Home <http://www.tehelka.com/> | Current
Affairs<http://www.tehelka.com/channels/news/news_main.asp>
| Opinion <http://www.tehelka.com/channels/op-ed/oped_main.asp> |
Business <http://www.tehelka.com/channels/Business/Business_main.asp>
| Engaged
Circle <http://www.tehelka.com/channels/crusader/crusade_main.asp> | Culture
& Society <http://www.tehelka.com/channels/Thehub/thehub_main.asp> |
<http://magazine.tehelka.com/> | Web
Specials<http://www.tehelka.com/channels/Web_Specials/Web_Specials.asp>
| Interact <http://www.tehelka.com/Interactive/> |
Archives<http://www.tehelka.com/archive/archive_main.asp>
Sunday, 8 February 2009
<http://www.tehelka.com/feeds/tehfeed.xml> | *TEHELKA INITIATIVES:* Critical
Futures <http://www.criticalfutures.org/> | Tehelka
Foundation<http://www.thetehelkafoundation.org/>
*From Tehelka Magazine, Vol 6, Issue 6, Dated Feb 14, 2009* *CURRENT
AFFAIRS* *cover story *
*The Idea Of Indignation*
*Mobs are born out of dangerous ideas. In mapping the Mangalore pub attack *
*SHOMA CHAUDHURY **tracks the underlying psychology of vigilantes across the
country*
*SHOMA CHAUDHURY* *
Executive Editor, Tehelka*
[image: Cover Story]
*Illustration:* SUDEEP CHAUDHURI
INMANGALORE, they beat women for drinking. In Pune, they tear priceless
manuscripts because they feel a historian has insulted Shivaji. In Delhi,
they spit on a man at a podium because they feel he is a traitor to the
nation. In Bhopal, they break a school because they feel the principal has
violated the national anthem. In Bombay, they raid and pillage because they
feel outsiders are stealing jobs and thwarting their mother tongue. In
Orissa, they burn houses and kill people because they feel their faith is in
danger of dwindling. In Gujarat, they rape and kill thousands because they
want to teach a community a lesson. They pull artists' hair, threaten
writers, slap women, hit men, burn paintings, ban films, tear posters, pulp,
burn, rape, kill, beat. As a matter of routine, they spill into the street.
This is not an army of beasts in some futuristic film. These are
contemporary 'keepers of tradition', 'protectors of society'. Zealots driven
by such fierce rage and selfrighteousness, they see no irony in
cannibalising the very culture, religion and nation they claim they defend.
It is tempting to dismiss these goons as some looney fringe outside of
ourselves, as just emanations of some hallucinogenic dystopia. But in truth,
the angry men of Mangalore — and vendors of anarchy elsewhere — have many
urgent lessons for Indians.
First among these lessons is a recognition that such armies can emanate from
any religion, society, or political dispensation. There is nothing to
distinguish the mobs rampaging on the streets of Calcutta claiming Taslima
Nasreen and Salman Rushdie's head and those who burnt down the sets of Water
in Varanasi. The anatomy of the zealot — Hindu, Muslim, Christian, Sikh — is
always the same: the brain-maps are identical; the disregard for law is
uniform. And political capitulation to them is almost instant.
Indian public life is increasingly being disrupted by vigilante mobs
dispensing quick and brutal 'justice'. Political parties beholden to them —
often guilty of nursing them with money and rhetoric — are forced to toe the
line. Emboldened, buoyed by a widening pool of political collusion, media
attention and public silence, such mobs are striking with greater and
greater impunity. Today, even as India casts itself as one of the leading
democracies in the world, all its big questions about self and society seem
to be playing themselves out on a burnt-down stage. Argument has been
replaced by war.
Given this, TEHELKA has picked 10 rabble-rousers from across the country for
its cover this week. Men and women who lead mobs either through practice or
precept. We could have included mafia dons and other criminal or
para-military forces used by political parties, but those have their own
logic of use and run less deep. Here, we have focused on men and women who
mobilise masses on a diet of hate, fear and injury, amplifying those
subterranean emotions in society that can find volcanic release.
