        
peer-reviewed journals: 55, 311

I find this figure very surprising.  What appears to be the same search, 
carried out this past March, came up with a (to me) much more credible figure 
of 27,566.

Sally


Sally Morris
South House, The Street, Clapham, Worthing, West Sussex, UK  BN13 3UU
Tel:  +44 (0)1903 871286
Email:  [email protected]


________________________________
From: [email protected] [mailto:[email protected]] On Behalf Of 
Stevan Harnad
Sent: 03 August 2012 20:08
To: Global Open Access List (Successor of AmSci)
Cc: LibLicense-L Discussion Forum
Subject: [GOAL] Update on Ulrichs estimate of total number of active 
peer-reviewed journals: 55, 311

For years now, I've just been re-using an old 
Ulrich<http://ulrichsweb.serialssolutions.com>'s estimate of about 25,000 for 
the total number of active peer-reviewed journals.

Prompted by a recent query from someone, I've checked again, and -- unless I've 
made a mistake in my search -- the number now seems to have doubled to 55,311.

The parameters I used to get this figure were (1) Active, (2) Journal, (3) 
Academic/Scholarly, (4) Refereed/Peer-reviewed,

A further breakdown shows that of these 55,311 active peer reviewed journals,

23,527 (43%) are available online

9,354 (17%) are indexed in Thomson-Reuters-ISI's Journal Citation reports

6,962 (13%) are open access journals (freely available online) (Gold OA, 
presumably not including Hybrid Gold).

769 (11%) of the 9,354 Thomson-Reuters-ISI-indexed journals are open access 
journals

--

According to the last estimate of journals indexed by SHERPA/ROMEO (which does 
not include all the journals indexed by Ulrichs, but does include most of the 
top journals indexed by Thomson-Reuters-ISI):

60% of journals recognize the author's right to provide immediate, un-embargoed 
open access upon self-archiving their final drafts in their institutional 
repositories.

--

It would be helpful if others could check and confirm these figures.

Stevan Harnad


_______________________________________________
GOAL mailing list
[email protected]
http://mailman.ecs.soton.ac.uk/mailman/listinfo/goal

Reply via email to