THE FORGOTTEN TRIBE – MHAR – PART 14   (FINAL)

BLACK

Generally, the Mhar were black in complexion; some as dark as charcoal. They 
were 
compared to a crow, which is not only black in color but it is also a 
scavenger. The 
Mhar was clubbed in the same category.

The whole world despises the crow because it is black in color, yet it has 
beauty of 
its own.

There was a time when black was considered a bad omen but now black is 
fashionable 
and everyone wants black. In the days of yore, black was worn at funerals but 
now it 
is worn at birthdays, weddings, parties, etc. – black has now become a fashion! 
Even 
girls find black boys attractive and vice versa!

Come to think of black, we practically can’t do anything without precious 
darkness 
which falls in the black category. For example, we can’t watch a movie in a 
theater 
without darkness. We cannot sleep soundly if there is no darkness – there may 
be 
some who can sleep with the lights on. In the past, people made love in the 
dark; 
now we need the lights on!

People who used to despise a crow appreciate it now despite its color - black.

Similarly, today, black people rule the world in almost every field – sports, 
music, 
politics, you name it.

The fastest man on earth is and was black – Usain Bolt, Asafa Powell, Carl 
Lewis to 
name a few. West Indies, a nation with black people, ruled the cricket world 
for 
many years. Pele, the king of the football, is a black Brazilian. The boxing 
legend, 
Cassius Clay (Mohammed Ali) is a black American, and so were Joe Frazier and 
Mike 
Tyson.

The king of the Pop, the late Michael Jackson, was a black. That he tried to 
become 
white is altogether another story.

Martin Luther King, the principal leader of the American Civil Rights Movement, 
was 
a black. The current President of the most powerful nation in the world, Mr. 
Barack 
Obama, is a black. Even the world-renowned Abade Faria, who shook the world 
with his 
hypnotism, was a black from Goa.

In the days of yore, anyone whose skin color was black was suspected to belong 
to 
the Mhar community. They didn’t spare even their complexion. Additionally, 
people 
tauntingly remarked thus: “To/tem mhar/mharinn koso/koxem dista!” (He/she looks 
like 
a Mhar.)

Many high society and well-to-do people have been despising Mhars but these 
days 
those very people stand in queues to avail of the Scheduled Caste/Scheduled 
Tribes 
quota benefits in educational fields, jobs, etc. The result: Genuine backward 
class 
people are deprived of their daily bread and benefits of such schemes while the 
well-to-do walk away with the cake. Who is a Mhar now?

Goa has around 19 Other Backward Classes (OBCs) and demands for inclusion of 
more 
communities keep pouring in.

Initially, Gavddi, Kunnbi, Velip and Dhangars were the first communities to be 
included in the list of Other Backward Classes, but recently the first three, 
Gavddi, Kunnbi and Velip, have been included in the list of Scheduled Tribes of 
Goa!

They are considered the original settlers of Goa. The Scheduled Tribe 
population is 
said to be about 1.5 lakhs while the OBCs comprise about 4 lakhs (around 25% of 
Goa’s 
estimated population.)

The issue of granting the status of Scheduled Tribes to Govly community or 
Dhangars, 
as they are referred to, has been hanging fire for some time. Their inclusion 
in 
Scheduled Tribes list was opposed by some sections on the ground that they are 
migrants from neighboring state and not a Goan tribe.

However, some say that Portuguese records, which refer to Goan people's life 
styles, 
indicate that they belong to Goa. Therefore, research on the community has been 
undertaken to determine their status.

In conclusion, there was a time when nobody wanted to belong to Scheduled 
Caste/Scheduled Tribes but now people are ready to move mountains to belong to 
it – 
not just ordinary people but even the high class and educated! Do I need to say 
any 
more?

There is a Konkani saying: “Bekar thovoi, furnem taxi,” which is equivalent to 
English saying: ‘Idle mind, devil’s workshop.’

This is exactly what happened in the past in the villages. People did not have 
much 
to do; so, they gossiped about families and their castes.

Nowadays, everyone is so busy that there is hardly any time to think or gossip 
about 
the caste. But there are still some who have nothing to do but gossip, and they 
belong to the above-mentioned class of people.


DISCRIMINATION

Unlike today, there were very few benches in the Anjuna Church in the Sixties. 
Those 
benches were donated by bhattkars and well-to-do people; they had their names 
affixed on them; some still do that.

Elite people found it difficult to kneel down on the wooden plank attached to a 
bench. Therefore, they fixed cushions/padding on them and covered them with 
velvet 
cloth.

The Mhar community members were not at all allowed to occupy a seat on the 
benches 
in the Church. There were instances when bhattkars offended and even slapped 
them 
for occupying a seat on a bench in the Church. I witnessed one such incident 
when I 
was about 8 years old.

Although the Church had extra rooms, none of the pede was given a room to live 
in. 
During the day, they slept in the niches below the main staircase leading to 
the 
choir. The pedo on night duty slept in the little room by the entrance of the 
cemetery.

The Mhar community members could not easily enter a house. They were not 
allowed to 
enter through the front door; they were always called (not called in) at the 
back 
door.

Actually, they knew their standard; hence, they never knocked on the front door 
– 
they always knocked on the back door or called out from backside.

The Mhar community maids who worked in houses were strictly instructed never to 
enter or exit the house from the front door but only from the rear door.

The Mhar were served food in separate vessels. If at all they were served food, 
they 
had to wait for others to finish eating before they could eat.

They were also expected to wash their plates after eating. As a matter of fact, 
they 
were served in separate plates, mainly aluminum or enamel plates – the type of 
which 
people use for their pets like dogs, cats, etc.

