--- On Sun, 12/4/09, mukulkesa...@hotmail.com <mukulkesa...@hotmail.com> wrote:
THE TELEGRAPH
Thursday , April 9 , 2009
THE GUJARAT MODEL
- Why the last week in Orissa was historic
MUKUL KESAVAN
In retrospect, the violence in Kandhamal in Orissa last year seems like the
first step in an electoral strategy, a strategy that can be broadly described
as the Gujarat model. For those who don’t remember those events, starting in
the last week of August, Christians in the Kandhamal district suffered a month
and a half of systematic intimidation, killing and displacement. Figures
released by the Orissa government put the figure at over 12,000 refugees, fed
and sheltered in government camps. This doesn’t account for those Christians
who fled their homes and sought refuge in places other than these refugee
camps, so the overall figure for the displaced is higher.
The troubles began after Swami Laxmananda Saraswati, a Vishwa Hindu Parishad
leader, was murdered by ‘Maoists’. The sangh parivar alleged that his murder
had been organized by Christians and used his funeral procession to stoke
murderous violence against Christians in the area. Having ‘cleansed’ Christians
from their homes, Hindutva militants declared with impunity that they wouldn’t
be allowed back till they re-converted to their ‘parent’ faith, Hinduism. There
were reports of groups of Christians submitting to ritual ‘shuddhi’ ceremonies
organized by these custodians of Hinduism’s integrity, to purge them of
Christianity, that alien contagion.
The main accused in this campaign of carnage and killing was Manoj Pradhan.
Charged with more than a dozen cases of murder and arson, Manoj Pradhan is
currently lodged in jail in G. Udayagiri, a town in Kandhamal. The
not-so-subtle irony is that Pradhan is also the Bharatiya Janata Party’s
official candidate for the G. Udayagiri assembly seat in the approaching
elections. B.B. Ramachandran, the BJP’s leader in the state’s legislative
assembly, offered a familiar defence: “he has been arrested under false
charges. In any case, he is not yet proved guilty in the court of law. Let the
people decide his fate”.
The BJP’s nominee for the newly delimited Kandhamal Lok Sabha seat is a former
IPS officer, Ashok Sahu, currently the state president of the Hindu Jagaran
Samukhya, who is notable for having declared without the inconvenience of
evidence that Christian terrorists had killed Laxmananda Saraswati.
A pogrom is the first step in the Gujarat model. The object of the pogrom is
polarization, specifically the consolidation of a Hindu majority. The third ‘P’
in this grim sequence is political victory at the polls. What we’ve seen in the
last week in Orissa is the BJP’s political establishment explicitly owning this
strategy. The long history of rivalry and tension between the largely Hindu
Kandhas and the largely Christian Panos has been brought to fever pitch by the
violence. Apart from possibly firming up a Hindu vote bloc, the Kandhamal
carnage led to the large-scale dispersal of Christian voters (thousands of whom
never returned to the villages where they’re registered to vote) and the
large-scale loss of identity cards of those who remained in Kandhamal whether
in refugee camps or outside them.
The Catholic archbishop of Cuttack, Raphael Cheenath, even asked for elections
in Kandhamal to be postponed because thousands of people had lost both the
documentation necessary for voting and the belief that they could vote
securely. He pointed out that the government had conducted no survey to
determine how many Christians had been chased out of their neighbourhoods. In
these circumstances, the BJP’s leadership sensed an opportunity. Freed from any
political need for restraint (having been divorced by Navin Patnaik’s Biju
Janata Dal before the polls), it allowed its campaigners to give their
majoritarian instincts full, feral play.
In a circumstance where, just over six months ago, dozens of Christians had
been killed and thousands made homeless, Sushma Swaraj in a recent speech
accused the BJD of not protecting Hindus. Narendra Modi, the pioneer of this
political strategy first tested on the bloodied proving grounds of Gujarat,
told an election rally that “[t]he spirit of Swami Laxmananda will shatter the
dreams of Naveen Patnaik”. But the last word in this matter must be reserved
for Ashok Sahu, the BJP’s Lok Sabha candidate for the Kandhamal seat. He said,
“What happened in Kandhamal is no reason to be ashamed about, at least not for
me. Today Kandhamal symbolizes Hindu culture.”
The reason these contests in Kandhamal are of historic and of national
importance is because they show us the BJP being true to its impulses, its gut
beliefs. Over the last few years (with the exception of Gujarat), the BJP has
been compelled by political and electoral necessity to abide by anodyne
coalition manifestos. Now that the party doesn’t have a tiresomely ‘secular’
partner to alienate in Gujarat, it’s taking the opportunity to be itself.
As Jajati Karan reported on Ibnlive.in.com, Manoj Pradhan had already contested
the assembly elections before, as an independent, and won over 15,000 votes.
The winning figure was 34,000. The calculation is that with the ground-clearing
violence of Kandhamal behind him and the endorsement of a major party, he might
well win the election.
Manoj Pradhan is 30 years old, roughly the same age as the BJP’s Lok Sabha
candidate from Pilibhit …quot; perhaps the best way of understanding him is to
think of him as someone who has walked Varun Gandhi’s talk. There were those
who were surprised by the BJP’s reluctance to distance itself from the young
Gandhi after the Election Commission condemned his hate speech and recommended
that the party not give him a Lok Sabha ticket from Pilibhit. Their surprise
was misplaced: to stand by Varun Gandhi’s Lok Sabha candidacy was no hardship
for a party that was willing to reward Pradhan’s bloodier doings in the cause
of a Hindu rashtra.
In recent times, majoritarian organizations in this country have tried to
expand the domain of permissible violence. The Sri Ram Sena in Karnataka, the
Maharashtra Navnirman Sena in Maharashtra, and the BJP in Orissa and Karnataka
have used thuggish intimidation in the name of a defence of culture. Their
targets have been the vulnerable and the weak: young women, poor north Indian
men and religious minorities. This election is a pointer to the likely
political behaviour of the BJP parties were it to be sprung from the
straitjacket of coalition politics. And should it win the Kandhamal contests,
something ominous shall have been proved.
mukulkesavan@ hotmail.com
Recent Activity
Visit Your Group
Weight Management Group
on Yahoo! Groups
Join the challenge
and lose weight.
Yahoo! Groups
Join people over 40
who are finding ways
to stay in shape.
All-Bran
Day 10 Club
on Yahoo! Groups
Feel better with fiber.
..
__,_._,___
Add more friends to your messenger and enjoy! Go to
http://messenger.yahoo.com/invite/
--~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups
"Green Youth Movement" group.
To post to this group, send email to greenyouth@googlegroups.com
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to
greenyouth+unsubscr...@googlegroups.com
For more options, visit this group at
http://groups.google.com/group/greenyouth?hl=en-GB
-~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---
