--- samir_kelekar <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:

> The concept of black smoke, white smoke to indicate the election of the Pope 
> is quite funny. 


Samir, 

There is a language and race element being overlooked.  One can ask why is 
black smoke chosen to
signal failure (non-election of the Pope) and white smoke to signal success.  
Why not the other
way around?  One finds racial connotations in the use of language, as in "black 
death" to describe
the plague. On the other hand to soften, even forgive a falsehood, is called a 
"little white lie".
To commit certain crimes is considered a "black mark" on one's record.  Why not 
"white mark"? 
This is to associate black people with crime. There are many other examples. It 
is unfortunate we
do not pay attention to language, especially its hidden racial, sexist, aegist 
overtones.  Yes,
black smoke to denote failure is not outside our racial prejudices, including 
the Vatican's bias
for reserving its highest honors of Popes, saints for Europeans (whites).

Regards,
George



Reply via email to