For 'Three Responses to Arundhati Roy<http://radicalsocialist.in/index.php/articles/national-situation/164-three-responses-to-arundhati-roy> ': < http://radicalsocialist.in/index.php/articles/national-situation/164-three-responses-to-arundhati-roy >.
The intro: Arundhati Roy is a well-known and powerful writer, associated with the left. As a result, when she lends er name to a cause, many people listen. However, her recent foray, Walking With the Comrades, in Outlook magazine, has serious problems.Aboe all, it reinforces the fraudulent notion that conflicts in India are a one-to-one battle between the state and some corporate groups on one hand and the Communist Party of India (Maoists) on the other. The Maoists would love to have this image deeply engraved. And the state too would like to reduce all conflicts to the monochromatic image of a Kishenji with his face covered. We reproduce below three thoughtful responses to Roy's article. END Sukla On 25 March 2010 15:54, Venugopalan K M <[email protected]> wrote: > > > > http://www.countercurrents.org/roy220310.htm > > "..This legacy of rebellion has left behind a furious people who have been > deliberately isolated and marginalised by the Indian government. The Indian > Constitution, the moral underpinning of Indian democracy, was adopted by > Parliament in 1950. It was a tragic day for tribal people. The Constitution > ratified colonial policy and made the State custodian of tribal homelands. > Overnight, it turned the entire tribal population into squatters on their > own land. It denied them their traditional rights to forest produce, it > criminalised a whole way of life. In exchange for the right to vote, it > snatched away their right to livelihood and dignity. > > Having dispossessed them and pushed them into a downward spiral of > indigence, in a cruel sleight of hand, the government began to use their own > penury against them. Each time it needed to displace a large population—for > dams, irrigation projects, mines—it talked of “bringing tribals into the > mainstream” or of giving them “the fruits of modern development”. Of the > tens of millions of internally displaced people (more than 30 million by big > dams alone), refugees of India’s ‘progress’, the great majority are tribal > people. When the government begins to talk of tribal welfare, it’s time to > worry..." > The most recent expression of concern has come from home minister P. > Chidambaram who says he doesn’t want tribal people living in “museum > cultures”. The well-being of tribal people didn’t seem to be such a priority > during his career as a corporate lawyer, representing the interests of > several major mining companies. So it might be an idea to enquire into the > basis for his new anxiety. > > "....An article on the internet says that Israel’s Mossad is training 30 > high-ranking Indian police officers in the techniques of targeted > assassinations, to render the Maoist organisation “headless”. There’s talk > in the press about the new hardware that has been bought from Israel: laser > range-finders, thermal imaging equipment and unmanned drones, so popular > with the US army. Perfect weapons to use against the poor.." > > "..On the outskirts of Raipur, a massive billboard advertises Vedanta (the > company our home minister once worked with) Cancer Hospital. In Orissa, > where it is mining bauxite, Vedanta is financing a university. In these > creeping, innocuous ways, mining corporations enter our imaginations: the > Gentle Giants Who Really Care. It’s called CSR, Corporate Social > Responsibility. It allows mining companies to be like the legendary actor > and former chief minister NTR, who liked to play all the parts in Telugu > mythologicals—the good guys and the bad guys, all at once, in the same > movie. This CSR masks the outrageous economics that underpins the mining > sector in India. For example, according to the recent Lokayukta report for > Karnataka, for every tonne of iron ore mined by a private company, the > government gets a royalty of Rs 27 and the mining company makes Rs 5,000. In > the bauxite and aluminium sector, the figures are even worse. We’re talking > about daylight robbery to the tune of billions of dollars. Enough to buy > elections, governments, judges, newspapers, TV channels, NGOs and aid > agencies. What’s the occasional cancer hospital here or there?.." > > "..Why must they die? What for? To turn all of this into a mine? I remember > my visit to the open cast iron-ore mines in Keonjhar, Orissa. There was > forest there once. And children like these. Now the land is like a raw, red > wound. Red dust fills your nostrils and lungs. The water is red, the air is > red, the people are red, their lungs and hair are red. All day and all night > trucks rumble through their villages, bumper to bumper, thousands and > thousands of trucks, taking ore to Paradip port from where it will go to > China. There it will turn into cars and smoke and sudden cities that spring > up overnight. Into a ‘growth rate’ that leaves economists breathless. Into > weapons to make war." > > "...The perennial problem, the real bane of people’s lives, was the biggest > landlord of all, the Forest Department. Every morning, forest officials, > even the most junior of them, would appear in villages like a bad dream, > preventing people from ploughing their fields, collecting firewood, plucking > leaves, picking fruit, grazing their cattle, from *living*. They brought > elephants to overrun fields and scattered babool seeds to destroy the soil > as they passed by. People would be beaten, arrested, humiliated, their crops > destroyed. Of course, from the forest department’s point of view, these were > illegal people engaged in unconstitutional activity, and the department was > only implementing the Rule of Law. (Their sexual exploitation of women was > just an added perk in a hardship posting.) > > Emboldened by the people’s participation in these struggles, the party > decided to confront the forest department. It encouraged people to take over > forest land and cultivate it. The forest department retaliated by burning > new villages that came up in forest areas. In 1986, it announced a National > Park in Bijapur, which meant the eviction of 60 villages. More than half of > them had already been