9-Sep-2012

Dear Friend,

If your non Catholic friend /colleague asked you a blunt question: “Who or what 
does Jesus mean to you?” What would your answer be? A prophet? An inspiring 
person? A miracle worker? A great personality? Is that it? Or is Jesus more 
than that for you? It is easy to give book answers, or second-hand answers. Is 
my life in any way dependant on Jesus or influenced by Jesus?? Have a quiet 
weekend reflecting on whether Jesus makes any difference in my daily Life.  Fr. 
Jude

Sunday Reflections: 24th Sunday  “Who do you say that I am? Who is Jesus to 
you?”  16-Sep-2012
Readings: Isaiah 50: 5-9             James 2: 14-8            Mark 8: 27-35

In today’s first reading the prophet Isaiah refers to the coming of the Messiah 
in tones of resignation as the ‘Suffering Servant.’ The servant is all the 
people of God, personified in the one who exemplified their best goals and 
traits – to overcome evil by good, violence by love, war by peace. In contrast 
to the unfaithful and unhearing Israel, the servant declares that he is 
obedient and listens to the Lord. The prophet Isaiah tells us how to recognize 
the Messiah. In spite of his sufferings, the Messiah, and the true follower and 
believer, will be the one who will not turn back from his course. Instead, he 
will set his face like flint and go on to achieve his purpose.

Response to Suffering
Until the age of twenty five, Eugene O’Neill was a failure. His life was 
without purpose, discipline or direction. Then one day he took seriously ill, 
and was taken to hospital. It was during his long stay in hospital that he got 
a chance to do something he had never done before. He got a chance to think 
about his life and where it was headed. It was also in the hospital that he 
discovered that he had a talent for writing plays. Eventually Eugene O’Neill 
recovered, took up a writing career, and went on to revolutionize American 
drama. It all happened because O’Neill reacted to sorrow and suffering in a 
constructive way. He responded to them in a life-giving way. Take also the case 
of Golda Meir. As a young person, Golda felt depressed because she was not 
beautiful. She wrote: “It was only much later that I realized that not being 
beautiful was a blessing in disguise. It forced me to develop inner resources. 
I came to understand that women who
 can’t lean on their beauty… have to work hard, and therefore have an 
advantage. In other words, Golda Meir accepted her cross. She didn’t cry out 
against it, she didn’t fret over it or resent it. She acknowledged it, picked 
it up and carried it courageously. Golda Meir went on to become the first woman 
prime minister of Israel.
Mark Link in ‘Sunday Homilies’

In today’s gospel Jesus asks his disciples the perception of the crowd 
regarding himself: “Who do people say that I am?” There are various answers: 
‘Prophet’, ‘Wonder-worker’, but ‘Messiah’ is not one of them. Now he turns to 
his disciples and asks: “And you, who do you say that I am?” A second-hand 
faith is a watered down faith. We cannot live only by what others say or 
believe. Peter’s answer on behalf of the disciples; “You are the Christ”, is 
pious, but incomplete. The Jews expected the Messiah to come in power, to free 
them from Roman dominion, but they did not expect the Messiah to suffer. Jesus 
therefore to dispel the false idea that they held on to, predicted that the 
Messiah would suffer and ultimately be put to death. Peter remonstrates with 
Jesus. “You must not talk about suffering. You cannot suffer. Don’t let people 
know that they have to suffer to follow you!” Jesus has to put Peter in his 
place and set the
 record straight. “Get behind me Satan! Because the way you think is not God’s 
way but man’s.” Who do you say that I am? Is not merely a question to establish 
the identity of Jesus but a rhetorical question mainly about us – his 
followers. “If we say that Jesus is “the Christ” then we must move aside from 
the throne of our own life and let him rule.  In Mark we are confronted by both 
suffering and exaltation, defeat and victory, weakness and power, death and 
life in its fullness. Peter on the one hand refuses to accept the suffering, 
defeat and death; on the other, he readily expresses the desire to stay where 
the exaltation, victory and manifestation of full life are revealed." Where do 
we stand with regard to Christ?