[image: Cover Story]
*Illustration:* UZMA MOHSIN
The mechanics of hate and anarchy inevitably are similar: the political
framework that gives it birth, the rhetoric of purity that fires it, the
collusion that gives it continuing life. Equally inevitably, these strands
are most visible in mobs born out of the majority community. The capacity
for maximum damage too is theirs. Telling the story of the majority, then,
is akin to recounting a parable. The characters, the place, even the time
might change: the story would remain the same.
One of the key lessons of Mangalore, then, is to recognise the damage years
of Hindutva resurgence has done to the Hindu — and by extension, Indian —
mindscape. In nurturing its project of turning a plural, playful, impossibly
diverse religion into an organising principle for a majoritarian
nation-state, Hindutva ideologues have not only unleashed the poison of
heightened communal politics into our bloodstream, but a deeper and, in the
long run, much more dangerous and wounding disease: self-disgust. In homes,
schools and public rallies across the country, young and old Hindus are
constantly being told — you are effete, you are effeminate, you have let
others invade and subjugate you, you have let yourself and your temples be
desecrated. From this humiliating, brainwashing story of emasculation and
injury has arisen not a productive desire for renewal but a new, almost
psychopathic desire for "masculinity": an appetite for brute domination. Not
the modern desire to live by the rule of law, but a crude desire for
reprisal. This belated project of asserting *"Hum bhi mard hain" *explains
much of the anarchy spilling around us. As long as you can display how
strong you are, all is kosher — you can count on the sneaking admiration of
your neighbours. And your mentors.
The ironies, of course, are laughable. Both classical Hinduism and its many
tribal and pagan versions have traditionally placed the female principle,
Shakti, with all its complex attributes — its capacity to be accommodating,
absorbent, argumentative, anarchic, both compassionate and capable of brutal
action — as its organising genius. Rejecting this, Hindutva "defenders of
tradition" now want to remould Hindu society along much more prudish and
homogenising lines, imitating aspects of Protestant Christianity and Islam —
cultures it, ironically, professes to hate.
A further irony: much of Hindutva inspiration comes from the reformist Hindu
visionary, Swami Vivekananda. As sociologist Ashis Nandy says, seeking to
revitalise the moribund culture Hindu society had become in the 19th
century, Vivekananda had called for a fusion of the "Vedantic mind with the
Islamic body", urging Hindus to reinvent themselves based on three Bs —
beef, biceps and the Bhagvad Gita. The only injunction the Hindutva brigade
seems to have focused on is the bicep.
With all these contortions, from a flawed but self-confident civilisation —
capable of absorbing languages, religions, people, cultures — Hindus are
being turned into a people driven by fear and a false sense of besiegement.
As Tarun Vijay, a well-known RSS ideologue, said without a trace of
self-mockery, "If we can have Save Panda campaigns and Save Tiger campaigns,
why can't we have a Save Hindus campaign?" The Sri Ram Sene of Mangalore is
a weapon born in the psychological crucible of that campaign.
Set aside the Hindutva experiment and you have the equally damaging
contemporary Islamist project — mobilised around a desire for purity and a
loathing of other cultures. Replace the Islamist project, and you have the
Christian proselytiser urging straying sheep to the one true God. The props
might change, the brain-map wouldn't.
MANGALORE HAS other lessons. Lessons of dangerous political opportunism and
sponsorship. The BJP is finding out to its dismay that the old truism is
true. Frankensteins are notoriously hard to leash. After the shameful
debacle at the pub, BJP leaders were unusually quick to denounce the brute
attack. "We do not support such hooliganism," said BJP national spokesperson
Rajiv Pratap Rudy. "We were not the perpetrators of these attacks," said
Yogesh Bhat, BJP spokesperson in Karnataka. (He could not resist the codicil
— "But what were those women doing dancing at the pub till 3.45 in the
morning?") These are heartening, if momentary, denials. Within days, the
inevitable cop-outs of course began to play themselves out. Sri Ram Sene
activists were arrested and promptly released; Karnataka Chief Minister
Yedurappa has consistently refused to ban them.
