http://pulsemedia.org/2014/04/25/raging-with-the-machine-robert-fisk-seymour-hersh-and-syria/
Raging with the Machine: Robert Fisk, Seymour Hersh and Syria April 25, 2014 ยง Leave a comment<http://pulsemedia.org/2014/04/25/raging-with-the-machine-robert-fisk-seymour-hersh-and-syria/#respond> *Yassin al-Haj Saleh is a Syrian writer who spent 16 years in the regime's prisons <http://pulsemedia.org/2010/07/04/journey-into-memory/>. In this exclusive for PULSE, Saleh, who has been described as the "conscience of Syria <https://www.bostonreview.net/world/postel-hashemi-interview-syrian-activist-intellectual-yassin-al-haj-saleh>", discusses the distorted lens through which most people are viewing the conflict.* In the West, Robert Fisk and Seymour Hersh are considered critical journalists. They occupy dissident positions in the English-speaking press. Among Syrians, however, they are viewed very differently. The problem with their writings on Syria is that it is deeply centered on the West. The purported focus of their analysis - Syria, its people and the current conflict - serves only as backdrop to their commentary where ordinary Syrians are often invisible. For Fisk and Hersh the struggle in Syria is about ancient sects engaged in primordial battle. What really matters for them are the geopolitics of the conflict, specifically where the US fits into this picture. On the topic of chemical weapons, Fisk and Hersh, completely ignore the antecedents of last summer's attack on Ghouta . A reader who relies exclusively on Fisk/Hersh for their understanding of Syria would never know that the Assad regime had used chemical weapons several times before the August 21, 2013 massacre in Ghouta. I was there at the time. I saw victims of sarin gas on two occasions in Eastern Ghouta and I met doctors treating them. The victims were from Jobar, which was hit with chemical weaponsin April 2013<http://therepublicgs.net/2013/04/30/injuries-by-chemical-weapons-in-eastern-ghuta/> and from Harasta, which was hit in May 2013<http://www.vdc-sy.info/index.php/en/reports/chemicaljobar#.U1AUMPldWSp> . It is shocking that investigative journalists such as Fisk and Hersh know nothing about these attacks. They write as if Ghouta was the first time chemical weapons were used in Syria. Their credibility and objectivity is compromised by these omissions. For these renowned commentators, all Middle East is reducible to geopolitical intrigue. There are no people; there is only the White House, the CIA, the British Government, Recep Tayyib Erdogan, the Emir of Qatar, the Iranian regime and of course Bashar Assad and the jihadis. In Fisk's myriad articles, one rarely reads about ordinary Syrians (the observation also applies to the late Patrick Seale). Robert Fisk was once a scourge of American reporters embedding with US forces during the 2003 invasion of Iraq. But he saw no irony in himself embedding<http://www.independent.co.uk/voices/commentators/fisk/robert-fisk-inside-daraya--how-a-failed-prisoner-swap-turned-into-a-massacre-8084727.html> with Syria regime forces as they entered Daraya in August 2012. More than 500 people were killed in a massacre at that time (245 according to Fisk). Who killed them? The rebels, determined Fisk based solely on interviews with regime detainees. Why should local fighters kill hundreds from their own community? Robert Fisk does not provide an answer. Had he spoken to a single citizen without his minders present, he would have learened that they had no doubts about the regime's responsibility. Indeed, it was an American journalist, Janine di Giovanni, who established that fact shortly thereafter<http://www.theguardian.com/world/2012/sep/07/syria-daraya-massacre-ghost-town> by visiting Daraya on her own. At the same time when this was happening Human Rights Watch<http://www.hrw.org/news/2012/08/30/syria-government-attacking-bread-lines> documented ten attacks on bread queues around Aleppo. Fisk did not mention a single one. During this time Fisk visited a security center in Damascus where he was welcomed by a security official. He was given access to four jihadi fighters, two Syrians and two foreigners. Fisk made a point of mentioning that the prisoners were allowed family visits. As someone who spent 16 years in Assad's jails and who has firsthand knowledge of these factories of death, I find this claim high improbable. Fisk's credulity is risible; he is assisting a shameful attempt to beautify the ugly polices of the House of Assad. Why has Robert Fisk never attempted to contact people of Eastern Ghouta to ask them what happened there last