moved out, and construction of national park > infrastructure had begun when the party moved in. It demolished the > construction and stopped the eviction of the remaining villages. It > prevented the forest department from entering the area. On a few occasions, > officials were captured, tied to trees and beaten by villagers. It was > cathartic revenge for generations of exploitation. Eventually, the forest > department fled. Between 1986 and 2000, the party redistributed 3,00,000 > acres of forest land. Today, Comrade Venu says, there are no landless > peasants in Dandakaranya. > > For today’s generation of young people, the forest department is a distant > memory, the stuff of stories mothers tell their children, about a > mythological past of bondage and humiliation. For the older generation, > freedom from the forest department meant genuine freedom. They could touch > it, taste it. It meant far more than India’s Independence ever did. They > began to rally to the party that had struggled with them. > > The seven-squad team had come a long way. Its influence now ranged across a > 60,000 sq km stretch of forest, thousands of villages and millions of > people. > > But the departure of the forest department heralded the arrival of the > police. That set off a cycle of bloodshed. Fake ‘encounters’ by the police, > ambushes by the PWG. With the redistribution of land came other > responsibilities: irrigation, agricultural productivity and the problem of > an expanding population arbitrarily clearing forest land. A decision was > taken to separate ‘mass work’ and ‘military work’. > > Today, Dandakaranya is administered by an elaborate structure of Janatana > Sarkars (people’s governments). The organising principles came from the > Chinese revolution and the Vietnam war. Each Janatana Sarkar is elected by a > cluster of villages whose combined population can range from 500 to 5,000. > It has nine departments: Krishi (agriculture), Vyapar-Udyog (trade and > industry) Arthik (economic), Nyay (justice), Raksha (defence), Hospital > (health), Jan Sampark (public relations), School-Riti Rivaj (education and > culture), and Jungle. A group of Janatana Sarkars come under an Area > Committee. Three area committees make up a Division. There are 10 divisions > in Dandakaranya. > > “We have a Save the Jungle department now,” Comrade Venu says. “You must > have read the government report that says forest has increased in Naxal > areas?” > A poem and a pressed flower from Comrade Narmada. A lovely letter from > Maase. (Who is she? Will I ever know?) > > Comrade Sukhdev asks if he can download the music from my Ipod onto his > computer. We listen to a recording of Iqbal Bano singing Faiz Ahmad Faiz’s > Hum Dekhenge (We will Witness the Day) at the famous concert in Lahore at > the height of the repression during the Zia-ul-Haq years. > > Jab ahl-e-safa-Mardud-e-haram, > Masnad pe bithaiye jayenge > > (When the heretics and the reviled will be seated on high) > > Sab taaj uchhale jayenge > Sab takht giraye jayenge > > (All crowns will be snatched away > All thrones toppled) > > Hum dekhenge > > Fifty thousand people in the audience in that Pakistan begin a defiant > chant: Inqilab Zindabad! Inqilab Zindabad! All these years later, that chant > reverberates around this forest. Strange, the alliances that get made..." > > "...The home minister’s been issuing veiled threats to those who > “erroneously offer intellectual and material support to Maoists”. Does > sharing music qualify? > > At dawn, I say goodbye to Comrade Madhav and Joori, to young Mangtu and all > the others. Comrade Chandu has gone to organise the bikes, and will come > with me to the main road. Comrade Raju isn’t coming (the climb would be hell > on his knees). Comrade Niti (Most Wanted), Comrade Sukhdev, Kamla and five > others will take me up the hill. As we start walking, Niti and Sukhdev > casually but simultaneously unclick the safety catches of their AKs. It’s > the first time I’ve seen them do that. We’re approaching the ‘Border’. “Do > you know what to do if we come under fire?” Sukhdev asks casually, as though > it was the most natural thing in the world. > > “Yes,” I said, “immediately declare an indefinite hunger strike.” > > He sat down on a rock and laughed. We climbed for about an hour. Just below > the road, we sat in a rocky alcove, completely concealed, like an ambush > party, listening for the sound of the bikes. When it comes, the farewell > must be quick. Lal Salaam Comrades. > > When I looked back, they were still there. Waving. A little knot. People > who live with their dreams, while the rest of the world lives with its > nightmares. Every night I think of this journey. That night sky, those > forest paths. I see Comrade Kamla’s heels in her scuffed chappals, lit by > the light of my torch. I know she must be on the move. Marching, not just > for herself, but to keep hope alive for us all. > > > You cannot build anything on the foundations of caste. You cannot build up > a nation, you cannot build up a morality. Anything that you will build on > the foundations of caste will crack and will never be a whole. > -AMBEDKAR > > > > http://venukm.blogspot.com > > http://www.shelfari.com/kmvenuannur > > http://kmvenuannur.livejournal.com > > > > > -- > > > You cannot build anything on the foundations of caste. You cannot build up > a nation, you cannot build up a morality. Anything that you will build on > the foundations of caste will crack and will never be a whole. > -AMBEDKAR > > > > http://venukm.blogspot.com > > http://www.shelfari.com/kmvenuannur > > http://kmvenuannur.livejournal.com > > -- > You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups > "Green Youth Movement" group. > To post to this group, send an email to [email protected]. > To unsubscribe from this group, send email to > [email protected]<greenyouth%[email protected]> > . > For more options, visit this group at > http://groups.google.com/group/greenyouth?hl=en-GB. > -- Peace Is Doable -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "Green Youth Movement" group. To post to this group, send an email to [email protected]. To unsubscribe from this group, send email to [email protected]. For more options, visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/greenyouth?hl=en-GB.