But this confused tango points to a growing crisis within the BJP. Party
insiders say many leaders at the centre are becoming impatient with the
fringe groups on whose backs they have clambered to political prominence.
Commentators are predicting that virulent communal politics has played out
its term in India. The lawlessness and atavistic morality of the VHP,
Bajrang Dal, Durga Vahini, Shiv Sena, Abhinav Bharat, Sambhaji Brigade, Sri
Ram Sene — perhaps even the RSS itself — no longer suits the BJP's pursuit
of power at the centre. "We have to rid ourselves of this retrograde cowbelt
politics," one BJP man says sarcastically. Easier said than done.
The angry men of Mangalore — and their ilk across the country — are not
mercenaries that can be disbanded once the contract is done; they are
products of a psychological laboratory, a cynical social mobilisation. They
are a generation bred on a language of an injured Bharat Mata, an enemy
race, and a castrated masculinity. Bred on an idea of nation not based on
the rule of law, but on angry sentiment. An idea of religion not gloriously
playful and plural but terminally pure. An idea of women not equally human
but a species to be subjugated (either through excessive worship or force).
How is this generation to be disbanded? If their mentors will not feed them
their prey, they will start to feed on their mentors. It is no coincidence
that one of the thwarted targets of Colonel Purohit was a moderate RSS
ideologue.
The thing about vendors of anarchy is that they are never *sui
generis.*They have sliver-tongued mentors, "iron men" wielding
dexterous words. The
LK Advanis and Narendra Modis, the Bal Thackerays and Rajnath Singhs. Men
who madden their listeners with self-loathing and hate, and empower them
with a call to duty and domination. After the recent carnage against
Christians in Orissa, the BJP leaders in Delhi refused to act against the
Bajrang Dal cadres, calling them "nationalists". Later though, when new
worms began to flood out of the woodwork and Hindu extremists were suspected
of engineering blasts across the country, their mentors began to hide behind
leaves more flimsy than the fig: Sadhvi Pragya was not the BJP's
responsibility because she had left the Durga Vahini 10 years earlier. The
men who died making bombs in Bhopal were not their responsibility either,
because they had left the Bajrang Dal five years earlier. And so on. Then
caught in the torque of their denials, a new round of assertions followed:
Sadhvi Pragya was an asset to the Hindutva cause, the BJP would fund her
defence, Uma Bharati would give her a ticket.
The classic cleft. To apologise for the rabid fringe is to be trapped in a
logic of your own making: become LK Advani after the Jinnah controversy:
risk the perception of emasculation. To not apologise is to be an
international pariah and be denied the highest seat in national politics: be
a Narendra Modi, live in-waiting, dogged by misdoings.
Frankensteins, the BJP is finding out belatedly, are notoriously hard to
leash. It's not just the BJP though. Every political party in India has its
own equivalent nursery. We saw the CPM unleash its gun-wielding motorcade in
Nandigram — Buddhadeb Bhattacharya's triumphant "payback". And the Congress,
they say, sponsored the rise of Raj Thackeray. How would those maps read?
THERE ARE still other lessons from Mangalore. Some of these are to do with
nuancing our ideas of tradition and modernity. The right to individual
freedom is a no-brainer: individual liberty, exercised within the framework
of the law of the land, is the obvious cornerstone on which all democracies
are founded. But there are proprieties within which freedoms are exercised.
These are subjects for complex conversations. Conversations we must insist
will no longer be played on a burned-out stage.
It can be no one's argument that people who frequent high-end bars are
necessarily liberal and modern — no more or less so than those who do not
drink or those who frequent gritty *thekas* and lower-class country bars
across the land. Drinking, kissing in public, holding hands, wearing noodle
straps or tight vests — none of this is about being modern or liberal. It is
just about having the right to choose. Salman Khan, for instance, might bare
his body a lot, but he has an uncomfortable reputation for beating women.
