========================================================================
You can post to GoaNet. Send in your views and comments to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
========================================================================

On Sun, 3 Nov 2002 [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

> Fred raises some interesting issues, but IMHO it is a disgrace for Bikram 
> Lamba, if he is an Indian, to venture into issues that are not only 
> provocative but incorrect.
> 
> Mississauga has a sizable Goan population, who should insist that the 
> publisher retract and/or correct the gross errors cited earlier on Goanet. 
> Otherwise, they will be compounded, through the multiplier effect, not only 
> among Mississauga News' readers but globally.

Just to take the debate forward...

I might not be so harsh in judging Lamba. It's just that each one of us
has a way of defining 'culture' and 'community' in the way we perceive
it. Can it be said that one interpretation is any more valid than the
other? My earlier argument was aimed at saying that there are many
different ways of interpreting what might appear to be a common
reality. That language is a new border for defining people of western
coastal India (beyond Goa), with all its implications....

Apart from the minor errors that Jorge pointed out to, that obviously
crept in unintentionally, the piece is just another way of defining
identity (based on language). Of course, defining identity is alway a
controversial and probably political task.

But then, we don't complain when the writer's biases tally with ours, do
we? FN

----------------------------------------------------------
What's On In Goa (WOIG): 
Nov 05 onwards: Wendell Rodrigues Festival. Altinho, Panjim
Nov 05 Bobbin lace-making training, Don Bosco's Panjim (till 17.11)
Nov 06 Richard Stallman, free software guru, speaks Farmagudi 4 pm
Nov 06 Bob Fitts, gospel music singer, Navelim grounds, 6 pm
Nov 06 Fr Britto's health courses, Pilar. Till 10.11. Later Chicalim.
Nov 06 ArtHouse, Calangute: Chaitali's acrylics on canvas till 19.11
Nov 07 Creative science, for children, Goa Sc Centre (till 16.11)
Nov 17 Goan Engineers and Assoc meet, at Pickering, Canada.
Nov 20 Fr Agnelo's 75th death anniversary, Pilar
Dec 01 Two day conference, Goa Agenda. IT For Society. (Ends 2.12) 
Every Sunday: Music therapy sessions at Moira, 5 pm. 278, N.Portugal

----------------------------------------------------------

Reply via email to