Begin forwarded message: > From: Jon Crowcroft jon.crowcroft -- cl.cam.ac.uk > Date: August 4, 2012 2:34:28 AM EDT > >> I agree 100% > > On Friday, August 3, 2012, Stevan Harnad <[email protected]: > > On 2012-08-03, at 7:33 AM, Jon Crowcroft wrote: > >> while I support the intention, for many of us who publsh with ACM and >> IEEE, we have been allowed to put open access copies in our own >> repositories for ages- but keep up the pressure on the "pay for >> publish" idea as its a) iniqutious rifling of the public purse and b) >> priced ludicrously high in any case... > > Why "but"? It sounds like you mean "and"! > > On no account should UK research funds be redirected to paying publishers > extra for "hybrid" Gold OA whilst they are already being paid more than > enough via subscriptions. > > And yes, all the ACM and IEEE journals are on the "side of the angels," > being among the 60% of journals that already recognize the author's right > to provide un-embargoed open access to the author's refereed final draft > immediately upon acceptance for publication ("Green OA"). > > The 40% of journals that still try to embargo Green OA, however, are no > longer the biggest problem. > > The biggest problem in the UK has very recently become the recommendations > of the Finch Committee, commissioned and accepted by the Science/Universities > Minister David Willets, recommending the phase-out of cost-free Green OA, > downgraded to digital preservation archiving, and instead mandating OA > exclusively > via "Gold" OA publishing, through extra payment out of the UK's scarce > research > funds. > > To compound this folly, RCUK, which formerly had a Green OA self-archiving > mandate > that had served as a model for the rest of the world, now proposes to mandate > that > UK fundees may only publish in journals that either offer Gold OA or allow > Green OA > (with a maximum embargo of 6-12 months), and if the journal offers Gold OA, > fundees > must chose paid Gold OA over cost-free Green OA. > > (May I post this reply to the cphc list?) > > Stevan Harnad > > Stevan Harnad typed: > > > On 2012-08-01, at 10:42 AM, David De Roure wrote: > > Hi Stevan - I confirm that this talk has been scheduled for Tuesday = > September 11th. > The Digital Research 2012 website is = > http://digital-research.oerc.ox.ac.uk/=20 > > Dear Dave, > > Thanks, here's my the title and abstract for my DR2102 keynote. (Can I = > assume that the time will be Tuesday morning 9-10:30?) > > Best wishes, > > Stevan > > > Digital Research: How and Why the RCUK Open Access Policy Needs to Be = > Revised > > The Web is destined to become humankind's Cognitive Commons, where = > digital knowledge is jointly created and freely shared. The UK has been = > a leader in the global movement toward Open Access (OA) to research but = > very recently its leadership has been derailed by the joint influence of = > the publishing industry lobby from without and well-intentioned but = > premature and counterproductive over-reaching from within the OA = > movement itself. The result has been the extremely counter-productive = > Finch Committee Report followed by a new draft of the RCUK OA policy, = > downgrading the role of cost-free OA self-archiving of research = > publications ("Green OA") in favour of paying subscription publishers = > extra money, over and above subscriptions, out of scarce research funds, = > in exchange for making single articles OA ("hybrid Gold OA"). The = > motivation is to reform publication and to gain certain re-use rights, = > but the likely effect will be researcher resistance, very little OA, a = > waste of scarce research funds and the loss of the UK's global = > leadership in the OA movement. There is still time to fix the RCUK = > policy. I will try to describe how and why. > > Berners-Lee, T., De Roure, D., Harnad, S. and Shadbolt, N. (2005) = > Journal publishing and author self-archiving: Peaceful Co-Existence and = > Fruitful Collaboration.=20 > =09 > =E2=80=A8Shadbolt, N., Brody, T., Carr, L. and Harnad, S. (2006) The = > Open Research Web: A Preview of the Optimal and the Inevitable, in = > Jacobs, N., Ed. Open Access: Key Strategic, Technical and Economic = > Aspects Chandos.=20 > > Harnad, Stevan (2012) Research Works Act H.R.3699: The Private = > Publishing Tail Trying To Wag The Public Research Dog, Yet Again. = > Technical Report, ECS, University of Southampton=20 > > Harnad, Stevan (2012) Why the UK Should Not Heed the Finch Report. LSE = > Impact of Social Sciences Blog, Summer Issue=20 > > Poynder, Richard (2012) OA advocate Stevan Harnad withdraws support for = > RCUK policy. Open and Shut July 26 2012=20
_______________________________________________ GOAL mailing list [email protected] http://mailman.ecs.soton.ac.uk/mailman/listinfo/goal
