I think that Stevan's definitive statement should close that discussion once and for all. It is crystal clear. Period.
Jean-Claude Guédon ________________________________ De : [email protected] [[email protected]] de la part de Stevan Harnad [[email protected]] Envoyé : jeudi 28 novembre 2013 08:05 À : LibLicense-L Discussion Forum Objet : [GOAL] Immediate-Deposit Mandates In No Way Constrain Authors' Publishing Options On 2013-11-26, Rick Anderson <[email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>> wrote: Stevan Harnad: "Independent and critical thinking" researchers will act according to the evidence: depend on it. They may be slow, but they are not stupid…" RA: Not only do I agree that they're not stupid, I wouldn't even say that they're slow. And as for acting according to the evidence, I couldn't agree with you more. In my experience talking about these issues with faculty researchers, their ambivalence about OA is based neither on stupidity nor on slowness, but on an insufficiency of evidence that OA is always and necessarily the answer. Researchers tend to see OA models as presenting a mixed bag of upsides and downsides (as any publishing model does). Researchers are generally smart and quick enough to immediately recognize, for example, that mandates constrain their publishing options, so they approach mandate proposals cautiously. One way they demonstrate caution is by insisting that such mandates include powerful escape clauses, thus turning them into "mandates" rather than mandates. (1) That making one's articles accessible online to all potential users is preferable to making them accessible only to subscribers is a no-brainer to figure out, with no further need of evidence, speed or sapience (though plenty<http://opcit.eprints.org/oacitation-biblio.html> of evidence<http://oabutton.wordpress.com> is available) The ones insisting that "further" evidence is needed to "prove" this are only the ones with a vested interest in the subscriptions or the subscription income. (2) What takes a bit more thought concerns what to do about publisher embargoes on authors providing (Green) OA. Researchers have been much slower to realize that they can provide Green OA without any constraint whatsoever on their publishing options: by depositing their refereed final drafts in their institutional repositories immediately upon acceptance for publication, whether or not the publisher embargoes Green OA, and making access closed (only the metadata are OA) if the author wishes to comply with a publisher embargo on OA. (3) During any OA embargo, the repository's automated copy-request Button ("Almost-OA Button<http://t.co/4LoFmhWkx5>") allows any would-be user to request and any willing author to provide a copy with just one click each. (4) Hence immediate institutional deposit can be mandated by all institutions and all funders without any constraint on researchers' publishing options. (5) The "escape clause" is only required for the "copyright reservation" policies (like Harvard's and MIT's), which are adopted by faculty consensus. Although the reported opt-out rate is only 5%, such policies do notionally constrain researchers' publishing options, if the publisher refuses to publish their papers under those conditions, or the author does not wish to try. (6) But Harvard and MIT also have an immediate-deposit clause, which requires immediate-deposit even if the authors opt out of the copyright-reservation clause. The purpose of the immediate-deposit<https://www.google.ca/search?hl=en&lr=&q=harnad%20OR%20Harnad%20OR%20archivangelism+blogurl:http://openaccess.eprints.org/&ie=UTF-8&tbm=blg&tbs=qdr:m&num=100&c2coff=1&safe=active#c2coff=1&hl=en&lr=&q=%22immediate+deposit%22+blogurl:http://openaccess.eprints.org/&safe=active&tbm=blg> mandate (Liege<http://orbi.ulg.ac.be/handle/2268/102031>/HEFCE<https://www.google.ca/search?hl=en&lr=&q=harnad%20OR%20Harnad%20OR%20archivangelism+blogurl:http://openaccess.eprints.org/&ie=UTF-8&tbm=blg&tbs=qdr:m&num=100&c2coff=1&safe=active#c2coff=1&hl=en&lr=&q=hefce+immediate+blogurl:http://openaccess.eprints.org/&safe=active&tbm=blg> model) is to accelerate and motivate researchers in doing what is in their own best interests anyway, once they have thought it through -- as you yourself have not yet done, Rick, in not knowing, or not having understood the difference between the copyright-reservation clause and the immediate-deposit clause, and their respective implications for publishing options as well as for potential research uptake and impact. Stevan Harnad _______________________________________________ GOAL mailing list [email protected] http://mailman.ecs.soton.ac.uk/mailman/listinfo/goal
