Christians, and how they're seen By Chottebhai
Ask the average Indian what they think of the Christian in India, and you will probably get the reply "peace-loving." Dig a little further and you will probably be told that they are a contented lot, who don't easily get agitated or involved in public life. You may also hear that they are not particularly ambitious. One must sound a warning that images may or may not be grounded in reality. There is one image that often comes to mind. When somebody wants to depict persons of different religions certain stereotypes are used. A Hindu is depicted with a tilak, chutiya and perhaps wearing a dhoti. A Muslim is depicted with a beard and achkan; while a Sikh is easily identifiable with a turban and beard. There are two caricatures used for indicating a Christian -- either a young man with a hat, suit and tie, or a woman with a cross dangling from her neck. Mercifully, the earlier image, the topi-tiewallah seems to be receding. This is because the Christians were among the first to adopt western culture and dress; particularly form the Goa-Bombay coast to those areas in north India where Christianity came in the wake of the British. With the advent of cable TV and exposure to a cross cultural world order almost all communities have opted for a dress form that is more user friendly -- read, a western garb. I see the depiction of a cross, as the distinguishing mark of a Christian in India, as something very significant. It indicates that Indian Christianity has come of age, that it is not confined to any culture, and can assimilate itself in any one. Eighty years ago Gandhiji had said that he liked Christ but not Christians. Which Christians was Gandhiji exposed to? The kind who adopted garishly western norms, when Jaikishans became Jacksons; when one would say, "Johnny, Tony, Topi, Tie, Main Hoon Isaibhai"! If you were a Christian, you were a beef-eater, no less. I wonder what Gandhiji would say about Indian Christians today! Going by my close links with veteran Gandhians, I think that Gandhiji today would have felt very close to Christians. In the West, Gandhiji is considered a true Christian, and I share that sentiment. Christian activists in India are ideologically very close to the Gandhians. Fifty years ago, the Christians of Kerala felt that the atheistic communists were their arch-enemies. After Vatican II, and the advent of Liberation Theology, the Marxists and Christians again find themselves on the same wavelength, because India's particular brand of Marxism is theistic to the core! What does all this mean? These are dancing images, prancing horses for Hussain, difficult to rein in. Images change with time and context, as do inter-personal relationships. About 20 years ago the Kanpur Catholic Association had conducted a survey to ascertain what non-Christians thought of us. The results were a pleasant surprise that the public perception of Christians was far more positive than we had allowed ourselves to believe. If one goes by the number of visitors to a Christian home on Christmas day, the long queues for admission in our schools and hospitals, and the number of non-Christian devotees at Marian shrines, one is left with no other choice than to conclude that, over all, Indian Christians enjoy a healthy public image. There have been two criticisms of Indian Christians that we need to face squarely -- foreign funds and religious conversions. It is estimated that Christian organisations in India receive about Rs 2500 crores per annum in foreign aid. This is something that non-Christians resent. The public image was that these vast funds were used for fraudulent or coercive religious conversions, and compromised one's loyalty to the nation because of allegiance to foreign masters. Now that Hindutva organisations are tapping rich NRIs, and with globalisation's shrinking effect, the criticism of foreign funds has lost its cutting edge. The conversions bogey, as we know only too well, is a malicious propaganda used for gaining political mileage. Census of India figures are the most authentic ones to ascertain the growth of religious groupings. And the facts are before us. The Christian population of India actually increased after Independence from 2.4% in 1961 to 2.6% in 1971. Thereafter it reverted to 2.4% in 1981 and slipped to 2.3% in 1991. The Government of India has not released the figures for the 2001 Census, perhaps because in runs contrary to its political propaganda. The Christian decadal growth date from 1981 to 1991 at 16.89% was 5.21%, below the national average of 22.10%. i At the recent All India Catholic Union annual general meeting at Chennai I had moved a resolution asking the Government to release the religious figures of the 2001 Census, failing which AICU would seek redress from the Supreme Court. The AICU must exert itself to bring out the facts, counter the false propaganda, and rectify our public image on this score. If I may be permitted to digress a bit, I find that the decline in Christian percentage in India from 1971 dovetails neatly into the Catholic Church's changed perception of evangelisation after Vatican II (1962-65). There are two more public images that I would like to highlight. Thirty years ago I often heard non-Christian leaders exhorting the public to work with "missionary zeal". Perhaps these old timers had actually witnessed foreign missionaries making great sacrifices for the poor among whom they worked. Unfortunately, I no longer hear this term being used in public. Are we now flagging in our zeal? Even the word "missionary" has become redundant, more easily replaceable with institutional "machinery". The other term is common usage was "convent educated", since corrupted and abbreviated to "convented" in matrimonial ads. Earlier, by convent education was understood an all round grooming and education for girls, who were denied that opportunity. Today so many have jumped on to the convent bandwagon that we have names like "Shri Atal Behari Convent School" in every gully in our towns and urban conglomerates. "Convent" is no longer associated with a group of dedicated Catholic religious women. It is now a synonym for elitist education. The oldest Catholic institution in my hometown of Kanpur is St. Mary's Convent. It was colloquially known as Bhaktin School, the school run by devotees. Again I must confess that I have not heard the term "Bhaktin" used for the last forty odd years. Times have changed, and so has our public image. I leave you to draw your own conclusions. IN THE MEDIA: The most enduring Image of Indian Christians is