A 58 year old wife and 28 year old daughter committed suicide in their 
respective rooms in an East Delhi flat after their husband/father, an 
Additional Secretary rank officer of the Indian Corporate Law Service and 
former CBI department director was arrested by the CBI for accepting bribes 
from a Pharmaceutical company. It was discovered that he also possessed a large 
amount of cash and other assets disproportionate to his income.

Except for the family suicides apparently due to his arrest bringing "dishonour 
to the family" according to the notes left behind, this is the usual story of a 
high ranking bureaucrat getting caught by an investigative agency for a short 
or long career of corruption. Usually not much comes out of such arrests 
besides extreme harassment for life to the person concerned. There is an old 
adage in India that refers to trouble with the Authorities. The wheels of Govt 
turn slowly, but when you are caught in it, you turn to dust.

What are the real issues at stake here? Could someone enlighten me whether the 
simple solution would be to pay them commensurate with a pay and benefits 
package available in the private sector or for the Govt to deal with the two 
most pressing needs of an official nearing retirement ie professional education 
costs for his children and a home after retirement. Would that help such 
officials to be on the straight and narrow or would greed triumph over any 
measures that the Govt takes. As it stands, Govt employees cannot on their 
salary alone, afford to save for those two post retirement necessities.

I don't believe the Govt cannot afford to pay its employees enough so that they 
have no proclivity to corruption. The money the govt loses by way of revenue 
through corrupt practices would more than outstrip whatever they pay out to 
their officials to stave off temptation. Look at the recent pay commission for 
example. An unheard of 23% increase over the last commission scales. If they 
can afford this, they can afford anything.

An Additional Secretary in the Govt of India earns about Rs.200,000 monthly pay 
and allowances before the new 23 pc increase. While this may not seem much if 
you compare it with the banking or private sector, a fully furnished flat with 
a couple of domestics included, are part of the deal as is also an official car 
and driver and a host of other lesser perks.

Has any ruling authority past or present applied themselves to this and what 
has been the outcome.

Roland Francis
Toronto.

Reply via email to