------------------------------------------------------------------------
Goanetters visiting Viva Goa 2006 in Toronto, Canada on July 29, can use
the BMX booth as a meeting point. Please list your name on the message
board that will be provided, courtesy of BMX.
http://bmxgoa.com
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Dear Fred:
I will provide another example of the mischiveous and
biased "fact finding" reports circulated by PUCL and
its associated orgnization (I call them associated
because the PUCL website carries this report)
Please read the full report at
http://www.pucl.org/Topics/Religion-communalism/2003/sholapur.htm
witha
open mind .
On 11 octber 2002, a mob of muslims protesting against
the remarks of jerry Falwell against Prophet Muhammad,
attacked and ranssacked hindu properties and religious
places. A total of 11 people were killed ,over 150
injured and 500 arrested. Amongst the dead were a Shiv
sena shakha pramukh who was stabbed to death while 5
muslims died in the police firing.
The fact finding report says the following:
"The natural question that arises is that can a small
timer politician like M. D. Sheikh with his minor
paper like Dainik Bandhuprem and an organization like
MVP can on its own heat so influence the Muslim masses
as to come on roads and indulge into rioting with such
ferocity as described in the Press and narrated by the
Hindu victims like Narsingh Mengjis family. No
reasonable person can answer this question in
affirmative"
SO HERE THE COMMITTEE IS QUESTIONING THE CREDIBILITY
OF THE VICTIMS THEMSELVES WHO FOR A CHANGE HAPPENED TO
BE HINDUS! NARSING MENGJI IS THE EX BJP MLC OF THE
AREA AND IF HIS HOUSE COULD BE BURNT DOWN , THE
NATURAL ANSWER IS THAT THE RIOTEERS WERE MUSLIMS, NOR
RSS ACTIVISTS.
"Except for a case of stabbing of Shiv Sena Shakha
pramukh Chandrakant Mhetre in Vishnu Nagar and burning
of house of Narsingh Mengji, Ex-MLC of BJP there was
no case of significant damage from Muslim mobs that we
come across. There were of course allegations of
goddess idols being broken, the photographs of some of
them having been already published by some papers."
THE SAME REPORT CLEARLY MENTIONED BEFORE THAT "Around
the same time, a mob attacked a pandal of Shraddhanand
Navratra Mahotsav Mandal in Vijapur Ves. The police
had to resort to firing in air to disperse the mob"
SO IF THE MUSLIM MOB ATTACKED A NAVRATRI MANDAL ISNT
IT PLAUSIBLE THAT ALLEGATIONS OF GODDESS IDOLS BEING
BROKE COULD BE TRUE? ALSO IF A SHIV SENA PRAMUKH COULD
BE STABBED TO DEATH AND A TOP BJP LEADERS HOUSE COULD
BE BURNT DOWN DOESNT IT MEAN THAT MUSLIMS WERE THE
ONES WHO WERE LEADING THE RIOTS?
" Some people outside Vishnu Nagar however told us
that his (Shiv sena leader Mhetres)murder was executed
by his own people taking cover of the riots. It was
beyond our means to verify this."
CLASSIC TACTIC OF BLAMING THE VICTIM HIMSELF,WE DID
HEAR THE SAME EXPLANANTION in case of godhra that the
train was burnt by BJP activists themselves,FURTHER
ISNT IT PROBABLE THAT MUSLIMS TOO ATTACKED FELLOW
MUSLIMS TAKING COVER OF RIOTS IN SHOLAPUR AND
ELSEWHERE?
"It appears that in the earlier communal riots also
Mengjis had become the chosen target of Muslim mobs.
One had to naturally ask why the entire anger of the
Muslim community is directed towards them. The answer
did not come from Mengjis. They appeared to accuse
Congress for lending tacit support to Muslims in their
ire against the BJP. The information that we gathered
reveals that Narsingh Mengji is a very vocal advocate
of Hindutva politics and represents its face in
Sholapur. He is the person who led people from
Sholapur area to Ayodhya in 1992 and participated in
destruction of Babri Masjid. The BJP leadership in
Sholapur talked about teaching lesson to Landyas on
the Gujarat pattern as claimed by the CPM leader Com.
Adam Master. This cumulative information can profile
Mr. Narsingh Mengji and explain how Muslims take him.
IT IS NOW CLEAR THAT THERE WERE RIOTS IN SOLAPUR EVEN
BEFORE GUJARAT HAPPENED,AND MUSLIM MOBS WERE ACTIVE
AND THEY HAD TARGETTED THE BJP LEADERS HOUSE BEFORE
CLEARLY INDICATING WHO WERE THE DOMINANT PARTY IN THE
RIOTS FURTHER THE REPORT "NATURALLY" ASKS THE QUESTION
WHY A MOB HAS TARGETTED A POLITICIANS HOUSE IN THE
PAST THE REPORT IMPLICITLY SUGGESTS THAT THE BJP
LEADER HAD IT COMING BECAUSE OF HIS POLITICAL
LEANINGS.THAT IS IS "NATURAL" THAT IF yOU BELIEVE IN A
PARTICULAR IDEOLOGY YOU ARE A LEGITIMATE TARGET OF
MUSLIM MOBS.
MY COMMENTS:
every fact finding report released by PUCL either
blames RSS or the State machinery, and every tme
muslims and chrstians are the innocent victims. I
wanted to see one report in which the perpetrators of
the violence were muslims.
As the above report shows the PUCL and its allied
organizations are highly biased towards one particular
political ideology.The above report is not only
blatantly biased but allmost justifies the vicous
assaults carried out by fanatic muslim mobs against
hindus in Solapur when the issue was protesting
against jerry falwell remarks
-vivek
__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around
http://mail.yahoo.com
_______________________________________________
Goanet mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.goanet.org/listinfo.cgi/goanet-goanet.org