August? It would have been easy for a person as well-connected as he to convince his friends in the regime, such as Assad's media adviser Buthaina Shaaban, to facilitate his entrance to the besieged town. He could have met ordinary people for a change with the intimidating presence of regime minders and found out for himself who used the chemical weapons that killed 1466 people, including more than 400 children. Ignoring local sources of information on the conflict in Syria seems to be a standard practice among many in the West, especially among leftwing and liberal commentators. This speaks volumes about their ideological bias. Their dogmatic self-assurance with its veneer of professionalism is not substantively different than the obscurantist self-righteousness of the jihadis. The Hersh/Fisk narrative unfolds in a historical vacuum: it tells you nothing about the history and character of the regime. You will not learn that the regime has used collective punishment as a policy since the very beginning of the Syrian revolt. That it has used fighter jets, barrel bombs and scud missiles against civilians to cow them; that it has invited foreigners from Lebanon, Iran, Iraq, and other countries to assist in the slaughter. Nor will you learn about a flourishing death industry in the very places to which Fisk is a welcome visitor. Three months ago he penned an article about Assad's systematic killing of the detainees in his dungeons, but Fisk reported on this topic in a way that gives us a biopsy of his professional conscience. Fisk prefaces his report on the regime's atrocities by warning readers about the horrors that may soon exist "if the insurrection against Bashar al-Assad succeeds." For most the significant fact about the photos was the industrial scale killings inside Assad's jails that they evidenced. But Fisk appeared more obsessed with the timing of the photos as they were appearing a day before the Geneva 2 Conference. Fisk may have been reminded of Nazi Germany by the horrific fate of the 11,000 prisoners, But he still found occasion to expatiate at length about Qatar, whose "royal family viscerally hates Bashar al-Assad", for funding the investigation. For Fisk, the atrocities were a mere detail in a larger conspiracy whose real victim was Assad's regime. To the uninitiated, Fisk's article might convey the impression that those 11,000 were all that were killed by Assad's regime and the 20,000 killed in Hama in 1982 were all that that were killed by his father's. The actual number of victims is eleven times as many for Assad and twice as many for his father. Moreover, these figures ignore the tens of thousands arrested, tortured, and jailed, and the millions who have been humiliated by this regime By methodically ignoring the Syrian people and by focusing on Al Qaeda, Robert Fisk and Seymour Hersh have done us all a huge disservice. The perspective on Syria portrayed by these writers is exactly the view of Syria that Basher Assad wants to rest of the world to see. - *Yassin al-Haj Saleh* (born in Raqqa in 1961) is one of Syria's most prominent political dissidents. In 1980, when he was studying medicine in Aleppo, he was imprisoned for his membership in a pro-democracy group and remained behind bars until 1996. He writes on political, social and cultural subjects relating to Syria and the Arab world for several Arab newspapers and journals outside of Syria, and regularly contributes to the London-based *Al-Hayat* newspaper, the Egyptian leftist magazine* Al-Bosla*, and the Syrian online periodical The Republic <http://therepublicgs.net/>. Among Saleh's books (all in Arabic) are S*yria in the Shadow: Glimpses Inside the Black Box *(2009), *Walking on One Foot* (2011), a collection of 52 essays written between 2006 and 2010, *Salvation O Boys: 16 Years in Syrian Prisons *(2012), *The Myths of the Others: A Critique of Contemporary Islam and a Critique of the Critique* (2012), and* Deliverance or Destruction? Syria at a Crossroads <http://www.cihrs.org/?p=8177&lang=en> *(2014). In 2012 he was granted the Prince Claus Award as "a tribute to the Syrian people and the Syrian revolution". He was not able to collect the award, as he was living in hiding in the underground in Damascus. -- Peace Is Doable -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "Green Youth Movement" group. To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to [email protected]. To post to this group, send an email to [email protected]. Visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/greenyouth. For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout.
