On Mar 1, 2008, at 8:41 AM, Martin Landa wrote:

Hi,

2008/3/1, Michael Barton <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>:
Well, my understanding of the direction of GRASS is that by v7, we'll
 lose all the interactive xterm-specific d.* modules. Interactive use
will all be shifted to whatever GUI we design, rather than being hard- coded into a module. Simple, interactive measurement between 2 points
 on a display screen seems to me something to be handled by a GUI.

 d.measure will go away OR change to a module in which you enter a
 start and end point and it returns the distance between the points.
 In the latter case, it could then be 'plugged into' a GUI as a
function to calculate distance between points interactively 'grabbed'
 by the GUI.

In that case I would vote for `g.measure coords=` or something
similar. Then this module could be used in GUI (not matter which one)
or directly from CLI. Or in wxPython to use Python SWIG interface
(need to be improved) to use gislib for distance calculation and
similar.

Ignoring geodetic distance for LL projections is simply ignorance (on
 my part here) of the equations needed to do it. It's easy to
 determine if a location is LL. In that case, it should calculate
 geodetic distance rather than (or perhaps in addition to) displaying
 distance in map units. Just need to have the functions to do this
 added to the measurement methods.

why to code it in Python when it is already available in gislib? We
should avoid code duplication.

Certainly. If a new version of d.measure or a hypothetical g.measure could be created, we could use that. Until that happens, we'll need to do it in Python (which is not all that bad). Is there anyway to access gislib directly from Python? This could be an alternative to creating a new module or changing an existing one.

Michael

_______________________________________________
grass-dev mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.osgeo.org/mailman/listinfo/grass-dev

Reply via email to