From: "Francis Rodrigues" Dear Jose, I know you as a kind, caring physician. However I do also recognize that arguing with you is a thankless task all round - for the reader, the writer, the netter. Why don't you stick to medicine, and leave the law to others?
Your patient (RB) is not terminal - as yet. I'm sure he does not need you to defend him, his vocal chords are yet in order - we have been hearing them loud enough in cyberspace for half a dozen years now ! It is time to let him speak for himself. Secondhand is second-guessing. You asked for proof of your patient's WGD claims. When supplied you did not refute them. Now you are being disingenuous again, quoting the letter of the law. Let's cut to the chase - a simple yes or no will do. Is Rene Barretto the founder and originator of the World Goa Day idea ? Has WGD done anything concrete for Goa? Kind regards, Francis. ==== Dear Francis, With due respect, I do not see why I (jc) should have to stick to medicine. >From what I see, You (Francis) have claimed (expressly or impliedly) the propriety (of the WGD idea) on your behalf (or another) on the basis of International Property laws. Can you defend that claim? Next, you (Francis) have accused Rene of Theft. Can you prove that accusations? jc doesn't know who is "the founder and originator of the World Goa Day idea" jc couldn't care less .... You (Francis) on the other hand have claimed that Rene is NOT "the founder and originator of the World Goa Day idea" It probably means a lot to you.... BUT can you prove that he is NOT? I regret to inform you Francis ....that you might be right about arguing with me. It is indeed Thankless....especially when You cannot defend an accusation you make against another. It is also.... a way out ....or as some may call it ....'an escape clause' I will assume - based on the discussion we have had thus far - that unless proved otherwise: 1: You (Francis) do NOT have ANY Claim (on your behalf or that of another) with regards to being "the founder and originator of the World Goa Day idea". 2: You have falsely accused Rene of Theft (and I'm sure you know what that means) of "the founder and originator of the World Goa Day idea" If anyone else had made that accusation, it would have been excusable. But ...you are a lawyer. Surely you know what entails the IP claims and Theft accusations. Do you not? Hence.... unless you submit the Proof of Theft or withdraw this accusation, it is indeed pointless continuing this controversy with jc. Since jc did not start it, it is NOT up to jc to end it. One final note ....with due respect, please be advised that (jc) does NOT have to stick to medicine. good wishes as always jc _______________________________________________ Goanet mailing list [email protected] http://lists.goanet.org/listinfo.cgi/goanet-goanet.org
