Journal titles are not designer "brands": They are earned track-records for peer-review quality standards.
Track records for peer review have to be established across years of maintaining a peer review quality standard; they are not established overnight by creating a new journal title and publishing a few good articles. There may sometimes be a correlation between journal impact factor and journal peer-review quality standards, but neither the small magnitude of that correlation nor its misuse has anything to do with the need for time and evidence to establish a journal's track-record for quality before the title itself earns its correlation with quality. Stevan Harnad On Thu, Nov 8, 2012 at 7:28 AM, Ross Mounce <[email protected]> wrote: > What's wrong with a high quality, peer-reviewed RCUK-funded article > appearing in a 'faceless' journal with the word 'Open' in it? > > If the traditional publishers won't allow CC BY for a reasonable price > then of course new 'faceless' entrants will offer more value for money gold > OA venues of equivalent technical quality. > > I for one would quite like this change. Articles would have to be judged > on their own merits for once, rather than the journal impact factor of the > journal they appear in. > > As long as its good content, peer-reviewed and available as CC BY with a > DOI, article landing page and a few other technical things - I think this > would be good. Articles don't need 'face' branded journals to have > intellectual merit. > > My .02 > > Ross > > PS who or what are the 'gold oa pack'? Do supporters of OA really have to > be so divisive? > On Nov 8, 2012 12:12 PM, "Steve Hitchcock" <[email protected]> wrote: > >> Having feasted on Kent Anderson's anti-OA, anti-eLife and anti-PMC views, >> thanks to Richard Poynder's interview, the gold OA pack are now descending >> on Nature for having the temerity to charge a higher price for CC-BY OA >> than for, say, CC-BY-NC-ND >> http://www.nature.com/press_releases/cc-licenses.html >> >> "what’s really outrageous about this: they’re explicitly charging MORE >> for applying/allowing a CC BY license relative to the more restrictive >> licenses. Applying a license to a digital work costs nothing. By charging >> £100-400 more for CC BY they’re really taking the piss – charging more for >> ABSOLUTELY NO ADDITIONAL EFFORT on their part. Horrid. Other than greed >> what is the justification for this?" >> http://rossmounce.co.uk/2012/11/07/gold-oa-pricewatch/ >> >> Apparently Nature has a brand value it is ready to exploit, and we >> haven't yet learned that it's rights we are paying for with gold OA, not OA >> itself. >> >> Or perhaps we have learned that lesson, and the new game is to squash >> brand value. A PLOS representative apparently says at #berlin10sa "it's not >> about where you publish it's about who you reach". In other words, make the >> venue irrelevant? >> >> @PLOSBiology The @wellcometrust values the merits of the article over the >> journal it is published in - Chris Bird at #berlin10sa >> >> Another anti-OA cook had already spotted, and applauded, this strategy >> (see penultimate paragraph) >> >> http://scholarlykitchen.sspnet.org/2012/11/06/why-did-publishers-get-so-big/ >> >> Meanwhile, the #altmetrics movement gathers steam with the idea that we >> can measure some new things even if we don't yet know what those things >> might mean. But one goal is clear: disconnect the impact calculation from >> the venue and reconnect it to the paper. Actually, it is about time that we >> moved on from the journal impact factor, but is that the simple agenda here? >> >> I suspect this is not where Finch and its publishers, and RCUK, think >> they are heading with their vision of hybrid gold OA. That approach is >> going to price some authors out of their familiar, favourite journals; the >> emerging alternative is those journals may not be there for them at all, to >> be replaced with faceless collections like (name your publisher) OPEN. >> >> Straws in the wind, or connected? >> >> Steve Hitchcock >> WAIS Group, Building 32 >> School of Electronics and Computer Science >> University of Southampton, SO17 1BJ, UK >> Email: [email protected] >> Twitter: @stevehit >> Connotea: http://www.connotea.org/user/stevehit >> Tel: +44 (0)23 8059 9379 Fax: +44 (0)23 8059 9379 >> >> _______________________________________________ >> GOAL mailing list >> [email protected] >> http://mailman.ecs.soton.ac.uk/mailman/listinfo/goal >> > > _______________________________________________ > GOAL mailing list > [email protected] > http://mailman.ecs.soton.ac.uk/mailman/listinfo/goal > >
_______________________________________________ GOAL mailing list [email protected] http://mailman.ecs.soton.ac.uk/mailman/listinfo/goal