Would that make him modern? Any more than the mob beating women in the pub
is traditional?
We are living in a complex, anxious age. Tougher laws cannot fix those
anxieties, only conversations will. In a vulgar display of bicep a couple of
days ago, National Commission for Women Chairperson Girija Vyas told
mediamen, "Who is Renuka Chowdhury to intervene? I am the head of the
National Commission for Women." In that moment, Vyas brought herself down to
the level of the mob she is investigating. The real crisis of the mobs
sprouting across India is the language of confrontation that has bred them.
To reverse this course, we have to find a lost language. A language of
dignified public discourse. We have to reach for the culture within.
*From Tehelka Magazine, Vol 6, Issue 6, Dated Feb 14, 2009*
A genuinely hurt
do-gooder<http://www.tehelka.com/dotnet/mainheadline.asp?id=1>
By Anand ST Das Tapeshwar Viswakarma, who sued the film, Slumdog
Millionaire, and attacked a theatre, says his fight has 'just started'
Read>> <http://www.tehelka.com/dotnet/mainheadline.asp?id=1>
Journalist Self-Immolates, Students
Protest<http://www.tehelka.com/dotnet/mainheadline.asp?id=2>
By PC Vinoj Kumar
Only A Small Fish? <http://www.tehelka.com/dotnet/mainheadline.asp?id=3>
By Sanjana
Marriage Sans Frontieres<http://www.tehelka.com/dotnet/mainheadline.asp?id=4>
By Peerzada Arshad Hamid More
Stories>><http://www.tehelka.com/dotnet/allnews.asp>
<http://www.tehelka.com/home/20081206/mdefault.asp>
<http://www.tehelka.com/Subscribe/index.asp>
<[email protected]?subject=complaints or feedback on
subscription&[email protected]>
<http://www.tehelka.com/Interactive/>
<http://tehelka.ganeshaspeaks.com/>
<http://www.thedailyretail.com/>
<http://ads.ozonemedia.co.in/accipiter/adclick/CID=000060500000000000000000/acc_random=24940706/SITE=TEHELKA/AAMSZ=728X90/pageid=95264631>
<http://ads.ozonemedia.co.in/adclick/SITE=TEHELKA/AAMSZ=728X90/pageid=1>
About Us <http://www.tehelka.com/about/> | Who's
w...@tehelka<http://www.tehelka.com/about/team.asp>| Advertise
With Us <http://www.tehelka.com/about/advertise.asp> | Print
Subscriptions<http://www.tehelka.com/Subscribe/index.asp>|
Syndication <http://www.tehelka.com/about/syndication.asp> | Terms of
Service <http://www.tehelka.com/about/tos.asp> | Privacy
Policy<http://www.tehelka.com/about/privacy.asp>|
Feedback<http://www.tehelka.com/story_main41.asp?filename=Ne140209coverstory.asp#>|
Contact
Us <http://www.tehelka.com/about/contact.asp> | Bouquets &
Brickbats<http://www.tehelka.com/channels/People/people_main.asp>
Tehelka.com is a part of Anant Media Pvt. Ltd. (c) 2000 - 2009 All rights
reserved
--
" The so called caste-hindus are bitterly opposed to the depressed class
using a public tank not because they really believe that the water will be
thereby spoiled or will evaporate but because they are afraid of losing
their superiority of caste and of equality being established between the
former and the latter. We are resorting to this satyagraha not becasue we
believe that the water of this particular tank has any exceptional
qualities, but to establish our natural rights as citizens and human
beings."
- Dr B.R. Ambedkar, Mahad Satyagraha Conference, December 25th , 1927
--~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups
"Green Youth Movement" group.
To post to this group, send email to [email protected]
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to
[email protected]
For more options, visit this group at
http://groups.google.com/group/greenyouth?hl=en-GB
-~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---