that churned out by Bollywood. It is very true that Bollywood movies often depicted Christians as Julie the mini-skirted vamp or Tony the drunkard or bootlegger. Several organisations have objected to Bollywood producers about these stereotypes, and the trend has definitely changed for the better. Some Christian leaders and organisation over-react to lighthearted banter, like the nun in the Hero Honda ad. But we need to ask ourselves a very relevant question: "Why is our Media Image different from our public image?" We need to understand how Bollywood movies are made, and by whom. The big names in Bollywood were Punjabis -- like the Kapoors and Chopras. Christians in Punjab were basically Majbi Sikh (Dalit) converts. They were landless agricultural workers, and even sanitation workers, concentrated in Gurdaspur, Amritsar and Lahore (now in Pakistan) districts. One doubts the Kapoor khandan had any contact with Punjabi Christians. Hence their image of Christians is what they found in and around their film studios in Mumbai; and we cannot deny that the ones to wear micro-miniskirts were mostly Catholics in the late 'sixties and 'seventies. I lived in Bombay for some two years during the height of the mini era. Why blame Bollywood? Our very own Mario Miranda always portrayed the office secretary -- which most girls then were -- as Miss Fonseca with a big bustline and short dress. Cartoonists, painters, film directors go by images, real or imaginary. Have you ever seen a cartoon by Laxman showing politicians in good light? Bollywood's caricatures are not limited to Christians. Sardars were depicted as guffawing truck drivers, Banias as avaricious, Thakurs as cruel, Parsis as kinky, and Muslims as benign chachas. This was the era of masala action movies, or mushy romances. This was also the time when communities had very little interaction with each other. We therefore tended to accentuate the differences that stood out, rather than the commonalties. Besides, who would go to see a Bollywood movie in which the entire cast was in straight jackets? I do not seek to justify the Bollywood image, but am attempting to understand it a little more objectively. It must also be said, that as with our public image, our media image has also metamorphosed over time. Film audiences have matured, forcing directors to change track -- to be more realistic. It is a positive development. THE PRESS: Our media image is certainly not restricted to Bollywood. The English-language press, be they dailies or journals, are largely supportive, appreciative and sensitive to the Christian community in India. Could this be because several of its staffers have studied in Christian schools? Maybe. What of the vernacular press? This is the danger zone. Particularly in north India, the vernacular press has been hostile to Christians and Christian issues like conversions. Hindi papers report events differently from national level English-language dailies. They are more parochial in their views. During the recent riots in Gujarat it is reported that the Gujarati language papers played a very big role in inflaming passions against the Muslims. Hence I appreciate the initiative of Christian journalists in Ahmedabad, led by the redoubtable Jesuits, to build up a Gujarati language media front. In like manner, Satya Manthan Sansthan, inspired by Bishop Patrick D'Souza of Varanasi, has been bringing out a series of booklets in Hindi, seeking to correct common misconceptions. Dainik Jagran is the second largest Hindi daily, and it is based in my hometown of Kanpur. There were times when it spewed venom on Christians. Its editor, the late Narendra Mohan (not Modi), was even rewarded with a seat in the Rajya Sabha by the BJP. He knew my family well; so about six years ago he invited me over to his office to "discuss" Christian issues. We called it a satsang. I went armed with documentation. He quoted from the statements of firebrand but obscure American evangelists that denounced "pagans" and hollered for conversions. I presented him with the Census data that I have quoted herein above. I also read out passages from Vatican II documents, which I explained were the official teachings of the Catholic Church. He was astounded. His face went red with embarrassment and his countenance fell. He was being confronted with truth that was contrary to his prejudices. I clearly recall quoting form the Declaration On Religious Freedom, which states, "It is one of the major tenets of Catholic doctrine that man's response to God in faith must be free. Therefore no one is to be forced to embrace the Christian faith against his own will. This doctrine is contained in the Word of God and it was constantly proclaimed by the fathers of the Church" (DH No.9). I also quoted to him from the Declaration on the Relationship of the Church to Non-Christian Religions. Referring to Hinduism and Buddhism it states, "The Catholic Church rejects nothing, which is true and holy in these religions. She looks with sincere respect upon those ways of conduct and life, those rules and teachings which, thought differing in many particulars from what she holds and sets forth, nevertheless often reflect a ray of that Truth which enlightens all men? The Church therefore has this exhortation for her sons: prudently and lovingly, through dialogue and collaboration with the followers of other religions, and in witness of Christian faith and life, acknowledge, preserve and promote the spiritual and moral good found among these men, as well as the values in their society and culture" (NA 2). Subsequently I had another satsang with this editor, this time accompanied by a seminary professor who was well versed with in-culturation and inter-religious dialogue. I dare to believe that these satsangs had some impact in toning down his anti- Christian rhetoric. -- Chottebhai, born as Allan Noronha but more widley known by his assumed name, traces his roots to the Goan village of Aldona, and is based in Kanpur, where his family set up the Noronha Sandan at Krishnanagar. He is a campaigner on Christian issues. This article is excerpted from Vishal Jagruti. Chottebhai can be contacted via email noronha<at>vsnl.com ########################################################################## # Send submissions for Goanet to [EMAIL PROTECTED] # # PLEASE remember to stay on-topic (related to Goa), and avoid top-posts # # More details on Goanet at http://joingoanet.shorturl.com/ # # Please keep your discussion/tone polite, to reflect respect to others # ##########################################################################
