[Goanet] Countering magical thinking

[Dr . Ferdinando dos Reis Falcão]

On Sun, 20
Feb 2011 10:49:47 -0800, Santosh Helekar chimbelcho at yahoo.com wrote :
<<< ……. 1- I do not want to upload
the scanned paper in the public domain and provide a link to it for copyright 

reasons.  2- As far as the paper is concerned,
the claim below that it was removed by somebody is false….Like most papers
cited in the medical databases prior to the late 1980s it is not available
online. 3- This paper is not a "confirmation" by "modern science"
of any miracle.  4- The results
described do not come even close to confirming unequivocally the claims that
the material is human heart and blood, that it is fresh, that it is from a
living person, 5- Regarding why such a flawed study would be published, the
answer is that obscure publications like the one in which it was published do
not have a rigorous peer-review process, and/or high standards. ….Cheers,
Santosh>>>>

 

RESPONSE : 

1- It is not illegal to
upload a document. It is only illegal to reproduce someone else’s document
under your name or pirate copies for sale. That is copyrights. 

2- The link to the site
on Medline by me in my last post is very clear. The contents have been removed.
Medical papers dated even from 1960s are available online.

3- I have already stated
that science and scientist cannot confirm miracles. Science cannot explain the
bizarre occurrence against all laws of science.

4- According to the
report Santosh claims to be in possession, what was it then. Why does he not
specify what is stated? Cannot think of something plausible?

5- If that is so, why
was a review of this report not published with correct interpretation of
findings?

Santosh has delusions
that  he has much better knowledge
than eminent scientist of the 1970s. To him, even Einstein of the 18th
century   maybe considered as
a cretin, and all Goan fools. Stop looking in the mirror Santosh and drawing
conclusions. You have already exposed your capabilities and incompetency on
Goanet. 

http://www.psrast.org/mobileng/mobilstarteng.htm#junk  

You are a shame to the
science profession. 




Dr. Ferdinando dos Reis Falcão.