On Wed Oct 24 13:50:46 PDT 2007 Bhandare wrote:
Bhandare.....I have to repeat again......your commentary on Goanet is all
over the map. On any given day, you will be left, right, up, down,
upside-down, inside-out......there is no consistency in what you write. Some
examples:
The RC church has collected billions of dollars from
gullible folks for the purpose of charity and
alleviating human suffering, and used that money to
buy justice
RESPONSE: This thread is re the HJS exhibition in Goa. What relevance does
the exhibition have with the RC church?? It appears you are raising the
issue of the RC church into this debate because you are responding to an
individual with a Catholic name - Jason Keith Fernandes!
If the respondents have Hindu sounding names you call them communists,
pseudo-secularists and other odd names.
None of the paedophiles have ever been punished
RESPONSE: None?? To score brownie points are you going to invent facts?
Read a story of a few hours ago:
http://www.newsday.com/news/local/wire/newyork/ny-bc-ny--priest-abuse1025oct25,0,3611627.story
Surely you know how to Google!!
As regards freedom of speech I consider it absolute.
everyone has a right to say freely what one wants,
and you by the same token have a right to protest.
RESPONSE: Really? So when Gadgil, Sabnis, FN, Miguel and others protested
the exhibition why did you have to demonize the individuals as above?
I have merely tried to expose the hypocrisy and the
arrogant self righteous attitude of a few vocal
posters on Goanet who selectively target the Hindutva
organizations.
RESPONSE: Several months ago I labelled your writings as self-righteous. Now
you want to turn around and term others as self-righteous.
If you have carefully read my posts on Goanet, I have
never defended all that the HJS or the RSS does.
RESPONSE: As I said at the start.....your commentary is all over the map.
You want to support the HJS but you are afraid of being seen as a supporter
of the HJS. Are you ashamed to explicitly state you support the HJS??
For several months almost every message from Mario Goveia was about the US
war in Iraq. Irrespective what the original thread was about, he would draw
inferences and relationships to the war. There was nothing else he could
write about.
Similarly, we now have Albert who can only write about "God" with ocassional
criticism of the Catholic Church in Goa. There is nothing else he can write
about.
Both self-righteous individuals!!
Now, are you going to be objective in what you write or continue with the
same shenahi - when you respond to a poster (with a Catholic name) on any
issue, you will bring up paedophilia in the Catholic Church....and when you
respond to a poster (with a Hindu name) on any issue, you will shout
communist, pseudo-secular, etc... while at the same time claiming that
"everyone has a right to say freely what one wants".
Whats it gonna be?
- Bosco