They were also not served water in glasses but in a “kotti” (coconut shell.) 
Some 
poured water directly into the cupped hands of the Mhar for drinking instead of 
giving it in a tumbler.

Similarly, the Mhar males were not served liquor in a kals (cup) but they were 
served liquor in a shaven kotti.

They could not wear sandals and walk in front of a dominant caste member, and 
they 
had to walk with folded hands and also had to stand up in respect.

As soon as a person was dead, a messenger obtained a death certificate from a 
doctor, and the same messenger then proceeded to the Church along with the 
certificate, which was essential because a person who committed suicide would 
not be 
given a Church burial; things have changed now.

The Padr Cur or the curate usually wrote down the details of the deceased and 
questioned the messenger: “Tumi taka khuimche classint purunk sodtat – 
kopelmarant, 
poile classint, dusre classint vo tisre classint? (In which class would you 
like to 
intern him/her – in the cemetery chapel, in the first class, the second class 
or the 
third class?)

For reader’s convenience, there were four classes in the cemetery and this is 
how 
they were segregated:

The top class was located inside the “kopelmar” (cemetery chapel.)
The first class was located on the left and right of the kopelmar.
The second class was almost in the middle of the cemetery.
The third class was located on the left and right of both extreme inside 
corners of 
the cemetery entrance.

In between each class a little “fatranchi mer” (stone ridge) was fixed to 
differentiate between classes.

As far as the Mhar community was concerned, they were directly assigned the 
third 
class without even asking them the above question, but not after the Seventies, 
when 
they began to prosper!

In the third class there was an extreme corner where the destitute were buried 
and 
for whom a “bhaddeachi kaixa” (hired coffin) was used. In Anjuna, this kaixa 
was 
always kept on the funeral carriage in the outside room at the right entrance 
of the 
cemetery, which has now been converted into a cemetery. Unfortunately, many 
Mhar 
community members were buried using the hired coffin.

Come to think of it, a person comes in this world naked and should be cremated 
or 
buried naked as is done by Hindus and Muslims (they wrap the body in a white 
bed 
sheet.) Per the Holy Bible, a person comes from the dust and to dust they must 
return.

In this regard, I would say the Mhar community fulfilled the Holy Scriptures 
partly, 
if not completely, in as much as they departed this world in the way they 
should, 
half clad, leaving no worldly wealth behind to fight for - at least the 
olden-day 
generation of the tribe did so.

Didn’t we read in the Holy Bible that the first shall be the last and the last 
shall 
be the first? I hope the Creator will apply this rule to the Mhar community who 
were 
denied justice while on this planet.

During “bhattkar shahi” (landlord rule) days, men from the elite society got 
friendly and even had sex with low society girls, including the Mhar community 
girls 
but when it came to getting married, they would wash off their hands by 
pointing out 
to the caste.

Some bhattkar heirs even had children from the Mhar community female servants 
working in their homes but they would not marry them. At the most, they allowed 
those children to live in their properties.

Wasn’t that outrageous? Does this mean that caste does not matter when one has 
sex 
but it matters only when one is required to get married?

The Mhar community members were taunted at every step and made a prey of 
mockery in 
the eyes of Goan society. Even tiatrists used the words “mhar, chamar” in their 
songs and plays and insulted them publicly.

Wherever they went, people remarked sarcastically:  “Ar’re tum mhar mur’re” – 
the 
same was said of a chamar, as both belonged to the lowest caste of the Goan 
social 
fabric.

The Mhar community was considered so downtrodden that whenever the rich and the 
affluent cursed, they would say: “Hanv mhoji girestkai vattevoilea mharak, 
chamarak 
ditolom/ditelim punn tuka kednanch divchonam/divchinam.” (I would rather part 
with 
my wealth to a roadside mhar or chamar but not you.) But it was only a figure 
of 
speech; I heard many say it but did not witness anyone fulfill it.

By now the caste has been dissolved into the society. Gone are those days when 
students and friends used to be restricted from talking to or mingling with low 
caste peers. In fact, nobody knows who is who now, and the caste system is the 
least 
subject anyone would be interested in, except, of course for a few demi-gods, 
who 
are always interested in it.

Many from the Mhar community have come up in life and left Goa for greener 
pastures 
in foreign countries where nobody is interested in the abominable caste system. 
Yes, 
they have chosen to settle there permanently and never to return to their place 
of 
origin, which means nothing to them but a nightmare!

We humans have a tendency to name, brand, categorize, smother, discipline, 
demark, 
label, as if multitudes of varied human beings could be contained under 
monolithic 
ideologies of caste or religion or nationality.

We must refuse to be labeled like a product in a mass-production factory with 
its 
contents, nutritional value and price written on a label. For God’s sake, we 
are 
human beings; let us not become branded items!

We all belong to one God, who is the supreme Creator of this wonderful 
universe, and 
His message is love – ‘Love your neighbor as you love thyself.’ So, let us love 
each 
and every human being on this beautiful planet.

Over the years, especially post-liberation Goa, education has played a vital 
role in 
eradicating the caste system in Goa, but there are still a few holdouts for 
whom the 
old Konkani proverbial saying is apt: "Sumb lasta punn entto urta" (Rope burns 
but 
the twist remains!)

(ENDS)


Thank you all for making time to read this series and for the feedback that I 
have 
received thus far. Please continue to email your feedback to 
[email protected] 
or [email protected]



Moi-mogan,

Domnic Fernandes
Anjuna, Goa
Mobile: 9420979201


 All rights reserved 


Reply via email to