I just returned from Barcelona, Spain which has a  huge statue of Christopher 
Columbus returning from the Americas and a large royal square in front of the 
palace where he was received by Queen Isabella.  The history and architecture 
of Barcelona reflects the colonial grandeur which, inn my view may even surpass 
that of London.  These observations encouraged me to read about the intense 
Portuguese-Spanish rivalry in the Age of Discovery - fifteen and sixteen 
century.  I then read on the net two different accounts of SFX, which in my 
opinion are totally opposite in describing the same person (SFX).

As I view it, SFX was a thorn in the side of the Portuguese (in Lisbon and in 
Goa), especially given the strong rivalries of the two Iberian countries during 
his period; and the contrary objectives of SFX and the Portuguese colonialists 
in Goa.  

The readers can read the following and make their own judgment of who is giving 
us the BS.

Regards, GL

-------------- Ivo D' Souza wrote:

His (SFX) Apostolic Method:  The Governor Martim Afonso de Sousa requested him 
to reside in his Palace, but Francis preferred to stay in the Royal Hospital 
("Hospital Real"), where he dedicated himself to the sick and lepers of the 
Hospital of St.Lazarus. He was preaching and catechizing in the church of the 
Rosary. Penitents crowded to Francis for confession in the chapel of the 
hospital. In the old Cathedral of the Bishop, Francis baptized his neophytes. 
On weekdays, in the afternoon, Francis visited prisoners of the Prison 
("Cadeia", situated in a place in front of the Cathedral  and the Palace of the 
Vice-Roys), taught them how to confess, and ordinarily heard them afterwards in 
general confession.

------------ Teo D'souza wrote

Francis Xavier represented the powerful Iberian power of those times and 
simultaneously the hierarchical authority of the Tridentine Roman church, 
backed by the moral authority of the Society of Jesus in ascendancy. Francis 
Xavier was consequently backed by considerable authority, not withstanding his 
own personality traits and zeal. Francis Xavier had extraordinary means at his 
disposal during his lifetime, 

A Sorbonne-based lady historian who has been analysing in recent years the 
Jesuit missionary activities in India, including the historiography related to 
Francis Xavier, has quite a few texts published and online that could shock the 
pious devotees of the saint. She tells us, for instance, that Xavier's mission 
among the Portuguese was exclusively for the benefit of the men and their 
heroic mercantile and proselytising enterprises.



Reply via email to