Film: ‘The Giant of Thunder Mountain’
Eli Weaver, "the giant," lives like a hermit on Thunder Mountain, due to the 
hostility, gossip, and rejection of the local townspeople, who, without 
evidence, accuse him of murdering his parents. A young girl, Amy Wilson, seeks 
to turn the tables by befriending the giant, –learning that Eli was innocent of 
the tragic deaths of his parents. Eventually, she succeeds in winning his 
heart, and Eli agrees to visit the townspeople again, only to be rejected and 
cast out a second time. However, Amy and her brothers persist in keeping their 
friendship alive with the giant. Through a series of suspense-filled events, 
which are totally misunderstood by the townspeople, a lynch mob erroneously 
hunts down Eli. However, the truth is revealed in the nick of time, and Eli is 
instrumental in capturing the real criminals, associated with a travelling 
carnival. The townspeople, finally accepting the truth, regard Eli as a hero. 
Eli, in several respects, comes across as
 a Christ-figure in the movie: suffering many hardships from the rejection, 
scorn and derision of the townspeople, reminding me a little of William Butler 
Yeats’ "rough beast" exterior, contrasted with the biblical tender, gentle 
Jesus who loves and welcomes children.
Rev. Garth Wehrfritz-Hanson –From Internet Sources

The Cross at the Crossroads….
There were three young trees growing together in the forest. They were young 
healthy and ambitious. They compared their dreams. One wanted to be part of a 
structure of a castle or a palace, so that it could be a spectator in the lives 
of the high and mighty of society. The second wanted to end up as a mast of one 
of the tall ships, sailing around the world with a great sense of adventure. 
The third hoped to end up as part of some public monument, where the public 
would stop, admire and take photographs. Years passed by, and all three were 
cut down. The first was chopped up, and parts of it were put together to form a 
manger for a stable in Bethlehem. The second was cut down, and the trunk was 
scooped out to form a boat, which was launched on the Sea of Galilee. The third 
was cut into sections, two of which were put together, to form a cross on 
Calvary. Each had a unique and special role to play in the one great story of 
redemption.
Jack McArdle in ‘And that’s the Gospel Truth’

Film- Pay it Forwards
In the film, "Pay It Forward" Trevor, a seventh-grader, responds to the call of 
his Social Studies teacher to come up with a plan to change the world and act 
on it. Turning "pay backs" upside down, he devises, "pay it forward" wherein 
you seek to find three people who need some help in a "really big" way and 
requiring some kind of sacrifice one helps these three with the understanding 
that if they are helped they will pay it forward to three more people...and the 
plan works in wonderful ways, resulting in the death of the student who 
sacrifices his life for one of his people. His compassionate heart is 
memorialized at the end of the film as we see a long line of cars...people who 
have been touched by his sacrifice who never knew him, but have experienced his 
compassion in their lives through someone else.
Diane C. Jackson

Readiness to Face Death
When the Berkenhead sank, Alexander Russell, a young officer aged seventeen, 
was ordered to command one of the boats which carried women and children. As 
they were pushing off, a sailor who was drowning clasped the side of the boat, 
but there was no room for even one more. A woman on the boat cried: “Save him! 
He is my husband.” Russell rose, jumped clear off the boat, and amidst a chorus 
of “God bless you!” he sank in the water, which was full of sharks and was seen 
no more, while the sailor was being pulled in to take his place.
Anthony Castle in ‘More Quotes and Anecdotes’

Double Lives
G. K. Chesterton has a story about a popular philanthropist. The main reason 
for his popularity was his unfailing good humour. No one bothered to ask how he 
managed to be always happy. They assumed he was born an optimist. But then one 
day he was found dead in mysterious circumstances. Foul play was immediately 
suspected. However, the case completely baffled the police. Eventually it was 
Chesterton’s unlikely detective, Fr. Browne, who solved the case. His verdict – 
the man committed suicide. At first the people refused to accept Fr. Browne’s 
verdict. They couldn’t imagine how such a happy man could commit suicide. But 
then it emerged that there was a serious side to the funny man. The man who 
made others laugh was in fact a deeply depressed man. But he could never tell 
anyone how he really felt. The man had two lives. One open, seen and known by 
all, the other secret, and known only to himself. In public he was the man who 
smiled at everyone.
 But in private he was wounded and desperate. He felt he had to live up to 
people’s expectations in return for their attention and esteem. He was never 
able to be himself. Finally, he realized that his whole life was based on a 
lie. The strain of trying to maintain the public image became so great that he 
could no longer cope with it. So he committed suicide.
Flor McCarthy in ‘Sunday and Holy Day Liturgies’

May we be followers of Jesus sharing the Cross and the Crown!

 
Fr. Jude Botelho
[email protected]

PS. The stories, incidents and anecdotes used in the reflections have been 
collected over the years from books as well as from sources over the net and 
from e-mails received. Every effort is made to acknowledge authors whenever 
possible. If you send in stories or illustrations I would be grateful if you 
could quote the source as well so that they can be acknowledged if used in 
these reflections. These reflections are also available on my web site 
www.netforlife.net Thank you.

Reply via email to