> On Nov 24, 2013, at 6:21 AM,  Frederick FN Noronha wrote thus to Dr Falcao:


1: You're needlessly targetting a community and it's abilities!

2: So why be dismissive of an entire community, even if just trying to make a 
point about someone else's typos/carelessness?

3: If you replace the word "Sardar" above with "Goan" or "Goan Catholic", you 
can decide for yourself how fair such stereotypes are. FN

4: PS: Accept your point about the misspelling of Tehelka though.

5: Tarun Tejpal is a member of it. And while he definitely deserves to be held 
accountable for his treatment of his women staff, Tehelka's journalism, or much 
of it, has been pioneering.

COMMENT: 

While I agree with the stereotyping point (#3 supra) made by FN, I am not 
convinced that Dr. Falcao had targeted any community or even been dismissive of 
that community.

As one who coined the word Tejelka, I invite you understand that it was NO typo 
or act of carelessness, rather as a word I derived from Tejpal and Tehelka. 

I agree with #5 (supra). The unfortunate result of all this: All that 
'pioneering work' is now tainted for good. That was the point of my Tejelka 
article. 

jc

  • ... Dr . Ferdinando dos Reis Falcão
    • ... floriano lobo
    • ... Frederick FN Noronha फ्रेड्रिक नोरोन्या *فريدريك نورونيا
      • ... Jose Colaco

Reply via email to