Hi Nikos/devs,

Currently, I am Co-supervising a student who is using i.landsat8.swlst module 
for his bachelor thesis.

During that work we stumbled upon some minor issues where we would like to 
propose some changes in the module:

-          The k-flag does the opposite of what the description tells. It sets 
the computational region to the Landsat scene. I would say, it is more in line 
with other GRASS modules if the computational region is not changed by default. 
So I would rather change the description than the behavior (please find a 
suggestion in the diff below). However, maybe it is even more coherent with the 
rest of the GRASS modules if the flag is removed?

-          Currently, the module always overwrites an existing MASK and 
requires either the QAB band or a raster representing unreliable pixels which 
the module then uses as an inverted mask. I would like to propose to leave the 
(cloud) masking out of the module and leave that to other modules 
(i.landsat8.qc, r.reclass, r.mask...).

Please find attached a diff covering the suggested changes in i.landsat8.swlst 
plus some message and UI cosmetics.

Nikos, if you prefer a PR on github I can create one (don`t know how you sync 
gtihub and svn...)?

If you agree in the proposed changes I will also check and adjust the manual 
accordingly...

Kind regards,
Stefan

Attachment: i.landsat8.swlst.diff
Description: i.landsat8.swlst.diff

_______________________________________________
grass-dev mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.osgeo.org/mailman/listinfo/grass-dev

Reply via email to