Warning: I am retaining a small part of a very long post that most netters must have simply skipped reading. The Goanet is no sociology class to hold sustained interest in such issues...at length.
Dear Netters, I read the article in the oHeraldo and again on the goanet. It is a good essay ...and sociologically sound. I would agree fully with Zarine Chinvala were I to be living in Utopia. Unfortunately for all of us, this is Goa in India. The percapita income is high thanks to the rich mine owners raking in the moolah. A contract teacher in a vocational stream earns Rs.4000/-[US$80] per month.If s/he is working 'part time'[although without any other source of income] the monthly[not daily!] package is Rs.1000/-[ US$20].One part-time teacher that I know has been working on that handsome "salary" for the last two years hoping to hit the jackpot....a full-time job with salary for 11 months of a year! In such a circumstance, how and with what does one 'rehabilitate' a prostitute or a pimp that will be rendered 'unemployed' by a High Court order? Yes, I fully agree that the prostitutes when sent back to Andhra Pradesh, Soundatti[Karnataka] or where ever they come from, may get dispersed to other places and be difficult to track and may spread AIDS all over the country. If they remain in Baina they are easier to track, but the AIDS problem is spreading all over the country all the same. Baina is no "Goa for Goans" territory: it has national and international clientele. A few years back, Primary School teachers from Maharashtra had come to Baina in their jeeps[ banners and all!] after a 'adhiveshen' to do a practical study on the pre-New Year performance of these prostitutes, the price range of their services and the possibilities of group discounts well before the 'charter' business had hit Goa with the sledgehammer. Goan lads are no 'whited sepulchres'.They also conquer prostitutes in foreign lands. A poor widow's dole under DSSS is Rs.500/-[US$10] per month, our freedom fighters get six times as much. A 'good' prostitute's earnings will surpass the DSS pension in a day and that of a freedom fighter in a week. Rehabilitation will have to be comensurate to that to be interesting. They will have to be paid more for their 'idle capacity' than we can afford for our elders. Can the state afford it? It is one thing financing an NGO with 10 staff members, another to look after thousands of prostitutes who need no degrees to qualify for rehabilitation.Being involved in an NGO for a decade, I know how much more difficult it is to get money to plant ten trees than to have a conference for a hundred people. Which international agency that funds studies on gender issues or human trafficking will fund a rehab. programme?? If there is one, let us send the link to Chandrababu Naidu in tandem with the denizens of his state now in a miserable state in Baina. Such funding will also break the back-bone of PWG, MCC and a myriad of 'senas'....or convert each of them into a NGO to channelize the funds. ARZ is doing a good job.Let it not go overboard with it. Just because a little is good; a lot is not always better. Viva Goa. Miguel Date: Sun, 23 Nov 2003 09:30:52 +0530 (IST) > From: "Frederick Noronha (FN)" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > Subject: [Goanet]COMMENT: Beneath the surface at Baina (Zarine Chinvala) > By Zarine Chinvala > > Trafficking and prostitution are the source of, and outcome of, extreme human rights violations for the victims involved. This has been constantly reflected at the Baina beach red light area where Arz has been witness to crass exploitation in the form of child prostitution, violence, rape, addictions, high suicide rates, and life threatening diseases. > > Therefore, any victim of commercial sexual exploitation needs to be protected from such extreme exploitation while she remains in the situation or removing her from prostitution, if she so desires, with adequate sustainable rehabilitation. These persons are not the prostituted women, but perpetrators -- brothel keepers, pimps, trafficking agents, customers, and mards. Prostituted women are victims of an organized crime. > Demolishing red light areas has been tried out in other parts of the country > (during our research). It is easily forgotten that prostitution is a consequence of social and economic pressures, trafficking is an organized crime and that it is a trade > that is strongly established on years of networks of demand and supply. The > focus on the roots of the crime is lost and the victims are further victimized. > > There's reason to be concerned about the High Court order calling for > 'eviction', 'deportation'. Here are some things that could be done. > > * The community at Baina Beach is not a homogeneous one but consists of > different groups. A large sub group may consist of those, especially from Andhra Pradesh, who may opt for rehabilitation options in their states of origin, if the options provided are immediate and sustainable. > > *There is another sub group that is residential in Goa and has no roots in any other state, which may also want rehabilitation. *One sub group based in Goa may desire to not accept any options and continue in the same trade. *Another large group not related to the trade but resides in the area must be provided rehabilitation in the state. > > * The directions of the High Court be appropriately implemented without > causing human rights violations. * Survey needs to be done by an apt agency with knowledge and experience of > research, and having a rapport with the groups concerned. > > * Comprehensive planning and monitoring of implementation is needed. * There is a need to look at this issue not of eradication of the prostitution at Baina beach, but one of spread of trafficking and prostitution through the state of Goa. Our group, Arz, offers all professional help to ensure that trafficking in humans can be controlled in the state of Goa. > > [TISS-trained social worker Zarine Chinvala is known for her work from the > thick of the red light quarter of Baina. She is part of Arz, an organisation > working for some time now in that misunderstood area.] > --- Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free. Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com). Version: 6.0.530 / Virus Database: 325 - Release Date: 10/22/2003 --- Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free. Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com). Version: 6.0.543 / Virus Database: 337 - Release Date: 11/21/2003 ########################################################################## # Send submissions for Goanet to [EMAIL PROTECTED] # # PLEASE remember to stay on-topic (related to Goa), and avoid top-posts # # More details on Goanet at http://joingoanet.shorturl.com/ # # Please keep your discussion/tone polite, to reflect respect to others # ##########################################################################
