Marco:
> I read and accepted the terms of the RFC 2 document
> published here:
> http://download.osgeo.org/grass/grass6_progman/rfc/rfc2_psc.html

ok, then "+1" from me.


> > simple curiosity: where do you expect your initial
> WinGRASS commits to be? In a dir in the source code like
> macosx/ and debian/, or in the grass-web
> grass63/binary/mswin/ area, or ..?
> 
> 1) grass-web/trunk/grass63/binary/mswindows/native
>  
> to maintain the published release documentation
>  
> 2) branches/develbranch_6/win32
>  
> the folder where i put all the scripts and files needed to
> prepare the release installer (as an exe file).

why refer to 32bit in the dirname?


> Just few questions: all the files (dos batch scripts, the
> NSIS script, icons and documents) are made by me, with the
> exception of:
>  
> 2.1) the bmp files (4) for the installer GUI, taken from
> the standard library of NSIS (that is OS, obviously)

it may be "open source", but that means 1001 different things, many of which we 
can not touch. what is the license exactly? are those 4 files distributed under 
terms compatible with the GPL? If not GPL is it one of the OSI usual-suspects 
approved set?

> 2.2) a small part of the installer, a function to let
> replace parts of strings; I just copied and pasted it,
> maintaining the header, where is clear the line
> ";Written by [author]"

what license terms did the author provide it with? you can not just cut and 
paste things from the internet or "cook books", even with attribution. is it a 
simple one- liner that is hard to write any other way, or is it an original 
work?  without a clear license you can not distribute the code. if in doubt try 
and contact the author of that code, they may give you full permission to use, 
modify, and redistribute it.


> does it match the RFC 2?

Without more details I don't know.
to be clear, it is explicitly the committer's responsibility to ensure that 
everything they put in the repo is legally kosher.


(this is perhaps a matter that should be cc'd to the -dev list for wider 
audience + comment)


good reading:
  http://www.softwarefreedom.org/resources/2008/foss-primer.html


Hamish



      

_______________________________________________
grass-psc mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.osgeo.org/mailman/listinfo/grass-psc

Reply via email to